Transcript
0:02 Let's pray together. Father, as we consider what you have revealed to us about your good design for men and women, please help us to love what you love and to hate what you hate. We ask in the name of Jesus. Amen. Amen. Please open your Bible to 1 Timothy chapter 2. 1 Timothy 2. As I preach through 1 Timothy, the next text in our series is 1 Timothy 2:es 11 and 12. So we'll begin by reading 1 Timothy 2:es 11 and 12. Hear the word of the Lord. Let a
0:53 woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Rather, she is to remain quiet. First question to ask here is how does this passage connect to what comes before. You may recall last sermon I preached was on modesty on verses 9 and 10. In verse 10, Paul says he desires that women women adorn themselves with what is proper for women who profess godliness with good works. What is an example of such good works? This sentence, the very next sentence, the it specifies learning
1:44 quietly and submissively is one of those good works. The main idea of this passage is that a woman must learn in a certain way, quietly, and submissively. So, I'd like to preach to you on 1 Timothy 2 11-12 on this topic. A woman must learn quietly and submissively. I plan to explain and apply this passage by answering nine questions. Let's start with the first question. What does the command let a woman learn mean? And if you like to follow along with this outline, it's in your worship service guide. The whole outline is there. So question one, what
2:34 does the command let a a a woman learn mean? So, I'd like to address a translation issue for this command in verse 11. Let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. There are two basic options for how to translate that command. Option one is allow a woman to learn. Option two is a woman must learn. Now, most of you are native English speakers. It's your heart language. And when you see the command, let a woman learn, it sounds like saying, "Allow a woman to learn in a certain way." Sounds
3:24 like option one, but that's not what Paul intends here. A better translation is the second option. A woman must learn. Let me explain to you why that's the case. It's difficult to translate Paul's Greek words into English here because he's using a grammatical construction in Greek that English does not have. That's called a third person imperative. So if I were to look at Pastor Nathan and say, "Nathan, come here." That's called second person. So it's not I'm not talking to myself.
3:56 That'd be first person. I'm not talking to someone over there, third person. Talking to you and looking at you. Second person. Nathan, come here. That's you come here. Or I could talk to all of you and say, "Open your Bible to 1 Timothy 2." That's a imperative, a command to you plural. We don't have something in English where we say, "He must come here or they must be quiet." We don't talk that. We don't have a a a command like that. Greek does. It's called a third person imperative. And it's kind of tricky to translate into English. So a lot of English translations will will translate it as let the interesting you know this from Genesis 1 when the translation for God creating light for
4:41 example how does it go let there be light it's translating it's that's Hebrew not not Greek it's a it's adjustive in Hebrew but it's similar here uh let there be light it's not allow there to be light it's it's commanding light to come into existence so it's kind of like that here with a third person imperative so instead of saying let which I think we hear as allow. I think it's better to say whoever you're talking about in the third person he or she or a woman or they must. That's getting the idea across. Paul's directing his command here straight to women in the church.
5:18 And as he does that, he's teaching the rest of the church that it's good and right for women to learn. So the issues here are not uh you must allow a woman to learn. Paul's saying a woman must learn. You say, you might be thinking, all right, do any other English translations support what you're saying here? And actually, most of them do. You might have one on your lap. So the the NIV says, "A woman should learn." The CSB, a woman is to learn. The net Bible, a woman must learn. The NLT, women should learn. That's the idea. The translation, let a woman learn, is misleading. Paul's not commanding the
6:05 church to allow women to learn. So issues, don't simply allow women to learn. The women should learn. The women must learn. And you think think about it. When Paul wrote this letter in in the first century Greco Roman world, it was not an egalitarian world like ours is today. At that time, men dominated in every culture. So in the Jewish world, the Greor Roman cultures, it was customary for men to be more educated than women. So for Paul to command the women to learn was countercultural. And it really was honoring and dignifying women. So what does that mean for the women in our church? Now the women must learn. They must study the Bible and study theology. Careful Bible
6:57 study and theology are not just for the guys. The women must learn. So question one, what does the command let a woman learn mean? answer. It means a woman must learn. But Paul's focus here is not commanding that a woman learn. He's commanding that a woman learn in a certain way, quietly and with all submissiveness. So that leads to the questions two and three. Question two, what does quietly mean? Again, verse 11 begins, "Let a woman or a woman must learn quietly." Quietly. Now, that word quietly translates a phrase that more
7:47 formbased translations render in quietness. That exact same phrase in quietness occurs at the end of this passage, verse 12. She is to remain quiet. It's so we have remain quiet, learn quietly. It's the exact same phrase in the Greek text. And it sounds awkward to translate it exactly the same way in these two sentences. So that's why it looks different in English. Now the word for quietly in verse 11 and quiet in verse 12, that word occurs only two other times in the whole New Testament. So it's not a common word. One of those times it occurs is really helpful for us to understand what it means here. It's in Acts 21. Paul's arrested in the
8:35 temple and he asks the Roman tribune for permission to speak to a Jewish crowd. And Acts 22:2 says, "When they when the crowd heard that Paul was addressing them in the Hebrew language, they became even more quiet." That's the word. The context of Acts 22 is a gathered assembly of people listening to one person speak. It's Paul speaking. And the assembly was not just quiet. They were listening intently to hear and learn what Paul was saying. Listen intently. That's how women must learn when the church gathers to worship. The issue is not just turn the volume off. It's not just be silent.
