Listen on

Recognize That Wine Is More Fitting Than Nonalcoholic Juice for the Lord’s Supper

Transcript

Transcript

0:03 Brothers and sisters, I exhort you to recognize that wine is more fitting than non-alcoholic juice for the Lord's supper. And you're thinking, "This is the exhortation. This is an unusual exhortation." So, I'm planning to preach a series of sermons on the Lord's Supper later this year, God willing. and my fellow pastors think it would be helpful for me to address this particular issue now rather than wait to the second half of this year. And this exhortation is unusual not just because of the content uh but also because it's not going to be as short and zippy. So it'll be a little bit longer. And there are notes where the sermon outline notes normally go in your worship service guide. So if you'd

0:47 like to follow along there, you can follow. So, I'm going to start with five reasons that wine is more fitting than juice for the Lord's supper. Reason one, Matthew 26, excuse me, here is reason one. Wine is what Jesus used when he first instituted the Lord's supper. So, listen to Matthew 26 27-29. When Jesus instituted the Lord's supper, quote, he took a cup and when he had given thanks, he gave it to them saying, "Drink of it all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins. I tell you, I will not drink of what's the phrase? This fruit of the vine." I'm going to come back to that. I

1:34 will not drink again of this fruit of the vine until that day when I drink it new with you in my father's kingdom. So when Jesus is referring to the liquid in the cup, so sometimes the Bible refers to just the cup. But when we the liquid in the cup, he calls the fruit of the vine. Here's what Pastor Jeff Meyers says about that phrase, and I agree with him. He says, "The phrase the fruit of the vine is merely a poetic way of describing wine." This equivalence is firmly and unquestionably established in the literature of the times. The Jews never used mere grape juice in their Passover cups. Moreover, the phrase the fruit of the vine became for the Jews a technical description of alcoholic wine

2:18 when it was used in sacred ceremonies like the Passover. So that's reason one. Reason two, wine is what the early church used when they participated in the Lord's supper. And I can prove this to you. So the early church copied what Jesus instituted. 1 Corinthians 11 tells us that. And in in that passage when Paul rebukes the Corinthians for how they participated in the Lord's supper, here's his rebuke. In eating, each one goes ahead with his own meal. One goes hungry, another gets drunk. It's very hard to get drunk on non-alcoholic grape juice.

2:56 That's an understatement. So, you can't do that. The early church clearly used wine for the Lord's supper. That's reason two. Here's reason three. For the vast majority of the church's history, wine is what the church has used when they participated in the Lord's supper. So the Christian church has universally used wine for the Lord's supper until do you know when that changed? I had to do some historical learning here. About the second half of the 1800s is when this changed. So let me tell you about why that happened. Um, everybody was using fermented juice that was alcoholic. The switch happened most notably in America and it coincided with the temperance movement.

3:40 So, some Christians adopted the view that drinking alcohol is sinful. And here's the part I didn't know. In 1869, a man named Thomas Bramwell Welch, maybe you've heard that name before, Welch, invented what we now call Welch's grape juice. Mr. Welch invented grape juice that doesn't ferment. Mr. Welch invented this beverage so that his church could use non-alcoholic grape juice in the Lord's supper. And then he marketed his invention primarily to churches.

4:14 I didn't know this. So by the late 1800s, more and more churches used unfermented grape juice in the Lord's supper. By 1920, after national prohibition in America, most Protestant churches here used non-alcoholic grape juice in the Lord's supper. So using non-alcoholic grape juice in the Lord's supper is relatively new in the history of the church. For the vast majority of church history, all Christians used wine. That's reason three. Reason four, wine is more fitting than juice to symbolize the joy we share as we remember that Jesus triumphed over sin, death, and Satan in his crosswork. So, wine is more fitting for a joyful feast to relax and make merry together. So,

5:01 the scriptures talk about wine and joy together. We've sung some psalms about this. I'll quote two of them to you. Psalm 4:7, "You have put more joy in my heart than they have when their grain and wine abound." And here's another. Psalm 104. You caused the grass to grow for the livestock and plants for man to cultivate that he may bring forth food from the earth and wine to do what? To gladden the heart of man. That's reason four. And then reason five, which I need at least 20 minutes to unpack. I'm just going to give it to you. MelkiseDC brought out bread and wine and Jesus is our high our high priest in the pattern of Melkisedc.

5:46 Genesis 14 tells us about Melkisedc. Verse 18 says he brought out bread and wine. And it's no coincidence that bread and wine symbolize the broken body of Jesus the new and greater MelkiseDC. I think this is an example of picture prophecy that is typology that God intended all along. I don't have more time to say more about MelkiseDC now, so I'm going to move on. Those are five reasons I believe that wine is more fitting than juice when we participate in the Lord's supper together. So, you might be wondering, well, then why do we offer juice? Why isn't it wine only? So, I'm I'm encouraging you. My exhortation is drink wine when we participate in the Lord's supper.

6:31 But there's a there's a big however here. So, here's the here's the butt. The pastors of our church do not require you to drink wine. We include this note in our worship service guide. The inner eight cups in the tray are juice. The rest are wine. And why do we do that? At least four reasons. Reason one is for adults. Some adults may have a conviction against ever drinking alcohol. I respect that conviction. But I think that those with a stronger conscience, which means a conscience that is more theologically informed, that's theologically correct, those with a stronger conscience don't hold that conviction. God gives us all foods and drinks to enjoy. So we can receive

7:17 alcohol to the glory of God as long as we receive his gift with thankfulness and we use it as he intended, which means never get drunk. That's off limits at all times. So I can imagine the scenario. Imagine a man who earlier in his life was enslaved to the sin of drunkenness and then God gloriously saves him, delivers him from that captivity and that man may vow never to put a drop of alcohol to his lips lest he be tempted to go back down that path of destruction and get drunk. So we include the option of juice for a man like that. Though I think it would be even better if such a man not only never got drunk again, but also recognized the goodness of God in what he's created and

8:03 could drink a small mouthful of wine at the Lord's supper. That's reason one. Reason two is for pregnant women. Some pregnant women may strongly prefer not to drink even a drop of alcohol. Now, I'm not a medical doctor, but it seems to me like common sense that a small sip of alcohol once a week is fine. So, pregnant women have been celebrating the Lord's supper like that for 2,000 years. But if a pregnant woman is convinced that drinking even a small sip of alcohol is dangerous, she has the option to drink juice. Reason three is for parents. Some parents may strongly prefer that their children not even taste alcohol.

8:51 So that decision is up to the parents. And I'd say if you're a parent with that conviction, may I offer some friendly push back for you to consider? uh if your child in the future were to become enslaved to the sin of drunkenness, the reason for that would not be that our church serves wine for the Lord's supper. It would be even better, I think, to teach your children that God created wine, that wine is more fitting than non-alcoholic juice for the reasons I've already shared with you. And then finally is reason four, which I think is probably the most compelling of the four reasons, is for children. Some children may find the taste of alcohol so disgusting that drinking it for the

9:39 Lord's supper would turn what is supposed to be joyful into a dread. I have one daughter like that. So we don't force the children of our church to drink the wine. So children, if you're a member of our church and you participate in the Lord's supper, what should you do here? You should do what your parents tell you to do. If they encourage you to drink wine, drink wine. If they encourage you to drink juice, drink juice. So those are my exhortations. Children, listen to your parents about whether to drink wine or the juice. Adults, I encourage you, don't require you, I encourage you to drink wine when you participate in the Lord's Supper. And for everyone, I exhort you to recognize that wine is

10:26 more fitting than non-alcoholic juice for the Lord's supper.

No transcript available.