God’s Good Design for Men and Women: Part 1 of 4—A Spectrum of Views and Two Types of
Transcript
Transcript
0:06 together. Father, as we consider what you have revealed to us about your good design for men and women, please help us to love what you love and to hate what you hate. And we ask in the name of Christ the King. Amen. Please open your Bible with me to 1 Timothy 2. 1 Timothy chapter 2. As I preach through 1 Timothy, the next text in our series is 1 Timothy 2 9-15. So let's start by reading it. 1 Timothy 2 starting in verse 9.
0:53 Likewise also that women should adorn themselves in respectable apparel with modesty and self-control, not with braided hair and gold or pearls or costly attire, but with what is proper for women who profess godliness, with good works. Let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Rather, she is to remain quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor. Yet she will be saved through childbearing if they continue in faith and love and holiness
1:41 with self-control. Now, instead of preaching just one sermon on this passage, verses 9-15, I'm planning to preach nine sermons on this passage. Well, actually, it's four sermons on what the whole Bible says about God's good design for men and women, and then five sermons specifically on verses 9 to 15. So, you might be wondering, why would we spend so much time on God's design for men and women? I think spending extra time on this topic and on this passage is a way for me to obey Titus 1:9. Titus 1:9 says that this is my job as a pastor. An
2:31 elder must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it. Now briefly elaborate on those two purposes there in reverse order. Notice the second purpose to rebuke those who contradict it. It's referring to sound doctrine. My job as a shepherd is to refute what is evil and ugly and false. It's part of the job description. Bad theology hurts people. False teaching can ruin a church. A pastor must protect the sheep
3:20 from error. And one of the most harmful errors in our culture is false teaching about men and women. A lot of teachers who influence conservative and confessional evangelicalism have contradicted 1 Timothy 2:9-15. So I think it's fitting that we slow down here in our series on 1 Timothy and take some time to carefully refute evil ideologies about men and women. This is an opportunity to correct errors that are common in our secular culture and unfortunately common even in our Christian culture among professing Christians. That's purpose two in this statement. Purpose one is to give instruction in sound doctrine. My job as a shepherd is to feed the sheep with what is good and beautiful and true.
4:11 Good theology helps people. Healthy and true teaching builds up a church. And since many people in our culture are confused about what to think about men and women, it's especially important that we think clearly and accurately about God's good design for men and women. Basically, we want to live in light of reality. It's foolish, for example, to deny that gravity exists. to be on the top of a 10-story building and jump off and say, "Well, I just I don't identify as someone who believes in gravity. That's foolish, right? You want to live in light of reality. Gravity exists. So don't be foolish." In a similar way, it's foolish to deny how God has designed men and women. We might pretend that men and
5:01 women are basically the same, but that would be as foolish as pretending that gravity doesn't exist. So, I have at least seven goals in this nine-part sermon series. Here they are. Number one, I'd like to understand what God's design for men and women is. So, before we can apply these truths, we have to understand them accurately. If God has revealed truth to us in scripture and in nature, we should pay close attention to what he's had what he has revealed to us. A second goal in particular, we want to understand what 1 Timothy 2 9-15 means and how it fits with what God has revealed elsewhere in scripture and in nature. I think we'll be better prepared to do that if we first zoom out of 1
5:48 Timothy 2 to see what the rest of the Bible says about God's design for men and women. We'll do that in the first four sermons. Then we'll zoom back in and look at this passage. And it's important to remember that for the vast majority of church history, Christians have not debated how to interpret 1 Timothy 2 in light of feminist arguments. That didn't start to happen in in the church until the 1970s and the 1980s. That should be a yellow flag to us that maybe modern biases are affecting us more than we realize.