9:21 It's be silent so you can listen intently. It's be quiet so you can intently listen and learn. This command to be silent is to have an attentive silence for the sake of giving someone a hearing. In a similar way, in the context in a similar way to Acts 22 when Paul's speaking to the crowd, in a similar way in 1 Timothy 2, when the church gathers to worship, there's a gathered assembly of people listening to a pastor authoritatively teach God's words. That's what's Paul talk that's what Paul's talking about here. And in 1 Timothy 4:13, where he says, "Devote yourself to the public reading of scripture." You might be wondering why we read so much scripture out loud. Because of 1 Timothy 4:13.
10:03 Devote yourself to the public reading of scripture, to exhortation, to teaching. That is the context of first Timothy, particularly our paragraph here in 1 Timothy 2 8-15. It's a public worship gathering. Now, what Paul writes here is not only for a public worship gathering. It's the wider Christian community because of what he says about dressing modestly and doing good works and continuing in faith and love and holiness and self-control. That's more than just public worship gatherings, but it's not less than that. Now, the word for quietly in verse 11 is similar to the word for quiet in verse two. 1 Timothy 2:2, that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life. Now, there interestingly, quiet refers to a
10:53 calm, wellordered life without turmoil and disruption. That's what we're praying for when we pray for government authorities. So, apply that to our passage. A woman should learn quietly, calm, well-ordered. Sounds a lot like First Peter 3:4, which exhorts wives. Let your adorning be the hidden person of the heart with the imperishable beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit which in God's sight is very precious. So a wife with a quiet spirit is not completely silent. She has to talk. She has to communicate. So the issue is not silence. This this quiet
11:43 spirit is a calm well-ordered spirit without turmoil or disruption. So in 1 Timothy 2 11 and 12, this means that a woman must learn by listening intently and calmly. She must not rebel against God's design for qualified men to teach and exercise authority over the church. So that's question two. What does quietly mean? answer. It means to listen intently and calmly. Now, question three. What does the phrase with all submissiveness mean?
12:19 That phrase with all submissiveness helpfully describes what it means to learn quietly. So, a woman must learn quietly. There it is, with all submissiveness. In the phrase with all submissiveness, that word submissiveness translates a word that occurs only three other times in the New Testament. And one of them is in the very next paragraph, chapter 3:es 1-7 in verse 4. An elder must manage his own household well with all dignity, keeping his children submissive. Some translations say insubmission.
13:00 Others say obedient that his children must obey him. So one way to paraphrase that phrase all with all submissiveness is with complete respect for order. That's a good paraphrase with complete respect for order. So a question for you. Uh if a woman must learn quietly with complete respect for order. Do you think that Paul is saying that all women must submit to all men? Now, we've already seen in our series on God's good design for men and women. A woman who's married is responsible to submit to her husband as to the Lord, but not to all other men that way.
13:48 So he's saying, Paul's saying here in the context of hearing a qualified man teach God's words, a woman must submit to what she is learning, namely God's words. So a woman must submit to God's words by learning from qualified men who teach God's words. And I say qualified men because the next paragraph lays out qualifications for the men who do this. Now, another question here. Ephesians 5:24 says that wives should submit in everything to their husbands. Do you think 1 Timothy 2:1 is teaching that a woman must show all submissiveness to her pastor in the same way that she is to submit to her husband in everything?
