Listen on

Sing: Part 1 of 3

Transcript

Congregational Worship

01

Should a Church Sing Imprecatory Psalms?

Andy Naselli

Aug 16, 2026
01

Sing: Part 2 of 3

Andy Naselli

Aug 2, 2026
01

Sing: Part 1 of 3

Andy Naselli

Jul 26, 2026
01

Pray and Give

Andy Naselli

Jul 5, 2026
01

Read God’s Words, and Teach and Preach God’s Words

Andy Naselli

Jun 21, 2026
01

How Does Our Church Structure a Worship Service?

Andy Naselli

Jun 14, 2026
01

Why Is the Corporate Worship Service So Important?

Andy Naselli

May 17, 2026

Transcript

0:04 Let's pray together. Father, as we consider how our church should worship you, would you please help us to worship you empowered by your spirit and in accordance with the truth? We ask in the name of Jesus. Amen. Please open your Bible to Ephesians 5:18. Ephesians 5:18. We'll look at that passage in just a moment. So, I'm preaching a series on congregational worship. And in the previous sermons, I explained four of the seven elements that scripture warrants in a church's worship service.

0:42 Read God's words, teach and preach God's words, pray, and give. In this sermon, I plan to consider one more element. That's sing. And then in future sermons, I plan to consider the final two. Baptize believers and participate in the Lord's supper. So in this sermon, I would like to preach to you on this subject. Sing. Sing. Now I'll begin very briefly by reviewing some aspects of congregational worship. So a church should worship God only in the way he tells us to worship him. In other words, scripture regulates what a church should do. Our worship must be according to scripture.

1:27 Scripture must warrant everything we do in a church's worship service. Some theologians helpfully distinguish between elements of worship, forms of worship, and circumstances of worship. Elements of worship are the activities that God commands us to do when we gather. Those are the seven elements I just mentioned. read God's words, teach and preach God's words, pray, give, sing, baptize believers, participate in the Lord's supper.

1:54 Forms of worship are wisdom calls about how we carry out the elements of worship. So, we're obeying God's commands, and we need to use wisdom to obey them. So, when we read God's words, which translation do we use? When we give, do we pass around an offering basket? Those are decisions about forms of worship. They require us to use wisdom as we obey God's commands. Circumstances of worship are practical decisions common to any human gathering.

2:20 They're not unique to a worship service. Like when it's 96° on a summer day, should we run the air conditioning? Yes. Yes. So, I don't plan to say much in this sermon series about circumstances of worship. I plan to focus on the elements and then say something about some of our forms of worship in this particular sermon on singing. I plan to answer some clarifying questions about singing and most of these questions are about forms of singing. That is wisdom calls about how we obey God's command to sing. So let's begin with question one.

3:01 And if you want to follow along the outline is in the worship service guide. So question one is about singing psalms. Why do we sing psalms? Now in my next two sermons on singing, I plan to expand on my answer to this question by answering two specific questions. So next sermon will be why should a church continually sing the psalms? And then the sermon after that is should a church sing impregatory psalms? So a whole sermon on that. But here I'll just answer the simple question. Why do we sing psalms? The main reason is that God tells us to sing psalms. Your Bibles open Ephesians 5 or you can look on the screen. Ephesians 5:18 and 20 begins with the command, "Be filled with the

3:44 spirit." And then God specifies what results from being filled by the spirit, addressing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody to the Lord with your heart, giving thanks always and for everything to God the Father in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ. And then in a parallel passage in Colossians 3:16, Paul commands, "Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly." And then God specifies what results from that?

4:15 Singing what? Psalms and hymns and spiritual songs with thanksgiving in your hearts to God. So when many people read those two passages today, they see those three terms, psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs, and they often assume the following. Psalms refer to psalms from the Old Testament book of psalms. So there are 150 psalms. Hymns refer to formal songs that a church sings during worship like how great thou art, holy, holy, holy, it is well, great is thy faithfulness. And then spiritual songs refer to praise choruses or more contemporary praise songs.

5:03 >> But I want to ask, is that what Paul intends when he writes those words, psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs. So those three terms translate three Greek words and each of those Greek words appear in the title to psalms in the [snorts] Septigen. The Septigen is the Greek translation of the Old Testament. So in that sense psalms, hymns and spiritual songs is like saying psalms and more psalms and other kinds of psalms. So uh further the new testament uses these these three terms translated here psalms, hymns and spiritual songs.

5:44 It uses those words interchangeably. The words are synonyms. So here's what I conclude from that. When Paul uses those three Greek words translated songs, hymns and spiritual songs, he is not sharply distinguishing three distinct types of congregational songs. I also conclude this at minimum minimum the church should sing psalms. I don't conclude that the church should sing only psalms. I'll say more about that in a moment. But it's puzzling to me that the one type of song that God tells us to sing is what most evangelical churches today hardly ever sing. God tells us to sing psalms. So we should sing psalms. And I also conclude this.

6:27 If our church intentionally chose not to sing psalms, then we would be choosing to disobey God. Singing psalms is a good litmus test for whether a church is committed to worship God the way he tells us to worship him. So that's question one, why do we sing psalms? The main reason is that God tells us to sing psalms. And question two is about paraphrased psalms. Does singing paraphrased psalms count as singing psalms?