6:24 A third goal is to recognize false teaching about men and women as deadly errors. These errors are common in our secular culture and unfortunately they're increasingly common among professing Christians. These are not minor agree to disagree issues. These are foundational matters. In order for us to be faithful, fruitful followers of King Jesus, we need to understand and obey and love what God tells us about his design for men and women. If we get this wrong, we're going to dishonor and disobey King Jesus. Here's a famous statement many wrongly attribute it to Martin Luther
7:11 that I think is fitting here. You've probably heard this before. It is the truth which is assailed in any age which tests our fidelity. If I profess with the loudest voice and the clearest exposition every portion of the truth of God, except precisely that little point which the world and the devil are at that moment attacking, I'm not confessing Christ, however boldly I may be professing Christianity. Where the battle rages, the loyalty of the soldier is proved. and to be steady on all the battlefield besides is mere flight and disgrace to him if he flinches at that one point. So brothers and sisters, the battle in our cultural context is raging right here. There's a
8:01 battle about God's design for men and women. And it would be cowardly and disobedient for us to run away from this fight. Let's face it head on. Goal number four, affirm that God's design for men and women is good. When you live in line with God's design and not against it, it's like doing woodworking with the grain, not against it. It's like petting a cat from head to tail, not backwards. It's like following a clear and helpful owner's manual instead of refusing to do what the designer says. In other words, to follow God's design for men and women
8:50 makes sense. It's the way it's supposed to be, and it saves us from all kinds of problems and disasters and heartaches. Goal five, don't just affirm, celebrate that God's design for men and women is beautiful and true. It's brilliant and glorious. So the pastors of our church want you to affirm what is true but not stop there. We want you to love it, to celebrate it. We want you to joyfully celebrate what is beautiful and true without being embarrassed by it. A lot of people when they come to 1 Timothy 2 9-15 trip over themselves apologizing for this being in the Bible.
9:35 They're embarrassed by it. We want the opposite perspective. We want to love it and celebrate it as good. When the four pastors of Christ the King Church planned to plant our church, we summarized our strategy with the three words, build and fight. And we summarized that we build and fight by focusing on seven priorities. Here's one of those priorities we articulated at the very beginning. Love God's good design for men, women, and families. We don't merely affirm God's good design for men and women in the home, church, and society. We love it. We want our families to be faithful and fruitful. In particular, while the family is deteriorating in our culture, we encourage husbands and fathers to
10:20 faithfully shepherd their households. And we encourage fathers and mothers to bring up their children with a Christian incultteration. So, in my sermons on God's design for men and women, I'm emphasizing one of our seven priorities. Goal six, resolve with God's help to obey God as men and women, husbands and wives, pastors and other church members. The pastors of our church want this study to motivate all of us to be faithful, fruitful Christians, Christian men, Christian women, not just nebulous Christians.
11:00 We're not androgynous. We're men and women. The great commission is not merely to make converts. The great commission is to make disciples who obey Christ the King. The great commission is to teach people to observe everything that Jesus commanded. That means we need to obey what God says. And a big part of that is obeying what he's commanded us about his design for men and women. And a seventh goal is to strengthen our church's immune system. There's a this is a metaphor about sickness spreading. We want to have a robust immune system. Joe Riggnney, my friend in in particular here, has helpfully warned that Christians need to beware of emotional
11:49 sabotage, to beware of people who use emotional blackmail and try to put a steering wheel on your back. Some churches are afraid to clearly and boldly teach about God's good design for men and women. Why? Because some people use some various forms of emotional sabotage in a disproportionately loud way. And they do this by objecting that when you teach boldly and clearly on this matter, it's abusive or harmful or hurtful or traumatizing or disappointing or insensitive or lacking nuance or whatever. Our church's pastors refuse to let others put a steering wheel on our
12:37 back. We refuse to let untethered empathy govern us. We are committed to strengthen our church's immune system by clearly and boldly proclaiming the truth and rebuking error, even well-intentioned error. So, I'm slowing down here in our series on First Timothy because I don't want to rush this. We need to understand God's design for men and women. Our pastors are aligned on this issue, and we want to make sure our members understand such a controversial and important matter. So, here's the plan.