14:40 Well, I believe that the extent of the pastor's authority here is teaching God's words. So, a pastor doesn't have authority to say to the church, um, I want you all to to to shop for groceries only at Costco and not at Target. God doesn't give a pastor the authority to say something like that. Now, he does give a pastor authority to say something like, "God says not to murder, so you must not support abortion." Now, that's a that's an application that flows right from what God says. Um, so how should a woman learn God's words from qualified pastors? With entire submissiveness, with complete respect for order. A woman
15:28 should not rebel against God's design for qualified men to teach and exercise authority over the church. So that's question three. What does with all submissiveness mean? Answer, it means with complete respect for order. Now question four, what's the flow of thought in verses 11 and 12? Well, the flow of thought is a kayazm. You heard that word before, kayazm. Kayazm is a literary figure in which a speaker or writer repeats words or themes in reverse order. And you can diagram it shaped like the letter X or the Greek letter ki. That's where you get kayazm kai kayazm. So here's an example of a kayazm. It's an easy one to see. Isaiah 6:10. Make the heart of this people dull and their ears heavy and
16:15 blind their eyes lest they see with their eyes and hear with their ears and understand with their hearts. And you can you can see the the X form. I don't mean to cross out scripture, but you see the the form there. U so we've got heart and heart, ear and ear, eyes and eyes. So you can say A B C CBA A. That's a kayazm. Okay. So there's a kayazm in 1 Timothy 2 11-2 which I highlight in my phrase diagram by having the the violet violet and then the green green. So it's an a ba. So lines one and four correspond to each other. A woman must learn quietly and she is to remain quiet. And again they both say in the Greek text in quietness at the end. And then uh in the middle lines two and
17:04 three correspond to each other. With all submissiveness corresponds to I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Now this flow of thought is important when we try to understand what does it mean to teach and to exercise authority over those words are very contested in New Testament scholarship and it's helpful to remember this this flow of thought here because if you can understand what all submissiveness means that will help you understand what it means to teach and exercise authority because there's a contrast.
17:41 So question four, what's the flow of thought in verses 11 and 12? Answer, there's a kayazm, an abba, kayazm. Now question five, does I do not permit signify that Paul is merely sharing his opinion? It's like he's writing a letter and saying, "Hey, here's my opinion. I don't permit." Now, God might permit it, but I don't. Is it is it like that? Is it just him sharing his opinion? And the answer is no. uh I do not permit is a command from God through Paul the apostle. Let's compare verse 12 with earlier in this passage, verses 1 and two, where Paul says, "I urge that the church pray for all all kinds of people, all kinds of prayers, especially government authorities." When he says,
18:23 "I urge," he's not saying, "Well, this is what I'm urging you." Now, God might not do this, but this this is what I'm saying. Or in verses 8 and N, when he says, "I desire that men pray by lifting holy hands without anger or quarreling. And likewise, I desire that women dress modestly, not ostentatiously or seductively." In a similar way, he says, "I don't permit." In verse 12, what Paul says about the church praying for government authorities and for women dressing modestly and for men praying without anger, it's all in line with what he says about not permitting a woman to teach or exercise authority over a man. This isn't just Paul's opinion. It's command from God through
18:58 the Apostle Paul. And that's that's the case in verses 1 and 2, 8 and 9, and verse 12. So question five, does I do not permit signify that Paul is merely sharing his opinion? Answer, no. It's a command from God through the Apostle Paul. Now question six, what does this word teach mean? Teach. Teach, I do not permit a woman to teach, translates the Greek word dasco. And you maybe can hear how that sounds like our English word didactic. In English when we say didactic, it's teaching something particularly having moral instruction as a motive. So here uh teach I do not permit a woman to teach in this context is about publicly explaining God's words. That's what it means every time
19:48 Paul uses teach in his letters to Timothy and Titus. And here some examples are 1 Timothy 4:11 and 6:2 and 2 Timothy 2:2, Titus 1:11. This is publicly explaining God's words. God's words carry authority. So, so if you explain God's words when the church gathers together publicly, it's an inherently authoritative action. It's a type of action that is fitting for a pastor to do. Women may not teach men in this way because this kind of teaching is fitting for pastors. The very next paragraph, and this is where paragraph breaks do not help. So, it's like you're reading along, you get to end of chapter two, chapter break, chapter three. Get rid of the chapter break and just think
20:32 it's paragraph paragraph. The very next paragraph is what we call chapter 3 1-7. It's about qualifications for an overseer or an elder or a pastor. One of those qualifications is in chapter 3:2 able to teach. Later in this letter in 1 Timothy 5:17, Paul says, "Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching." And there's our word, teaching. The action of teaching that Paul refers to repeatedly in his letters to Timothy and Titus is publicly and authoritatively explaining God's words to the church. And that kind of teaching is fitting only for qualified men. So question six, what does teach mean?