7:02 So sometimes we sing a psalm exactly as it appears in a modern English translation. But usually we don't. When we sing a psalm, we usually sing what's called a metrical psalm. Have you heard that term metrical psalm? So a metrical psalm rearranges a psalm to fit a rhyming beat or meter. That's where the word comes from following a meter. A metrical psalm is a rhymed poetic paraphrase of a psalm. So some poets arrange metrical psalms with very awkward English.

7:36 So I was teasing my kids this week. Even one song we sang today. It sounds like you had a uh uh where so uh how's it go? Uh our God our refuge is and strength. Our God our refuge is okay. So that's a little awkward in English, but some metrical psalms are really well done. So, an an excellent metrical psalm faithfully communicates the message of that psalm. And someone might object. I've had some friends subject this way to me. Well, we wouldn't call a paraphrase of Psalm 1 an actual psalm if we were reading it or preaching it. So, why should we sing uh why should singing a metrical psalm count as singing a psalm? That's a good question. So, some reformed Christians argue that when we

8:22 sing psalms, we must sing the very words of the psalms without rearranging them or paraphrasing them to rhyme. Uh, and so some will argue that we should chant the psalms. Have you heard of people who chant psalms? Interesting. Uh, so this is a minority view that most reformed churches reject. And here's why. God wrote 150 psalms in Hebrew for his people to sing, not merely to read. It's a hymnbook. The New Testament doesn't require us to sing the original Hebrew wording or even a woodenly formbbased translation. The New Testament highly prioritizes that our worship be edifying.

9:05 So it follows that a church should use the inspired psalms in a way that edifies the body, teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom. And that is what excellent faithful metrical psalms do. A metrical psalm that's excellent conveys the content, theology, imagery, message of the inspired psalm in a form that a congregation can actually sing together with understanding and with a fitting affection. So an excellent metrical psalm is different from an arbitrary or loose paraphrase of a psalm. Good metrical psalms faithfully communicate what the psalms mean. Just like a good Bible translation does when it rearranges syntax for read

9:53 readability in the target language. An excellent metrical psalm faithfully communicates a psalm's message and makes it singable. So does singing paraphrase psalms count as singing psalms? Yes. Many psalms are difficult to sing in English without rearranging them to fit a rhyming beat or meter. And you might be wondering, are are we novel in taking this view? Are we unusual? And I want to share with you that John Calvin recognized what I'm saying. Calvin, of course, held a high view of scripture. And he helped oversee what we call the Genevan psalter.

10:31 Have you heard that word, psalter? So, a psalter is a collection of psalms that a church uses for congregational worship. It it sets metrical psalms to memorable tunes. Calvin collected metrical psalms so that the whole church could sing the psalms. He argued that to sing psalms, we don't have to sing the original Hebrew or the precise translation of a psalm. Calvin argued that Christians should sing metrical psalms. And it's not just Calvin. Singing metrical psalms has been the standard for most reformed churches.

11:07 This is evident by just looking at psalters. So you can buy psalters. They're copies of the biblical psalms for congregational singing. Many psalters collect metrical psalms for churches to sing together. And this includes the Genevan psalter, the Scottish psalter, the Dutch psalter, many English psalters. So most reformed Christians have regarded such metrical psalms to count as singing psalms and worship services. Here's an example. The Westminster Assembly oversaw an English metrical psalter. So the Westminster Assembly refers to the the the group of men who wrote the Westminster Confession and the larger and shorter catechisms.

11:46 The Westminster Assembly in the in the Westminster Confession of Faith 21.5 refers to singing those metrical psalms as quote singing of psalms. That's the view they take. So here's an example of the first line of a metrical psalm from our himnil, the treasury of psalms and hymns. So you can see the the first line is a paraphrase of verse one. The king of love, my shepherd is and it goes on whose goodness fails never. I nothing lack if I am his and he is mine forever.

12:16 And what I like about what our himnil does is it puts a little subscript number that corresponds to the verse number it's paraphrasing. So you see it there, there's a two. You don't see the three because it comes later in the in the in the next line, but you also see four, five, and six there. That's that's an excellent way as you're studying a psalm to compare its words to the translation you're looking at and see how close they are.

12:42 Um, wonderful feature. So, does singing a paraphrase psalm count as singing a psalm? Yes. Many psalms are difficult to sing in English without rearranging them to fit a rhyming beat or meter. Question three is about exclusive psalmate. Why don't we sing only psalms? So some Christians argue that in a church's worship service, the church should sing only psalms and nothing else. The only songs that we see sing should be psalms. And this position is called exclusive psalmity.

13:23 Our church does not hold this position for at least two reasons. First, God does not require the church to sing only psalms. Now, the question still remains whether it's permissible and fitting to sing anything else. But I'm simply observing here in this first reason that scripture nowhere commands something like this. Sing psalms and only psalms. And then the second reason is that singing some songs outside the book of psalms is fitting. So, let me give you some reasons it may be fitting to sing a song that's not part of the book of Psalms. Here's one. There are songs in the Bible that are not part of the book of Psalms. And it's fitting to sing those God breathed songs. Here's a

14:10 sampling. These are songs in the Bible, but they're not in the book of Psalms. The song of Moses and Miriam after God delivered his people from the Egyptians after they passed through the Red Sea. That's Exodus 15. The song of the well after the Lord provided water for Israel in the wilderness. Numbers 21. The second song of Moses. Deuteronomy 32. The song of Deborah and Bareric after God defeated Cicora and the Canaanites. Judges 5.