13:11 In sermons 1:4, God willing, I'll I'll zoom out and summarize what the whole Bible says about God's good design for men and women. Then, we'll zoom back in in sermons 5:9 on 1 Timothy 2:9-15. So, specifically, here's the first four sermons. This is today explain a spectrum of views on manhood and womanhood and explain two different types of complimentarianism. So today's sermon is laying groundwork for the next nine. I'm going to be exedating our culture more than scripture today, but it's scripturally informed. Again, I'm doing what Titus 1:9 is saying to do to rebuke error. To rebuke error, we have to understand what the error is. Then in sermon two, I plan to give five
13:57 exhortations. That's next week, God willing. And then in sermon three and four, give six total arguments for what I call biblical patriarchy or broad complimentarianism. So after those four sermons, then plan to zoom back in on 1 Timothy 2 and look at verses 9 and 10. How should women dress? That passage teaches that women should dress modestly, not seductively or ostentatiously. Yes, we're going to have a whole sermon on modesty because that's what the text says. Then in verses 11 and 12, a woman must learn quietly and submissively as qualified men teach and exercise authority over the church. Then verses 13 and 14, a woman must learn quietly and submissively for two
14:43 reasons. We're going to look at those reasons and and try to understand the rationale for them and what else they might apply to. And then sermon 8 is going to step back and respond to objections. I've already articulated about 12 or 13 of them that people have to what Paul teaches in verses 11 to 14. And then finally, verse 15, a woman will be saved through childbearing. I'm really looking forward to that one. So that's our plan. In this first of nine sermons, I plan to explain a spectrum of views on manhood and womanhood and then explain two different types of complimentarianism. Let's start by explaining a spectrum of views that people hold on men and women. And by the
15:27 way, your your worship service guide has the the hand the the outline on there. It might help you follow along. How does God intend for men and women to be faithful and fruitful in the home and the church and society? This topic has been controversial for evangelicals for about the last 40 or 50 years. And I'm going to present a spectrum of major views here to help you get your bearings. So, one way to lay out the spectrum from left to right may be something like this. So on the far left be LGBTQ plus activism. That acronism, excuse me, that acronym stands for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer. And
16:16 then the plus sign, don't miss the plus sign. That's an umbrella term that means etc. It includes so-called minorattracted people and all other perversions. Basically, LGBTQ plus is an umbrella term that includes all forms of sexual and gender identities that are perversions. That is, they're contrary to God's design for men and women. This particular view has been most influential in our culture for about the past decade.
16:51 Moving to the right a little bit is affirming feminism and LGB but opposing the T the transgenderism. Now this view is becoming increasingly prominent in our culture. Influential people such as Elon Musk and President Trump and JK Rowling fit here. This view is certainly better than LGBTQ plus activism, but those who hold it are still happy to affirm so-called same-sex marriages as as actual marriages. Then we have radical feminism, reformist feminism, and evangelical feminism. Three different kinds of feminism, and they go from worse to a little less worse to little less worse, but they're all bad. So the
17:42 the first one radical feminism uh is like uh an example would be Virginia Remy Malanchott. Marne Costenberger wrote her PhD dissertation on on these versions of feminism and I I find her helpful describing them. For this one, radical feminism. She says this rejects the Bible and Christianity as unusable because of the Bible's male patriarchal bias. So it recognizes the Bible teaches patriarchy, but it rejects the Bible.
18:10 That's one version of feminism. The reformist feminism is a little different. An example is a a biblical scholar named Elizabeth Schusler Fenza. And this one Marne Cosenberger says essentially rejects Christian tradition about women and but it uses the Bible as a means to reconstruct their feminism. So they reject that the Bible's inherent and authoritative to and and that they they they use it though to support their version of feminism.