21:24 Answer, it means to publicly and authoritatively explain God's words to the church. Now question seven. Does I do not permit a woman to teach mean that God forbids women from teaching at all ever in any context? No. There are other contexts in wi in which it is fitting for women to teach others. Here are some examples. It's fitting for women to teach children, both males and females. Timothy's mother and grandmother taught him taught him the scriptures when he was a child and that was a good thing.
22:09 And moms and grandmas today should be doing that with their kids and grandkids. It's also fitting for older women to teach younger women. Older women are to teach what is good and so train the young women. That's Titus 2. And it is in such context that Proverbs 31:26 is fitting. She opens her mouth with wisdom and the teaching of kindness is on her tongue. It is fitting for women to teach. So let me make this question a little more challenging. Does this prohibition when Paul says, "I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man."
22:50 Does this prohibition mean that God forbids women from teaching men in any context at all? Is it always not fitting for a woman to teach a man? My answer to that is no. There are other contexts in which it is fitting for a woman to teach a man. Here's three examples. It may be fitting for a woman along with her husband to privately instruct a man. Biblical example is Priscilla along with her husband Aquilla. They privately taught Apollos.
23:28 Acts 18:26. They took him aside and explained to him, they explained to him the way of God more accurately. Another example, it may be fitting for a woman to pray or prophesy when the church publicly assembles. I believe that's what 1 Corinthians 11:2-16 teaches. In the context of first century Corinth, she would need to cover her head, wear a head covering. Now, this raises a lot of questions. Um, I don't have time to explain what prophecy is or what I believe the passage about head coverings means. Maybe later. Uh but there's at least some teaching element to prophecy because 1 Corinthians 14:31 says you can all prophesy one by one so that all may
24:18 learn and be encouraged. So people are learning during prophecy. There's a teaching element to prophecy. And Paul says in 1 Corinthians 11 that women may prophesy. But whatever prophecy refers to, it's qualitatively different from the kind of teaching that Paul forbids in 1 Timothy 2 12. And then a third example, it's also fitting for women to generally and informally teach men. This kind of teaching is not the public authoritative teaching in 1 Timothy 2:12. Instead, it's it's similar to what Paul highlights in Colossians 3:16. Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly. And what's the result of that when that happens? Teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom.
25:06 That's a general informal kind of teaching that all believers should be doing to each other. So this is this is the the bit that I think you might have questions about. What does this look like? When is it fitting and how is it fitting for a woman to teach a man? Now, the woman I have learned the most from by far shouldn't surprise you. It's my wife, Jenny. She teaches me every day. That that that should come as no surprise. If you're living with a a godly wife, she will teach you all kinds of stuff. But, uh I want to show you how this can work in other relationships as well. So, it's also fitting for this to happen with other women. I've learned from other women, especially in the context of
25:52 spending time with them as couples. And I'll give you two examples here. One is that my wife and I spent a lot of time with Tim and Anita Tomlinson. Maybe you know who they are. He was president of Betham College and Seminary for a while. He's part of our small group for years in our last church. And Anita is an older woman to me. She's an older godly woman full of wisdom and discernment. I'm going to be part of a a prayer gathering this afternoon that she and her husband lead. Uh she's so sweet and godly. I told her on Friday night I was going to do this. I think she was embarrassed that I was going to say this. Uh, but my wife can testify.