14:38 Hannah's song-like prayer. 1st Samuel 2, which is a model for Mary's Magnificat. Isaiah's songs about the vineyard of Israel being destroyed and restored. That's Isaiah 5 and 27. Hezekiah's song of thanksgiving after God healed him in Isaiah 38. The entire book of Lamentations consists of five songs that mourn the fall of Jerusalem. Lamentations is a song. Habach's song-like prayer in Habach 3, which the very text of Habach in verse 1 and 19 signals is a text that God's people should sing.

15:12 The song of Mary the Magnificat in Luke 1. The song of the angels in Luke 2. Glory to God in the highest and on earth peace among those with whom he's pleased. And then there's several songs in the book of Revelation. I I find these the most compelling argument for why it's permissible to sing songs outside the book of Psalms. The the song of the four living creatures and the 24 elders in Revelation 59 and 10. The song of the thousands and thousands around the throne in in Revelation 5:12 singing worthy is a lamb who was slain to receive power and wealth and wisdom and might and honor and glory and blessing.

15:46 And there's a song of Moses, the song of the lamb in Revelation 15. Those songs in the book of Revelation are compelling evidence because those are songs that God's people are singing in his presence right now. So the exclusive psalm view would not allow us to sing those. Here's another reason. David composed those songs. Excuse me. David composed songs that are not part of the book of Psalms and it's fitting to sing those songs. So David of course is the most prolific author of the Psalms and he composed songs that don't appear in the book of Psalms but they do appear elsewhere in the Bible in 2 Samuel three songs in particular 2 Samuel 1:22 and 23 and his song in 2

16:29 Samuel 22 is almost identical to Psalm 18. So it seems fitting that God's people continue to compose and sing new songs. Another argument, most of the church over the past 2,000 years has not sung only psalms, and it seems fitting to continue that practice. I just want to say this, this argument about this practice in church history is not decisive. It doesn't prove that the church may sing songs outside the book of Psalms, but it should give us pause before we break away from what most of God's people have traditionally sung in congregational worship. Another reason most of the psalms are prayers and it's fitting for us to pray to God with words that we have composed and not

17:15 exclusively with words from scripture. It's fitting for us to intercede to God to adore God in our prayers. And if it's fitting to speak such prayers, it's also fitting to sing such prayers. Think of a a hymn like Holy, Holy, Holy. It's not God breathed, but it's an excellent prayer that we can sing to God. And then final reason, the same type of reasoning that holds to exclusive psalm would also forbid singing paraphrases of psalms.

17:50 So the only option would be to sing or chant the psalms exactly as they appear in English translations. So here's how Doug Wilson argues. The exclusive psalmist has to make a case which can then be used against his own practice because most exclusive psalmists sing metrical psalms. Psalms put to meter in English in order to fit a modern tune are at best a paraphrase of the psalms. The singing of the first seven verses of a psalm in four-part harmony is not what David did and not what the Colossians did. Nevertheless, because such compositions are anchored to the text, they are far better than something composed by a ruthless evangelical wandering around in his emotions. If the

18:33 standard is strict psalming, all modern psalters that I have seen fail the test. But if the standard is expositorial and un excuse me, an uninspired accuracy, they're wonderful. The psalms in my Bible don't rhyme. So all that's to answer the question, why don't we sing only psalms? Because God does not require the church to sing only psalms. And singing some songs outside the book of psalms is fitting. [snorts] Question four is about lyrics. What kind of words should we sing? So we we teach and admonish one another when we sing.

19:11 That's what Colossians 3:16 says. So it's important that we sing the right kind of words. So here are four principles for what kind of words we should sing. Lyrics should revere God. We should not sing in a way that treats God lightly. We should sing words that are fitting for the triune God. So some contemporary pop songs talk about Jesus as if he's your boyfriend. So here's an example. It's a song titled The More I Seek You. Carrie Job repeatedly sings these words. I want to sit at your feet, drink from the cup in your hand, lay back against you, and breathe, feel your heartbeat.

19:59 We don't we don't sing those words together on Sunday mornings. Uh those words might be fitting for a woman privately to say to her husband, but they're not fitting for us to sing to the triune God. And also related to that, when a church sings songs like that, it's it's like pouring water on a fire for all the manly men. So suddenly the manly men will be thinking, "When will this song be over? Get me out of here." That's their thought bubble.

20:31 Here's another principle. We should sing words that teach sound doctrine. If we teach one another when we sing, that's what we're doing. we're teaching one another, then we should teach what is good, true, and beautiful. And we should we should not sing false doctrine. We should not sing what is false, evil, or ugly. Here's another principle. Emphasize the most important truths. So, some doctrines are more important than other doctrines, and we should sing those most frequently. We should praise the triune God. We should exalt in the good news about Christ the King. And then a final principle, our lyrics should not neglect biblical truths that we don't find uplifting.