18:38 A little closer to home is evangelical feminism or egalitarianism. This view, and by the way, those two terms, evangelical feminism and egalitarianism, I'm going to be using those over and over and over. I'm using them synonymously to refer to the same ideology. Marne Cosenberger explains, evangelical feminism rejected a critical stance towards scripture. Evangelical feminists said that nothing in the Bible should be rejected and scripture was seen as teaching complete male female equality. So this view claims to hold the same view about the Bible as we do that it's without error and it's authoritative and they say that it teaches egalitarianism. So a prominent
19:25 organization that promotes this view is Christians for biblical equality based out of Minneapolis by the way. So here is CBE's mission statement. CBE exists to promote the biblical message that God calls women and men of all cultures, races, and classes to share authority equally in service and leadership in the home, church, and world. CBE's mission is to eliminate the power imbalance between men and women resulting from theological patriarchy. That's evangelical feminism or egalitarianism. Next on this spectrum is complimentarianism. The term
20:16 complimentarianism summarizes the theological view of the Danvers statement dan v. the Danverse statement which the pastors of Christ the King Church affirm as part of our elder affirmation of faith. We may actually incorporate that into some future Sunday morning worship services when we uh uh confess uh truths together. That's a good statement. The Danver statement conveys that men and women are both equal in value and dignity and are beneficially different.
20:47 A prominent organization that promotes this view is the Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood. CBMW is an organization that I have written for many times over the years. Abigail Dods, wife of Pastor Tom Dods, is a council member for CBMW. And then next on this list is authoritarianism. Now, this label describes men who think that they may selfishly misuse their authority. It's a hyper headship that may justify sins like physical abuse. Doug Wilson calls a version of this view the patriarchy.
21:31 He explains that in contrast to patriarchy, the patriarchy is where men try to establish or reinforce their masculine authority by means of despising and disparaging women. The patriarchy doesn't want to encourage men to stand tall when making women cower will do. And the machismosphere is when they elevate women to cartoon levels of femininity and then in a corresponding way they elevate men to cartoon levels of masculinity. A trad can for every trad Barbie. I'd like now for us to focus on view six on that spectrum.
22:12 Complimentarianism because I think that's where all or at least most of us are. Not all of us who claim to be complimentarian are the same. There's a spectrum of views here as well. And I think it's helpful to recognize that there are two major types of complimentarianism. So that leads to question two. What are the two types of complimentarianism today? Again, define the term again. Complimentarianism is a view that men and women are both equal in value and dignity and beneficially different. As complimentarianism has matured over the past 40 years, people who call themselves complimentarians now have some
22:59 significantly different viewpoints and leanings and theological instincts. And two versions of complimentarians are now distinguishable. Here's how I'm going to label them. On the one hand, you have narrow or thin or ideological complimentarianism. And on the other, you have broad or thick or natural complimentarianism. Or you could just call it biblical patriarchy. I'll come back to that term. Now, these labels are relatively new. So, most published works on this topic do not use these labels.
23:34 So it may be helpful if I just contrast compare and contrast these two views. So when it comes to this understanding manhood and womanhood, both views agree that men and women are equally in God's image. They're biologically different and they're complimentary. Here's where they differ. First row here is how they differ on manhood and womanhood. The reason I'm I'm calling the first few narrow is that it has a narrow application that here here's what they would say. God requires men and women to relate differently to each other only narrowly in two areas. Marriage and ordination. So in marriage, a husband is ahead of his wife. And in ordination, only men may be pastors. That's it.
24:20 That's all it applies to. So this view is reluctant to define manhood and womanhood. It's reluctant to specify differences beyond uh between men and women beyond the obvious biological ones like the plumbing. The narrow view is quick to point out that broad complimentarians typically include cultural stereotypes in their definitions. The narrow view is reluctant to treat manhood and womanhood as significant for Christian disciplehip. That's the narrow application. On the other hand, the broad view has a broad application.