26:30 That's a godly woman who has taught me much. Another example is with a peer. I spent a lot of time with Tom and Abigail Dods. And Abigail is a godly woman who is full of wisdom and discernment. And sometimes Abigail correctly articulates a viewpoint on an issue before I do. I can think of a handful of issues where this has happened. And prior to my coming to the right conclusion, she explains her view to me and does so in a fitting way. She she uh will as a sister respectfully and appropriately challenge me. It would be silly for me to proudly reject any argument from Abigail on the
27:19 grounds that well she's a woman. So obviously my view is right. That's called a logical fallacy. Okay. So I need to be humble to learn from anybody and she's happy to do that in a fitting way in private. She'd be scandalized to do it publicly in the way that's fitting only for a pastor. I like how Rebecca Merkel puts it in her book, Even Exile, talking about this issue. She says, "It's not that men are supposed to be involved in teaching theology and women aren't." Let's pause right there. So, if that's what you're thinking, this means, get that out of your head. A woman, a godly woman, is teaching theology all day, constantly. Have when I'm walking around my house and I'm hearing my wife
28:06 interact with my kids, she's teaching theology in just about every interaction she has with my kids. Okay, back to Rebecca Merkel. It's that men are to teach it one way and women are to teach it another. If men are the words, women are the music. If men are the skeleton, women are the flesh. If men are the radio waves, women are the amplifiers. It has nothing to do with saying that women aren't smart enough or tough enough or gifted enough or anything of the kind. But God loves harmony. He loves the same tune playing out in different strains of the music, intertwining, harmonizing, and each making the other more powerful by virtue of the fact that each is doing something
28:49 different than the other. God is writing a song with harmony. And the feminists want to insist that everyone stay on the same note all the time. If truth were assaulted caramel, the feminists would like to take away the caramel and serve just the salt. So question seven, does I do not permit a woman to teach mean that God forbids women from teaching at all? Answer, no. There are other contexts in which women may teach others, including men.
29:24 Question eight, what does the word translated exercise authority over mean? So exercise authority over translates a Greek word from the word authento and the ESV renders that exercise authority over. And there's a vast amount of literature on this. I'm going to try to make it simple without being simplistic here. Here are at least five ways that evangelical feminists argue that this word doesn't mean what you think it means. So, one is that it means to doineer or usurp authority over. Another is it means assume authority. That's how the updated NIV renders it. Another is
30:14 murder or commit violence against. A fourth is to proclaim oneself author of and a fifth is gain mastery over. I'd say those are the the five most common proposals. Now what these other I would say bad translations have in common is that for each of them the word authent refers to wrongly using authority in all these cases authority is a bad thing right it's using it badly it's not good it's sinful so why does this matter if authent means simply to exercise authority over in in a good way, then
31:02 what Paul says in this passage applies in every culture and at all times. So in reply to these various other proposed translations, I'm convinced that exercise authority over is a good translation. I'm going to give you four brief reasons for that. One reason is that there's no compelling evidence that authent means these other things. doineer, assume authority, murder, proclaim oneself the author of, gain mastery over. So to the contrary, a scholar named Al Walters, W T E R S, has studied alphantto probably more thoroughly than any other living scholar or probably any other scholar.
31:48 And he compellingly demonstrates that the word means exercise authority over. So I commend you if you want to go down this rabbit hole. There's a 50-page chapter he wrote titled the meaning of authento. It's in the third edition of the book women in the church published by crossway 2016. Reason two, the kayazm, the abba kayazm in verses 11 and 12 requires a meaning like exercise authority because the phrase with all submissiveness is the opposite of to teach or to exercise authority over a man. All right. Now, reason three, hang with me. It's more complicated, but you can do this. Reason three, it's the most technical of the
32:37 reasons. The Greek grammar of I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man requires that those two activities teach and exercise authority over are either both negative or both positive. In other words, there are two valid options for what Paul intends to communicate. Either both actions are negative, I do not permit a woman to teach falsely, or to doineer over a man, that's negative, or both actions are positive. I do not permit a woman to teach or exercise authority over a man.
33:22 Now teach is a positive activity every time in Paul's letter letters to Timothy 1 Timothy 4:11 6:2 Timothy 2:2 and when Paul does refer to teaching false doctrine he uses a different Greek word for that instead of uh well it's hetereroids in and he does that in 1 Timothy 1:3 and 63. So here's the argument. Since teach is a positive activity, therefore exercise authority over in 212 must also be a positive activity and not a negative one about misusing authority.