21:17 For example, how often do modern praise songs praise God for judging his enemies? Can you think of an example? So that's a good reason to sing all the psalms. So question four is about lyrics. What kind of words should we sing? Lyrics should rever God, teach sound doctrine, emphasize the most important truths, and not neglect biblical truths that we don't find uplifting. Question five is about musical style. So why do we sing songs in a more formal musical style rather than a popular one?

21:56 So, in a debate book on Christian worship, my friends Michael Lawrence and Mark Deor defend a view that they call blended worship. And they begin their essay with this sentence. The style of music you use on Sunday mornings is incredibly unimportant. Well, I disagree with that. That would be like saying the way you dress on Sunday morning is incredibly unimportant. The same principles for how we dress for a worship service should apply to the musical styles we use. When the church comes together to worship on Sunday morning, there are ways to dress that are fitting and ways to dress that are not fitting for the occasion. For example, would it be fitting for you to

22:44 come on Sunday morning as a man in your swimsuit with no shirt, no shoes? Would that be fitting? This isn't a trick question. That would not be fitting, would it? But but if on Sunday afternoon you're relaxing with your family at a lake or a pool, that would be fitting there, but not here. Or would it be fitting for a woman on a Sunday morning to come in just tattered rags, paint splotches all over as Sunday morning attire? No. But if she was painting her house, that'd be perfect.

23:21 It's there there there are certain clothes that are fitting for some occasions and not others. When the church meets to worship God, there's a way to dress that is fitting and there's a way to dress that is not fitting. And you need wisdom to dress in a way that is fitting for the occasion. All right. So, in a similar way, when the church comes together to worship God on Sunday morning, there are musical styles that are fitting for this occasion and there are musical styles that are not fitting for this occasion. For example, let's take the song We Will, We Will Rock You.

23:57 That's a fitting song for pumpup music at a high school football game or basketball game. It's not a fitting song for a Sunday morning worship service. I've been to a a large mega church that played that song to open up a Sunday morning worship service. Uh it's not fitting to perform Beethoven's fifth symphony in the Sunday morning worship service, but that would be fitting at a concert. So there are musical styles that are fitting for when the church meets to worship God, and there are musical styles that are not fitting. And you need wisdom to select musical styles that are fitting for the occasion. So that's what the pastors of our church have tried to do. We're attempting to

24:39 exercise wisdom by selecting more formal musical styles rather than popular ones. And when I say more formal musical styles, I simply mean the songs in our himynel. I think that more formal musical styles are fitting for this occasion. And I think that more popular musical styles are not as fitting for this occasion. That doesn't mean that more more popular musical styles are not fitting for any occasion. Swing music is fitting for swing dancing. An Irish jig is fitting for dancing a jig. I an Irish jig, I guess.

25:16 Uh, and dures are fitting for morning. Uh, theme songs from the Rocky movies are fitting for working out. Uh, some instrumental soundtracks from movies are fitting for background music while you're reading. Some music is soothing. So, think of King, not King David, think of David playing his heart for King Saul. And that's soothing King Saul. The most soothing music for me is box six unaccompanied cello suites. Um, so you may be thinking, "But I really like singing songs with a contemporary musical style on Sunday mornings. Why don't we sing that way on Sunday mornings?" And I am not claiming that every church who uses a contemporary musical style is sinning.

26:02 I think that more formal musical styles are more fitting for this occasion. Just making a wisdom call here. A particular kind of contemporary musical style that I think is unfitting for our Sunday morning worship service is what I call radio songs. So here's what I mean by radio songs. Radio songs are popular style songs that a soloist might perform on a radio station like KTIS. So, why don't we as a congregation sing radio songs on Sunday mornings?

26:38 Well, I don't think that style is most fitting for congregational singing in a Sunday morning worship service. Here's why. One reason, radio songs typically have a highly emotional musical style that is similar to popular love songs. So, a Jesus is my boyfriend musical style is not fitting for a Sunday morning worship service when our church is revering the holy God. In our church's worship service, we express our affections for God. Our worship in song should flow from virtuous affections.

27:17 So, I'm going to very briefly here review what I taught in my first sermon in this series on congregational worship. So u I distinguish between affections and passions. Remember this right? So this is highly relevant for singing songs to God in a fitting way. Reformed theologians like Jonathan Edwards helpfully distinguish your affections from your passions. And the word emotion, by the way, is a new word. Didn't exist commonly until the 1800s. I think it's helpful to distinguish appetites, passions, and affections in line with Jonathan Edwards and other reformed theologians. So appetites are impulses of a creature's mind and body to meet needs and desires like you're

28:02 hungry or you're thirsty. So that yeah, that's your appetite. And this is something that a human being can have and something that an animal could have. So passions are sudden impulses of people when they respond to stimuli like uh someone tickles you and you laugh. That's the stimuli. Or uh a scary animal is chasing you and you get a surge of adrenaline and and you run. That surge of adrenaline is a passion. So passions aren't necessarily bad. Uh but I'm just emphasizing it's something that happens to you. Affections are cultured inclinations of people to abstract concepts such as God, truth, goodness, and beauty and disinclinations

28:50 to their opposites. So your affections are your heart's deep settled loves and hates. Like here's an example of a good affection. A man who has a deep love for his family. Or here's another example. It's the it's a love here's a hate. a man who hates sexual immorality. That's a good affection. Now, today, people use the word emotion for all three of these concepts, especially for passions. So, if you laugh, you're expressing emotion. But you have to ask, what kind of emotion? I mean, if you're laughing because someone's tickling you, that's a passion. If you laugh because someone told a a clever joke and you got the punchline, that's an affection.