24:54 The broad view would say that the way God created and designed males and females applies in some way to all of life in the home, in the church, and in society. So, here's one way to define manhood and womanhood. I'm going to quote Bobby Jameson. I think he nailed it here. Manhood and womanhood are the potential to be a father or mother in both biological and metaphorical senses. To father is not only to procreate but to provide, protect and lead. To mother is not only to nurture life physically but to nurture every facet of life to care comprehensively and intimately. So that's the the big
25:42 picture contrast between the narrow and the broad views. Now I'm going to contrast them in marriage and the church and in society. So in again when it comes to marriage both views agree on paper at least that a husband should lead his wife and a wife should submit to her husband. But here's how they would differ. The narrow view emphasizes mutual submission between a husband and wife. They don't emphasize that a husband has actual authority. And it and this view tends to be more open to a mother pursuing vocations outside the home while putting young children in daycare. The broad view emphasizes God designed hierarchy between a husband and wife. So a husband leads, a wife
26:26 submits. And this view tends to advocate living on the husband's income so that a mother can better nurture the children at home, especially when the children are young. That's in the home. Then in the church, the narrow view agrees with the broad that only qualified men should be ordained. But here's where they differ. The narrow view would say a woman may do anything an unordained man may do, like teach an adult Sunday school class to men and women or even preach a sermon to the church.
26:59 The broad view would say only qualified men should teach and exercise authority over the church. And this includes the function, not merely the office of pastor or elder. That's in the church. Then in society, the narrow view is reluctant to specify how men and women should function differently in society. The broad view in contrast would say the different ways that God designed men and women apply to how men and women function in society. For example, some vocations are appropriate only for men.
27:35 For example, military combat. Then these two views have different theological instincts, intuitions and burdens. So if you ask the question, what is the the biggest problem facing the church's understanding of manhood and womanhood today? The narrow view would say something like this. It's that men misuse their authority in the home and the church. So we should emphasize that men and women are equal. So this view affirms but does not emphasize that men and women are different and that God has given men actual authority and it tends to criticize broad complimentarianism then make a case positively for complimentarianism. In contrast, the broad view would answer that question by
28:24 saying we should emphasize that men and women are equally made in God's image and acknowledge yes, it's sinful for men to misuse their authority. But here's the thing. Sinful men and women may use any advantage they have to get their way. Privilege, wealth, strength, beauty, brains. Men who misuse their authority have been doing that since Adam and Eve fell. That's been going on throughout human history. The most generationally urgent problem now on manhood and womanhood is that our culture rejects God designed differences between men and women. So while our our culture is emphasizing androgyny and egalitarianism, Christians should emphasize that God made men and women
29:07 with complimentary differences and that God has given men actual authority in the home and the church. That's how they would answer that differently. And then finally, they have a different theological method. The the narrow view would be more biblicist, meaning it narrowly affirms that God requires men and women to relate differently in only two areas, marriage and ordination, because the Bible explicitly addresses those areas. That's what I mean by biblist. They have statements in the Bible that explicitly say that. The broad view tends to include nature.
29:41 So broadly it affirms different designs for men and women not just because of ex Jesus which is carefully reading the Bible but also because of good systematic theology and natural theology. I'll say more about that later in the series. Trying to read your faces if you're following me on the difference between narrow and broad. You got the gist? Okay, I'm getting thumbs up everywhere. That's encouraging. So now I'd like to just qualify this by clarifying what I just taught you.
30:11 Seven quick qualifications or clarifications. Number one, CBMW, the Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, is an organization that prominently represents mere complimentarianism, though most of its leaders are probably broad. So again, complimentarianism officially summarizes the Danvers statement. And according to Denny Burke, he's the current president of CBMW. John Piper drafted the Danverse statement. And then John Piper, Wayne Grudam, and some others coined the term complimentarianism in 1988. And Denny Burke argues that the Danverse statement itself is mere complimentarianism. That is, it's what all complimentarians affirm. All right. Clarification two.