34:01 So this rules out proposed translations like doineer both teaching and exercising authority must be positive activities. Finally, reason four, exercise authority over is a kind of activity that is fitting for a pastor. The very next paragraph, chapters 3 1-7, chapter 3 1-7, it gives qualifications for a pastor and it refers to that calling as in verse one, the office of overseer. What does an overseer do? He oversees. He practices oversight. That's exercising authority.
34:45 When you have oversight, you have authority. Later in this letter in 5:17, Paul says, "Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching." rule. The elders who rule translates a word that means to exercise a position of leadership to direct to be at the head of. That's authority. And then in 1 Peter 5:2, Peter exhorts the elders, shepherd the flock of God that is among you, exercising oversight. Oversight, that's authority. Pastors exercise authority.
35:29 So, it's fitting for a pastor to exercise authority. Now, when people say that a man is pastoral, what do you think they typically mean today? They they typically mean that he's he's gentle, he's caring, he's calming, he's comforting, he's a lot like Mr. Rogers. And that's those are good qualities. Those are good qualities for a shepherd of sheep to have. They're good qualities for a shepherd of people to have. But being pastoral is more than being tender. It also includes being tough.
36:15 And when I say tough, I mean a shepherd needs to be able to kill a lion or a bear or a wolf. That's part of the job description. Sometimes a shepherd needs to grab a sheep before it falls off a cliff. Being pastoral is a wise combination of strength and gentleness, of authority and compassion. Now, we typically don't struggle with the idea that it's fitting for a man and not a woman to be a warrior on the battlefield or to be a tackle football player or to be in a dangerous wilderness to hunt wild game.
37:02 So, why do we why do some people struggle with the idea that it's fitting for a man and not for a woman to be a pastor? I think Doug Wilson puts his finger on this in his little book, Why Ministers Must Be Men. Here's what he says. The problem is that for several centuries, masculinity has been seeping out of us. Many factors have contributed to this. But the upshot is that because of tradition, men have occupied the ministry, the pastoral ministry. At the same time, because of sentimentalism and pyotism, the definitions of piety have become increasingly feminized. The definition of what constitutes devout piety has drifted
37:50 into feminine territory, and ministers have labored to keep up with the shifting expectations. The sweetest and gentlest boy in the church is the one who is told repeatedly while growing up that he really ought to consider seminary. The boy who garnered 17 black eyes and three broken arms while growing up is never told that by anybody. Now he says, if the definitions of the godly minister are essentially feminine, what sense does it make to keep those who really are feminine out of that post? Women can do what we think ministry should be better than men can because women are naturally better at feminine piety than men are.
38:32 Traditionalists are fighting a rear guard action trying to keep women out of a post that women are clearly more qualified for than men are. Feelings can run high in the debate and the debate is essentially over whether men only or women and men both should occupy the post of an essentially feminized office. If anyone has the Samaritan to suggest that we return to the older view of a genuinely masculine pastoral office, then both sides in the contemporary debate will stare at him a gasast. And it will remain this way so long as girly men complimentarians persist in trying to keep girly women from getting their share of the effeminate action. Because of how we have been backed into a
39:12 corner, the egalitarians have a real point if they were to say that exclusion of women from ministerial office is arbitrary. When we think of how the modern ministerial call is defined, it is arbitrary. But if we recognize that the word of God not only excludes women from becoming women ministers, but also excludes men from becoming women ministers as well, we will I couldn't make it through. Uh we will be on the road to recovery.
39:42 In other words, we need to recover a biblical view of the office of pastor. If we correctly understand what it means to be a pastor, then we'll affirm that it's fitting for a man to be a pastor and that it's not fitting for a woman to be a pastor. So, question eight, what does the word translated exercise authority over mean? Answer, it means to exercise authority over. Okay, I know that that answer is kind of cheeky, but I'm just playing back uh with the the evangelical feminists who do interpretational backflips to change the meaning of what Paul so clearly says here. Now, let's consider one final question, and this one addresses arguments by egalitarians who emphasize
40:30 that Paul wrote this letter to Timothy in Ephesus. Question nine, does the historical cultural context of Ephesus restrict how we should apply this passage in other cultures? And my answer to that is no. Paul writes in 1 Timothy 2:8-9, I desire then that in every place, including the Minneapolis area, in every place, the men should pray, lifting holy hands without anger or quarreling. Likewise also the women. And he goes on. So what Paul says here is for Christians in all times and all cultures. Another key passage is what I think is the key passage of 1 Timothy 3:14 and 15. I'm writing these things to you so that if I delay you may know what how one ought to behave in the household
41:22 of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and buttress of the truth. So, what Paul writes in 1 Timothy 2:1-14 is for Christians in all times and all cultures. I think that's fairly clear. But part of my job as a pastor is to refute error, to rebuke those who contradict it. And evangelical feminists attempt to explain away 1 Timothy 2 11-12 by arguing that the historical cultural context of Ephesus restricts how we should apply this passage in other cultures.
