Leadership
Christ has given his church pastors and deacons to care for his people. Our pastors know, feed, lead, and protect the flock; our deacons serve in practical ways so the church can flourish.

Pastors

Andy Naselli
Lead Pastor
Married to Jenni since 2004 and father of four daughters. He holds two PhDs, served nine years as research manager for D. A. Carson, and teaches systematic theology and New Testament at Bethlehem College & Seminary.

Tom Dodds
Pastor
Married to Abigail since 2002 and father of five. A non-staff pastor since 2015, he founded and leads a technology services company and advises Christian business owners on leadership that glorifies God.

Dustin Williams
Pastor
Married to Maria since 2006 and father of four. He holds an MA in Biblical Counseling and is ACBC-certified. Born, married, and now serving in Stillwater, he loves teaching God's covenant faithfulness.

Nathan Colestock
Executive Pastor
Married to Maddie since 2017 and father of four. He earned his MDiv from Bethlehem College & Seminary and serves part-time as Head of School at Valor Classical Academy, longing to see Stillwater honor Christ.
Deacons

Andrew Wittenburg
Deacon for A/V
Married to Adelyn since 2023. He works in technology while pursuing an MA in Exegesis & Theology, and oversees audio/visual — setup, sound, recording, and live stream — so God's word is clearly heard.

Brad Brosius
Deacon for Safety & Security
Married to MariJo since 2011 and father of three. He leads a team of engineers for a defense contractor and directs the team that responds to needs and keeps the saints' worship safe.
Want to connect with a pastor?
Whether you're new to Stillwater or exploring the faith, we'd love to meet you.