30:58 The narrow view tends to speak of roles and the broad tends to speak of God's design. A lot of complimentarians refer to the different callings of men and women as their roles. Even some broad complimentarians do that. I used to do it even as recently as several years ago. And I regret doing that because now I think that the term roles is misleading. Here's why. A typical way to define role is the part that an actor plays in a movie or a play. So Harrison Ford, for example, is talented enough to play the role of Han Solo in Star Wars or or the role of Indiana Jones or the role of Jack Ryan or the role of the president of the United States among
31:46 many other roles. He's a gifted actor who's able to play all these different roles. Because that's the normal way people use the word role. I don't think role is the best word to describe what God calls men and women to do because it makes it sound like what God calls men and women to do is arbitrary, like you can just pretend, just take on the role. Women play one role, men play another role. They just have easily could have switched. Sometimes my daughters when they're young, they'll they'll play husband wife games and it's pretending to be husband and wife and it's like a group of six girls and someone has to be the dad that that's taking on the role.
32:25 That's what's going on there. So instead of using the word role, which you could swap, I prefer to speak of God's design for men and women. The word design is so much better. It emphasizes purpose, plan, intention. For example, a Phillips head screwdriver is a tool that is designed to do something specific to fit snugly into a screw and then turn it. Right now, you could screw a Phillips head screw with a stake knife.
33:03 not going to implicate anyone in my family. But if you do that, you may damage the screw and the knife. When you use a stake knife to screw a screw, you're using a stake knife for something it's not designed for. So when somebody argues, well a woman can take on the role of primary leader in a marriage and family or a woman can take on the role of pastor, a woman can preach a sermon. I would reply, "Yeah, and my stake knife can take on the role of Philips head screwdriver." God designed men and women in specific ways. And what he calls men and women to do ingeniously fits with his design. what God calls men and women
33:51 to do is not an arbitrary role. So, it's fitting to to refer to what God calls us to do as his design. It's how he designed us. That's clarification two. Clarification three, both narrow and broad affirm that women may teach in various ways. There at least five ways that women may teach in a way that honors the Lord. One is explaining scripture privately outside the context of the assembled congregation. I'm thinking Acts 18:26 where Priscilla with her husband Aquilla explained truth to Apollos. That's that's permissible. A second example is from 1 Corinthians 11:4 and5 praying and
34:39 prophesying in the assembled congregation. A third example is Titus 2 3 and 5 women teaching women. A fourth example is women teaching children, both male and female children. Timothy's mother and grandmother taught them the scriptures when Timothy was a child. And a fifth example is from John 4 and Matthew 28. Evangelism. Women may evangelize. So it those are five ways that it it is good and right for women to teach.
35:10 Number four, it might be helpful to suggest some examples of current proponents of narrow and broad complimentarianism. So just remind you here, historically the church has affirmed broad complimentarianism or what I would call biblical patriarchy. Narrow complimentarianism is more recent. So the names I'm going to give you are more recent. Examples of narrow complimentarians today probably include JD Greer, Kathy Keller, Beth Moore, Jen Wilin, Elise Fitzpatrick, and formerly Amy Bird, whom I would now say is indistinguishable from egalitarianism. Examples of broad complimentarians include John Piper, Doug Wilson, Joe Riggnney, Denny Burke,
36:02 Kevin D. Young, Tom Shriner, Rosaria Butterfield, and the pastors of Christ the King Church. Clarification five, there's a spectrum within narrow complimentarianism and within broad complimentarianism. And sometimes it's challenging to distinguish someone as either narrow or broad. So within the narrow view, there are different versions of narrow complimentarianism. For example, there's there's a there's a variety of that view that would say, "Yeah, God requires men and women to to relate differently to each other in marriage, but in the church, no, it's okay for women to be pastors." That's that's a a version of that within broad complimentarianism. John Piper, for
36:51 example, is broad and Wayne Grudum is a little bit narrower. So they would speak differently about God's design for men and women in society. So Gruden would be more inclined to say what exactly specifically explicitly does scripture say about that. And Piper's more willing to reason from principles to society. So here's an example. Piper will argue that it's not fitting for a woman to be a police officer or a drill sergeant. John Calvin puts it a little more starkly. He says that the government of women has always been regarded by all wise persons as a monstrous thing. So Wayne Grudam on the other side uh is uncomfortable arguing like that.