29:36 It's going through your intellect. So when we gather to worship God together and we we sing together in particular, our worship in song should flow from virtuous affections, our hearts deep settled loves and hates, not flow from our passions. Now, in my opinion, certain contemporary musical styles appeal primarily to our passions. It doesn't make them inherently sinful. I'm just arguing that those musical styles are not most fitting for congregational worship. Churches can employ those styles, I think, to elicit a fairly predictable response. So, for example, there are some songs played a certain way where it's fairly easy to

30:25 predict when a bunch of hands are going to go up or uh you just look at the music's volume and speed and pitch and key. And when that happens, someone might be looking on and think, "Oh, this is awesome. Look what's happening. The spirit's moving." And maybe he is. Uh but also what could be happening is people are just responding to a stimulus. uh and it's it's it's appealing to a passion and people mistake a special spiritual experience for just responding to a musical stimulus.

30:58 For example, uh there's a way to combine instruments like a synthesizer, a bass guitar, keyboard, and drums that makes you feel very sentimental. And you can do that with just a piano, too. Uh, so there's a way to play music that makes you want to respond in a particular way, whether to dance or to raise your hands or to just feel sad. And radio songs do that really well. They employ a highly emotional musical style to create a musical high that some people interpret as a deeply spiritual experience. So that's the first reason we don't sing radio songs. They typically have a highly emotional musical style that is similar to popular love songs. So here are the other reasons. They are

31:42 typically made for a soloist to perform. So we want to sing songs that are designed for a congregation to sing together. In particular, we love to sing in harmony, to sing in parts. Singing in parts is fitting because it's aesthetically pleasing and it illustrates how the church harmoniously works together like parts of a body. Songs that are performanceoriented are not fitting for a congregation in a church's worship service. The Sunday morning worship service is not a concert. And another reason, radio songs are often played so loudly over the speakers that they drown out the congregation.

32:23 So, at at many popular concerts, the music's so loud, you can barely hear yourself sing, let alone the person next to you. And when the church sings, the sounds coming out of the speakers should not be so loud that they drown out the congregation. We want to be able to hear each other sing. And a beautiful way to do this is to regularly sing ac capella. Just cut all instruments and hear our voices. And our church's custom has been to do that on the final verse of each song we sing. Another reason uh is that radio songs are typically epheminite.

32:59 So many radio songs are they're in a higher range that's fitting for a woman's voice. And such songs do not encourage men to lead out with vigorous hearty singing. So instead, if the men sing at all, they sort of mumble along and look forward to the song ending. We want our men to lead out with hardy, loud, vigorous singing. And we want all the women and children to heartily follow the men. And then another reason, radio songs emphasize only a small percentage of Christian doctrine.

33:42 So last year there was a himnil that came out uh by Keith and Kristen Getty published by Crossway the Getty himnil and last fall there was an event where they they they had a concert and did Q&A and I heard him respond to one of the answers and I transcribed it for you. So this is from uh November 2025. Keith Getty said the question is what gaps are most obvious or most exposed in modern worship? Here's his answer. In the broader contemporary worship music movement, only about 20% of subjects in Jipacker's book, Knowing God, are being plumbed at any depth. The picture you have of God from the songs you sing, and the visceral emotional picture that you're responding to in worship is not a

34:28 very true picture of the God of the Bible. We need a much bigger picture of the God of the Bible. Starting with the trinitarian understanding and starting with the fact that he is eternal. Many of my friends are involved in contemporary Christian music and Christian radio is a wonderful ministry. He says, "But at the end of the day, it's a business that is built on trying to market in less than three minutes to two women. And they give them both names. One is a woman with two young children and one is a woman approaching menopause and they try to reach those two women because they are 70% of their market. The problem is people are taking that and then trying to place it in our

35:10 churches on a Sunday as the standard diet for our Christian health. It's an unhealthy and completely upside down understanding. So that's why we don't sing radio songs. That's why we sing songs in a more formal musical style rather than a more popular one. Now, someone might reply, "But more formal musical styles can be musically challenging. Wouldn't it be simpler to sing easy songs? Why should we work at becoming more musically literate?" That's a fair question. So, let's apply that logic to the Bible and theology. Why should we work at becoming more biblically literate? Well, here's why. The more you know about God and his ways, the deeper and sweeter will be

36:01 your praise. And in a similar way, the more you know about music, the deeper and sweeter will be your praise as you sing to God. Now many of you did not grow up with musical training and it has been a learning curve for you to figure out what all the notes on the pages of our himnil mean. So Doug Wilson encourages us. We are in the process of recovering a musical heritage that we have been throwing away for several centuries now. So we will not recover it in 10 minutes. We will not have a convenience store reformation.