41:56 They make at least four different claims. So what I'm going to do is show you four different claims and briefly refute them. Claim number one, I do not permit is better translated I am not permitting. To imply that Paul is giving specific instructions for just this situation. Example is Gordon Fee an egalitarian scholar with the Lord. Now he says, "I do not permit" is better translated, "I am not permitting," implying specific instructions to this situation. In other words, Paul is saying, "I'm not now permitting. The command's just temporary. It's just the case for right now in Ephesus. I'm not saying this is the case for all times in
42:43 all cultures. I'm just not now permitting." So, in reply, two counterarguments. one, that's simply not how to understand the present tense form in Greek. The Greek New Testament is full of commands and exhortations in the present tense form that are universally binding and not temporary. And an example of this is 1 Timothy 2:1 where Paul writes, I urge, present tense form, I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people. He's not saying, "I am now urging to you people in Ephesus, but not for other people. I I'm urging for you right now." No, it's it's it's a not a temporary command that doesn't apply to us in the same way. And the second reason is in verses
43:31 13 and 14, Paul explicitly names two reasons for his command. And those two reasons are rooted in the created order. And therefore, they're transcultural. They are true for every culture at all times. That's claim number one. Claim number two, women in Ephesus were teaching false doctrine. That's why Paul says this. So women in Ephesus were doing this. So what Paul says is true just for Ephesus. Craig Kenir, an egalitarian, asserts this. He says, quote, "Much of the false teaching in Ephesus was being spread through women in the congregation. Presumably, Paul wants them to learn so that they could teach." End quote. Here's how Andrew Bartlett paraphrases 1 Timothy
44:20 2:1-12. I'm not permitting a woman false teacher with expensive and immodest dress, lacking decency and self-control, to teach and overpower a man. She's to be quiet and reverent and learn how to behave in accordance with the truth in full submission to God. So in reply to this claim, here are four counterarguments. One is that the only false teachers Paul names in Ephesus are men. Paul names Himaeus and Alexander in 1 Timothy 1:19 and 20. He names Himaeus and Felitus in 2 Timothy 2:17 and 18. In acts 20 30 Paul warns the pastors in Ephesus that men and the word for that there is males men will teach false doctrine. Another argument
45:10 counterargument is that the Bible does not say that women in Ephesus were teaching false doctrines. So Paul does warn women against being gossips and busy bodies saying what they shouldn't. That's 1 Timothy 5:13. In 2 Timothy 3, he describes weak women as particularly susceptible to false teaching. Uh he describes them as led astray by various passions, always learning, never able to arrive at a knowledge of the truth. But he doesn't describe any women as the ones primarily responsible for spreading false teaching. Another argument is that this objection is illogical because the same reasoning would require that men may not teach. In other words, if all women may
45:57 not teach in Ephesus because some of the women were teaching false doctrine, then it would follow that all men may not teach in Ephesus because the men, some men were teaching false doctrine. But Paul explicitly says that some men were teaching false doctrine, but he doesn't conclude that therefore all men may not teach. And a final counter-argument in verses 13 and 14, Paul explicitly names two reasons for his command. And he does not say that a reason for his command is that women in Ephesus were teaching false doctrine. You having fun? All right, hang in there. Claim number three, women in Ephesus were not educated. So here's how this argument
46:45 goes. Uh Craig Kenir again interprets verse 12 in light of verse 13 this way. Quote, "Paul intends to connect Eve's later creation to why she was deceived. She was not present when God gave the commandment and thus was dependent on Adam for the teaching. In other words, she was inadequately educated like the women in the Ephesian church." End quote. So here's the claim. The women in Ephesus shouldn't teach because they weren't educated. But in other contexts in which the women are educated, God does permit women to teach and exercise authority over men. Five counterarguments. One, Ephesus was a normal Greek society, not a unique feminist one. So Steve Ba, an expert on