37:34 He'd want to say I don't see scripture explicitly forbidding women from leading a civil government in the new covenant era. So that's just a difference just to be aware of that not all broad complimentarians have the same instincts here. And some within broad complimentarianism are broader than John Piper. An example is Michael Foster and non-tenant. They reject the term complimentarianism. They prefer the term patriarchy. Here's how they define patriarchy. The doctrine that men are made to rule in behalf of their father.
38:08 This naturally begins in their houses and continues out into the larger houses of churches and nations. And this leads to another uh clarification number six. Patriarchy is another term for broad complimentarianism. So let's talk about the word patriarchy. Patriarchy is a compound word. It's got two parts in it. Father rule. Those are the two parts. Patriarchy means father rule. It's right there in the word. So the Greek word patria means fatherhood. The Greek verb arco and the noun aray means rule. So Paul writes for example in Ephesians 3:14 and 15 I bow my knees before the father that's pater it sounds like
38:55 patriarch pat I bow my knee before the father from whom every family patria in heaven and on earth is named. And the ESV's translator's note on that word family says or from whom all fatherhood. The Greek word patria in verse 15 is closely related to the word for father in verse 14. There's something really important to connect between father and fatherhood. Here's how one theologian puts it. God does not reveal himself as father because of some correspondence between himself and human fathers.
39:30 Rather, God gives the name father to humans as an analogy, a reflection of who he is. Human fatherhood is to be learned and patterned after divine fatherhood, not the other way around. So patriarchy means father rule. It's a good word. It occurs in the Bible as patriarch. It's a common word, right? All over the Bible. Father rule. Now, ever since John Piper and Wayne Grudam and others coined the term complimentarianism in 1988, complimentarianism has been a common label that Englishspeaking conservative evangelicals have used for the biblical view of God's design for men and women. I like the term. I think it's a good label. What I like about the label is that it nicely captures what
40:19 God says in Genesis 2:18. It is not good that the man should be alone. I will make him a helper fit for him, a helper corresponding to him, a helper who corresponds to him, a helper who compliments him. Complimentarianism. But self-identified complimentarians have become less broad and more narrow to the point that right now it's no longer helpful when someone tries to distinguish his view by saying, "Oh, I'm a complimentarian." There's always you need a follow-up question. What kind? A lot of people who claim to be complimentarian are actually just an eyelash short of being evangelical
41:07 feminists. So the label complimentarian is not as useful as it once was and that's why some are preferring the label patriarchy or to clarify biblical patriarchy. Rosar Rosaria Butterfield is an example of a broad complimentarian who now prefers the label biblical patriarchy. Now some broad complimentarians don't like the label patriarchy. I'm friends with some of them and we have a friendly debate about whether we should use that label patriarchy. So here's what some of them argue. They think that patriarchy has insurmountably negative connotations. They think that the word is irredeemably tainted, inseparably associated with authoritarianism. So that's one view and
41:57 I respect that, but I respectfully disagree with it. I think that both labels are fitting. The two labels emphasize different truths. The label complimentarianism emphasizes that God designed men and women to complement each other. Men and women are not interchangeable. That's true. The label patriarchy emphasizes that God designed fathers to rule. God designed both complimentarity and hierarchy. Now, this is noteworthy. I'm going to show you a book cover. The book Discovering Biblical Equality is a prominent textbook that defends Evangelical Feminism. It responds to the 1991 book that John Piper and Wayne Grudum edited,
42:47 Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, a response to evangelical feminism. They wrote that book, then this was the response. Now I just want you to notice something. The subtitle of this second edition is complimentarity without hierarchy. Egalitarians love complimentarity as they define it. What they hate is hierarchy. That's the debated issue. The key issue is hierarchy. And that's why I think the label patriarchy is fitting. But what matters most is not the label, but what we mean by it. Final clarification number seven. Narrow
43:36 complimentarianism seems to have more in common with evangelical feminism than it does with biblical patriarchy. The label complimentarianism for both narrow and broad might mislead you to think, "Oh, those are basically the same thing." Very different from evangelical feminism. Well, actually, I think the narrow view has more in common with evangelical feminism than it does with patriarchy. Let me show you this. So, here's a way to compare four views on men and women. So, here are the four views. non-eangelical feminism, evangelical feminism, and then narrow and broad. Okay, those are the four views we're and we're going to answer some questions here. Question one, does
44:23 the Bible teach patriarchy? We got yes, no, no, yes. Question two, is the Bible correct? Got no, yes, yes, yes. Is what the Bible teaches good? No, yes, yes, yes. Is patriarchy good? No. No, no, yes. Now just just stand back and and look at that. Those middle two basically answer the questions the same way. There's a lot of overlap between those. It seems to me that narrow complimentarianism has more in common with evangelical feminism than it does with biblical patriarchy.