36:38 We want to be part of a grand reformation in in the Stillwater area that becomes richer with each generation. Reformations don't happen overnight. Reformations happen gradually. And we think that it is fitting for our reformation to increase our musical literacy. And that's why we sing some songs that are musically challenging. This musical reformation will help us build a sturdy, beautiful Christian culture. Singing the world's music with different lyrics leaves you with a culture that is thin and worldly. So that's question five. Why do we sing songs in a more formal musical style rather than a popular one? Because it's fitting for the occasion. Now the rest

37:26 of the questions we're going to go a little more quickly. Question six is about atmosphere. Should the lighting and sound level be like a rock concert? Well, this is an easy one. No, that's not fitting. It's not fitting to have a fog machine or strobe lights or a laser light show. That's distracting because it makes it feel like a performance. It's not fitting to dim the lights and put shades over all the windows so the room is completely dark and then you shine bright lights on the people on the stage and you can't see the people around you. uh that is like a performance. And when I say you shouldn't dim the lights, I I'm thinking of a typical Sunday morning worship

38:04 service. It would be fitting to dim the lights for say a candlelight evening service. It's not fitting to play music so loudly that you can hardly hear yourself sing, let alone the people around you. So God commands us be filled with the spirit with the result that we address one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs. And it's hard to obey that command if you can't see each other and if you can't hear each other.

38:28 So question six is about the atmosphere. Should the lighting and sound level be like a rock concert? No, that is not fitting. Question seven is about solos. Why don't we regularly feature soloists? So some churches regularly feature a soloist at some point in the worship service. Sometimes it's right before the preacher preaches a sermon. I have been a member of several churches with that custom and sometimes I still preach in churches that have that custom. So I don't think that custom is inherently wrong. But our church does not regularly feature solos because they can feel like a performance and we don't want the worship service to feel like a performance. We want to emphasize hearty

39:10 congregational singing. So why don't we regularly feature soloists? Because solos can feel like a performance and we want to emphasize hearty congregational singing. Question eight is about a choir. Why don't we regularly feature a choir? Because we want our whole congregation to be the choir. Now, we're not against choirs. I love choirs. Uh I sang in a choir in a church service every Sunday morning and Sunday evening for about 10 years. I enjoyed it. I I'm not opposed to church choirs.

39:44 So, our our church has will even feature a choir in our worship service on special occasions, but we don't regularly feature one because we want our whole congregation to be the choir. In the future, we may feature a choir more regularly on Sunday mornings, but we don't currently have a plan for that given our size and our priorities. And by the way, I just want to commend you all for how much you have grown in your musical literacy. And I don't mean to be condescending and say you guys were really bad when we started, but you weren't that great when we started. Um, when we first covenanted in January 2025, the musical literacy of our church was pretty low. Those first months, I

40:30 was thinking, is this going to work? And we just kept at it and kept at it. and you were motivated to improve and you've been working diligently to sing your parts in the psalms and hymns each week and many of you come early on Sundays for the psalm sing from 9:30 to 9:45 and we practice together and then in our Sunday worship services you have sung heartily to the Lord it's beautiful it's joyful it I think we are we are offering a pleasant aroma to the Lord in our songs now let's let's keep it at keep at it and let's get even better at it. So, this is question eight about the choir. Why don't we regularly feature a choir?

41:10 Because we want our whole congregation to be the choir. Question nine is about instruments. Why is a piano the only instrument that normally accompanies our singing? So, a piano is a fitting way to assist our small congregation to sing heartily. Instrumental accompanyment should be helpful and undistracting. So that's the principle we're trying to apply as we choose what is fitting to accompany our singing. The instrumental accompaniment does not need to be professional because we're not producing a show. So we don't need a professional band or a professional orchestra. The instrumental accompaniment should assist the congregation to sing loudly and joyfully.

41:58 And this isn't the only way to do it. There are lots of ways to do this. But a simple and an elegant way to do this is for a piano to support four-part singing. And especially given our church's age and size, I think that a piano is a fitting way to assist the congregation to sing heartily, to sing joyfully, loudly, vigorously. And also when a church chooses to have a whole big team of many musicians and instruments, preparing the music can take a big part of a church's staff and volunteer bandwidth. So at this stage, we don't think that's best given our church's size and priority. We're not ruling it out for something like that in the future. So singing with just a piano

42:44 accompaniment is obviously not the only way, but it's a fitting way. It's a fitting way to assist our congregation to sing heartily. Question 10 is about the mood. Why is the mood of our worship service joyful? The answer is because that tone is fitting for a worship service. Psalm 98 commands, "Make a joyful noise to the Lord, all the earth. Break forth into joyous singing and sing praises." We want to obey that command. Psalm 100 commands, make a joyful noise to the Lord, all the earth. Sing, serve the Lord with gladness. Come into his presence with singing. Titus is playing the symbols over here. He's he's participating right now, making a joyful

43:32 noise. We want to obey those commands when we meet to worship God together with singing. We want to obey those commands when we meet when we worship together and offer our sacrifices of praise to God. So, as a general rule, we aim for our worship service to be joyful and upbeat rather than dragging and durgeike. And we do that because that tone is fitting for a worship service. When we meet to worship God together, we're celebrating who God is and what he's done for us in Christ. So our celebration climaxes with participating in the Lord's supper and then singing the doxology.