47:33 the historical cultural context on Ephesus, demonstrates this. He says, I'm paraphrasing, in a normal Greek society, many men and women received basic skills to read and write. It simply wasn't the case that only some men could read and write and that no women could read and write. So, Steve Ba shows that the egalitarian argument that 1 Timothy 2:12 applies only to Ephesians women in Paul's day is unsound. Another argument, Priscilla was not permitted to teach or exercise authority over men. The the Bible highlights Priscilla. Remember, she's the wife of Aquilla. She's an educated woman who for over four years served the Lord in Ephesus while learning from the Apostle Paul. Acts 18:18 and 19. So
48:18 while she was in Ephesus, Priscilla and her husband Aquilla privately explained the way of God more accurately to Apollos and they later returned to Ephesus because Paul greets them in 2 Timothy 4:19. Priscilla was likely in Ephesus when Paul wrote First Timothy. Third counterargument is the objection is illogical because the same reasoning would require that uneducated men may not teach. But Paul doesn't single out uneducated men because the issue is not how educated you are. It's whether it's fitting for a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Fourth counterargument, Paul forbids the activities of teaching and exercising
49:07 authority over a man. He doesn't say, "I don't permit a woman to teach or exercise authority over a man unless a woman is sufficiently educated." And then the final counterargument in verses 13 and 14, Paul explicitly names two reasons for his command. And he does not say that a reason for his command is that women in Ephesus were not educated. One more claim and we're done. Claim number four. The principle is that Christians should not be offensive to the culture in which they live.
49:44 So Grant Osborne, one of my former professors in seminary, argues this quote, "There are no biblical obstacles to the ordination of women in Western society, where teaching and speaking in the church no longer have the implications they did in the first century. Attitudes today have changed." End quote. In other words, here's the argument. In the historical cultural context of the first century, it was culturally offensive for a woman to teach or exercise authority over a man.
50:16 So Paul advises that in that context, women shouldn't do it. But it's only in that kind of context. Since today we live in an egalitarian culture, an egalitarian society, it's now okay. In response, two counterarguments. One, it's not true that women had no prominent leadership positions in the region in and near Ephesus. In pagan religions, there were women high priestesses and inscriptions from Ephesus in the region show that women also held leadership positions in the civil realm. And then you may have heard this argument before. In verses 13 and 14, Paul explicitly names two reasons for his command. And he does not say that a reason for his command is that women teaching or exercising authority
51:05 over a man would be offensive in their culture. Now I I think you've heard me say this reason for all four claims. It's kind of a big deal. The reasons Paul gives are rooted in the creation order and are therefore transcultural. They apply to all cultures at all times. This is really important and we plan to look more carefully at verses 13 and 14 in our sermon next week. So question nine, does the historical cultural context of Ephesus restrict how we should apply this passage in other cultures?
51:45 Answer, hopefully you can answer this answer. No. That's it. Just no. No. Okay. So this this passage 1 Timothy 2 9-15 the whole passage raises some questions that I've not yet addressed in these sermons but I plan to address them in the next two sermons. So in the next sermon I plan to address the two reasons that Paul gives in verses 13 and 14 that support what he says in verses 11 and 12. And then in the sermon after that I plan to address at least a dozen ways that people object to what this passage teaches. But for now we can state the main idea of 1 Timothy 2:1 and 12 positively and negatively. So positively a woman must learn quietly and submissively. Negatively, a woman must
52:33 not teach or exercise authority over a man. So here are some ways we should obey this passage with God's help. One, only qualified men may publicly and authoritatively explain God's words to the church. This is fitting based on how God designed men and women. Two, only qualified men may exercise authority over the church. In other words, only qualified men may be pastors or elders or overseers. that is fitting based on how God designed men and women. And finally, women honor the Lord by not grasping to be pastors or to act like pastors, but instead to learn
53:23 God's words by listening intently and calmly with complete respect for order. That is fitting based on how God designed men and women. Let's pray. Father, thank you for instructing Christ's church how to behave in your household. Would you please help us to accurately understand your good design for men and women in the church? And would you please help us not only to understand it, but to embrace it as good and sensible and wise. We ask in the name of Christ the King. Amen.
No transcript available.