45:04 And this becomes more evident when you distinguish between evangelical feminism initially in the 70s, 80s, and 90s and evangelical feminism today. They're not the same. So today, many narrow complimentarians basically are functional egalitarians. In 2024, Brian Laughlin and Doug Ponder wrote an insightful article titled Complimentarians and the Rise of Second-Wave Feminism. And one of my takeaways from reading their article is that there are several views on hierarchy and complimentarity among evangelical feminists and complimentarians. Let me show you one more table. I like tables. This is the last table. Okay, this is this is my own synthesis, but it's in line with their
45:52 article. So let's we'll go view by view. There are four views here. Uh the biblical patriarchy view or the the broad view. Uh when it comes to hierarchy, this view affirms hierarchy broadly in the home, church and society. And it affirms complimentarity in the sense that complimentary differences between men and women are part of God's good design. These complimentary differences are reasons supporting the rules. View two, narrow complimentarianism. This view narrowly, barely affirms hierarchy and only in two specific areas, marriage and and the church. But for marriage, it's really emphasizing mutual submission. And in the church, it's saying, well, only qualified men may be
46:37 pastors, but a woman may do anything an unordained man may do. And Laughlin and Ponder uh say that this view is complimentarianism. It's complimentarian in name only. It treats men and women as interchangeable in principle so that God's rules seem arbitrary. Then this third view is egalitarianism initially versus increasingly now. So initially this view strongly rejected hierarchy in the home, church and society. And that's true for for egalitarianism now. But here's the difference between egalitarianism initially and increasingly now.
47:18 Initially this view wanted to affirm complimentarity. Remember that book title that said complimentarity without hierarchy. Well, today they don't talk that way. Uh there's a third edition of that same book that dropped that language alto together and said that egalitarians now have different opinions on gender related complimentarity. And I read that in the preface of their third edition. And I I wrote in my book, as the culture changes, so do so do theologies that accommodate the culture. So that is my attempt to explain a spectrum of views on manhood and womanhood and to explain two different kinds of complimentarianism.
48:06 So in this first sermon, I have attempted to lay a foundation that I will build on in the next eight sermons. In the sermon next week, God willing, I plan to give five exhortations regarding God's design for men and women. And then in sermons three and four, I plan to give six reasons for biblical patriarchy. And then after that, we're going to dive into 1 Timothy 2:9-15. Let's pray. Father, as we consider your good design for men and women, would you please bless our study? Please help us accurately understand what your design for men and women is. Please help us understand what 1 Timothy 2:9-15 means and how it fits
48:57 with what you've revealed elsewhere in scripture and nature. Please help us recognize false teaching about men and women as deadly errors. Please help us affirm that your design for men and women is good. Please help us celebrate that your design for men and women is beautiful and true. Please help us obey you as men and women. And please strengthen our church's immune system. We ask all this in the name of Christ the King. Amen.
No transcript available.