44:13 So when I get to lead us in the doxology at the end of the service, I have a view of you that you don't have. I get to see all your faces. And from the beginning, from January 2025, that view has consistently been wonderful. So you've just celebrated the Lord's supper. You're singing the doxology with your hands raised and your your whole body is communicating praise the Lord. Thank you, Lord. You're you're you're communicating joy in everything about what you're exuding in that moment. I love it. I love it. And so when I say that uh the mood of our service is joyful, that doesn't mean that we're superficially happy. We want to have a category for Paul saying sorrowful yet always rejoicing. And

45:00 sometimes we come to a worship service carrying heavy burdens that fill us with sorrow. So you want we don't want to be a superficial, you know, happy clappy, you know, group when we get together. We're talking about a deep settled rooted joy. And even when we're feeling sorrowful, we can rejoice in the Lord always. Again, we can rejoice. Philippians 4. And of course, it is fitting to intentionally slow down and have a moment of silence as we do when we confess our sins. It's fitting to sing songs with a slower tempo, a more contemplative, solemn mood as we do when we sing some of the psalms. But overall, the tempo of our singing and reading scripture and praying is crisp in the

45:44 sense that it's briskly decisive, not meandering. So, question tends about the mood. Why is the mood joyful? because that tone is fitting for a worship service. Question 11 is about the word amen. Why do we end all songs by heartily saying amen? We do that because it's a fitting way for us to exclaim together that we affirm the truth we just sang about. We agree with it and we love it. That's why Psalm 106 ends like this. Blessed be the Lord, the God of Israel from everlasting to everlasting. And let all the people say, "Amen. Praise the Lord. That's Psalm 106:48.

46:24 And 2 Corinthians 1:20 says, "All the promises of God find their yes in him, in Christ. That is why it is through him that we utter our amen to God for his glory." So when we sing psalms and hymns to God, it's fitting for us all to respond together with a hearty amen. And when you do that, don't forget the exclamation point. So question 11 is about saying amen. Why do we say amen at the end of our songs? Because it's a fitting way for us to exclaim together that we affirm the truth we just sang about.

47:01 Question 12 is about a himnil. Why do we use a himnil? Here's the short answer. A good himnil [snorts] is a rich resource for a church to sing and remember high quality songs. So I'm going to unpack that with even more specific reasons. I'll do this briefly. So reason one, a good himnil collects highquality songs that span centuries and continents and cultures. Since there are hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of outstanding hymns, we should not be content to sing shallow songs that came out 10 minutes ago or 10 decades ago. And we should not be content to sing shallow songs that nobody will request to sing on his

47:50 deathbed. We should prioritize songs that are built to last. Songs that our brothers and sisters have been singing for centuries. If Christ doesn't return first, we want to be singing those kind of songs. Another reason a himnil, a good himnil is a rich resource to help churches and families and individuals learn and remember sound theology. So a good himnil is a collection of rhyming rhythmic theology. It's what it is.

48:24 Rhyming rhythmic theology. Truths learned in song are remembered long. You can just remember words better when they're put to music. You don't remember everything I say in my sermons, but like when you drive home, you don't sing my sermons. But if it's a good song, you sing all the words of those songs. I'll embarrass Elelliana. I can just sing any song, any song for like half a measure and then she'll finish the line. She just she if it's to music, she gets it.

48:55 A lot of kids especially are like that. When they're they hear something put to music, they remember it. And sometimes that's really good. Like if you're remembering a song, sometimes it's unfortunate. Like if it's a really dumb commercial or an evil pop song and it's stuck in your head forever. But but my point I'm trying to make is you remember stuff put to song. And it's wonderful that we can do that with good quality lyrics. And and parents, aren't you glad that your kids are walking around singing psalms? Amen. Reason three, a good quality himnil encourages the church to sing beautiful harmonies. So the songs in a himnil typ typically have four parts for people who sing higher

49:40 and lower to sing. And those parts are called soprano, alto, tenor and bass. So ladies typically sing the higher voice is soprano, the lower lady voice is alto. And for men they have tenor and bass. The higher male voice is tenor and the lower male voice is bass. Well, uh, that's that's what the the lines are. The notes are the top two are soprano, alto, then you got tenor, bass, and a himnil lays all that out so you can work on your part and then come together with the church and sing beautiful harmonies. Uh, reason four, a good himnil encourages a congregation to grow in their musical literacy.

50:17 So, when it comes to words, we are not content to be illiterate. my my daughter uh coached a group of kids this last week for a Shakespeare play and on Friday they performed it and one of the girls who attended the play who who wasn't in the play came up to her and said can I be in the next play and Cara said well can you read and she said I probably can in a month she's really excited to learn to read I think that's wonderful uh we want our kids to learn to read value literacy we teach them when they're young right We value literacy and then we value biblical literacy.

50:56 Teach them to know the Bible, to understand the Bible. We're not content to have the bar so low that when we preach a sermon that it's got to be so simple that the youngest child in the room understands every word. No, we want to raise the bar. We want to grow in our biblical literacy. So if we're not content to be illiterate and we're not content to be biblically illiterate, then why should we be content to be musically illiterate? So we should value the ability to read music. We should grow uh in our musical skills and value that ability and a good himnil encourages our congregation to grow in our musical literacy. One more reason, a good himnil makes it easier to trace the

51:39 argument of a song from line to line and from stanza to stanza. So when a when a church is singing together and everybody's looking at the words on a screen, it's very hard to trace the argument of a song and to go back and and to look at that. All you see is a slide from from moment to moment. Uh but a good psalm or hymn progresses from line to line, stanza to stanza. And it's helpful to be able to look back and reflect on those words and phrases. So question 12 is about a himnil. Why do we use a himnil? Answer a good himnil is a rich resource for a church to sing and remember highquality songs. Question 13 is about our himynil. Why do we use the treasury of psalms and hymns? We use the

52:23 treasury because it is a fitting himnil for our church. And I'll very briefly unpack why I think it's a fitting himnil for our church. Our himnil helps us obey God's command to sing psalms. The first section of our himynil, it's psalms 1-481. It's all the psalms. It's psalms 1 through 150. And it's about three versions of each psalm straight through. That's the first part of our himnil. That's so helpful because it this himnil allows us to systematically comprehensively sing all the psalms.

53:03 It really really helpful. And then uh songs 482 to the end are other hymns including most classic hymns that reformed churches sing. So it's a good himnil. It's got all the songs. And then our himnil has more songs than most himnels. 1,135. We got a lot to work with. And then another reason, our himynil includes songs that Christians have been singing for hundreds of years as well as some that are more recent. Our himnil sets the music to a very singable pitch or range especially for men. Really appreciate that. Our himynel is more affordable than most himnils. So we're thinking we want a himnil that you you could buy extras for your family. We could buy in in uh great quantities for

53:51 our church. And then our himynil includes excellent indexes and online resources including free recordings available for each song. There's also a YouTube list that's got all the songs from our himnil in there. It's also one of the himynelss in the sing your part app that our church uses. So we wanted to use that app. So it's helpful to have a himnil that's also in that app. Our himynil includes guitar chords which is really helpful if you're away from a piano and you've got a guitar and you you can you could play along easily. And then our himnil arranges songs 482 to 854 under the five headings that our church follows. So I'll show you here on the screen. The call to worship,

54:31 confession, consecration, and then communion and commission. That's really helpful to have a himnil that arranges songs like that. That's that organization is helpful for us. So question 13 is about our himynil. Why do we use the treasury? because it's a fitting himnil for our church. Finally, question 14 is about musicians. Is it fitting for a church to employ professional musicians who are unbelievers? In 2002, Tim Keller explained why his church selected particular musicians.

55:09 Here's what he wrote. First, we use only professional and/or trained musicians for our corporate worship services, and we pay them all. The reason for this has to do with our commitment to excellence. Second, we often include non-Christian musicians in our services who have wonderful gifts and talent. We do not use them as soloists, but we incorporate them into our ensembles. We believe this fits a reformed world and life view. The dualistic view in many evangelical churches is that a godly, sincere Christian who is an average musician is more pleasing to God than a non-Christian professional musician. But reformed theology, he says, teaches that God's natural gifts in creation are as

55:55 much a work of grace as God's gifts in salvation. I strongly disagree with that reasoning. It is fitting for our musicians to play with undistracting excellence. But it is not fitting for our musicians to be unbelievers. The people who help us lead worship in song should be fellow believers because we're offering praise to God together in a covenant renewal ceremony. Just not fitting for unbelievers to lead God's people to praise God in song like that. So question 14 is about musicians. Is it fitting for a church to employ professional musicians who are unbelievers? No. We are offering praise to God together in a covenant renewal service.

56:43 You want some more questions and answers? I'll stop there. Okay, I'll stop there. Those are answers to 14 questions about singing. So I'll I'll close with two concluding exhortations. First, sing heartily when we sing together in our Sunday worship service. So when we sing together, we're worshiping God. We're obediently serving God. So serve him with joy, with gladness. That means, brothers and sisters, don't stand there and mumble softly with your mouth barely moving.

57:12 Come on, sing loudly, vigorously, joyfully. And it starts with the men. Men lead us in this. And exhortation two, prepare to sing on Sunday morning. Prepare. So use the Sing Your Part app throughout the week. Starting on Monday, you can start practicing all the psalms and hymns we plan to sing together on the upcoming Sunday. In the Sing Your Part app, if you select Christ the King Church in Stillwater, Minnesota, you can see and hear what we plan to sing in our upcoming worship service. You also have the option to listen to songs on a playlist that we provide for you on our church's website under prepare for worship. And you may not know this, in the Singer Part app, you can adjust the

57:56 tempo, the speed, you can adjust how loud the different parts are. So if you sing tenor, you can crank up the tenor parts. You can learn your line and hear that better. And so learn the tunes, learn your parts, get familiar with the music and the words. Learn it well enough that when you come together to to worship God together on Sunday morning, you can sing the right words and the right notes at the right time and be thinking about what they mean. And for some of you, that means you start practicing on Monday. But that's our goal. We don't want you here on Sunday singing the right notes, singing the right words, and having no idea what you're saying. So, our goal is you're

58:36 able to sing the right notes, the right right times, the right word, all that, and be exalting in the truth of what you're saying. That that's our goal. And that we can do that together and offer a sacrifice of praise to God. I'd encourage you if you're you're still trying to get better at this, come at 9:30. from 9:30 to 9:45 each week we practice together. That's a great time to to practice together. Let's pray. Father, thank you for the gift of music.

59:05 It is a joy to worship you by singing psalms and hymns together. So when we sing together, we ask please help us honor you in a fitting way. And we ask in the name of Christ the King. Amen.

No transcript available.