Transcript
0:28 Let's pray together. Father, as we consider your words to us in 1 Timothy 2, may the words of my mouth and the meditations of all our hearts be acceptable in your sight, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. We ask in the name of Jesus. Amen. Please open your Bible to 1 Timothy chapter 2. 1 Timothy 2. As I preach through 1 Timothy, the next text in our series is 1 Timothy 2 verse 4. I'm going to start reading in verse one so that you can see how verse 4 connects to our text from last week,
1:17 verses 1 to3. So 1 Timothy chapter 2 and we'll begin reading in verse uh verse one. 1 Timothy 2:1. First of all, then I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people, for kings, and all who are in high positions, that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way. This is good and it is pleasing in the sight of God our savior who desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the
2:05 truth. So our text last week was verses 1 through3. Why should the church pray for all kinds of people specifically for government authorities? And the answer we saw last week is for one purpose and two reasons. The purpose is that we may lead a peaceful, quiet, godly, dignified life. Reason one, this is good. Reason two, it pleases God our savior. Now, we're going to consider verse four. God, our savior, desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth. So, I'd like to preach to you from 1 Timothy 2:4 on this subject. God wants all kinds of people
2:58 to be saved. I plan to unpack this passage by asking three questions. First, why does it please God when the church prays for government authorities? Second, does desires all people to be saved mean that God wants all people without exception to be saved? And third, how should we apply the truth that God wants all kinds of people to be saved? And to remind you, the outline is on your worship service guide on one of the pages there. The text for this sermon is only verse four, that God desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.
3:37 We're slowing down to address only verse four because that statement in verse four raises some theological questions that we should wrestle with. We'll spend most of our time on question two. Let's begin with question one. Why does it please God when the church prays for government authorities? Verse four says that God our savior quote desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth end quote. How does that connect to what comes before it? And the answer to this question is is fairly straightforward. Verse four gives a reason for the second half of verse three. The second half of verse three says that it pleases God when the
4:26 church prays for government authorities. The reason it pleases God when we pray for government authorities the way that Pastor Dustin prayed this morning. The reason that pleases God is that God wants all kinds of people to be saved. Or stated another way, God wants all kinds of people to understand and believe the good news about Jesus. That's what that phrase come to the knowledge of the truth means. to come to a saving faith in Christ. So question one, why does it please God when the church prays for government authorities? Answer, because God wants all kinds of people to be saved. God wants all kinds of people to come to the knowledge of the truth.
5:08 That's how verse four fits in the flow of what Paul is arguing. Answering question one is relatively easy. Not question two. Question two is more challenging. So, I'll spend most of the sermon on question two. Does desires all people to be saved mean that God wants all people without exception to be saved? So, in this sermon, I'm going to be using these two phrases, all without exception and all without distinction. So, I want to make sure right up front we understand what I mean by those phrases. I'll I'll illustrate it with some examples. To illustrate all without exception, consider this sentence. All squares have four equal
5:58 straight sides and four right angles. So the word all in that sentence means all without exception. All means every single square. There's not one square that doesn't have four equal straight sides and four right angles. That's all without exception. Now look at the this other one here. Cars come in all shapes and sizes. Well, the word all there means all kinds of shapes and sizes. That illustrates all without distinction. See the difference? Here's another example.
6:35 1 Timothy 6:10 in the King James version says, "The love of money is the root of all evil." It sounds like all without exception. Most English translations say something like this. The love of money is a root of all kinds of evil, all without distinction. So when it comes to the issue we're considering this morning, all without exception would mean God desires every single person in world history to be saved. There's not one person in the history of the world whom God does not want to be saved. That would be all without exception. All without distinction would be this. God desires all kinds of people to be saved. You with me on the distinctions
7:21 there? Okay. Now, there are at least two viable ways to explain what Paul means in verse four when he says that God, our savior, desires all people to be saved. I'm going to call them solution one and solution two. Solution one is God desires that all people without exception be saved in one sense and he doesn't desire it in another sense. In other words, this view distinguishes two aspects of God's will, namely what God desires and what God decrees. I agree with this theological uh framework, this perspective. But the question is whether
8:09 this is the correct way to understand what Paul intends to communicate in 1 Timothy 2:4. So that's an open question. But before we we decide that I'd like to explain this perspective so you can weigh if this is the best way to take 1 Timothy 2:4. I'll explain this perspective with three statements. First, we must distinguish two aspects of God's will. So God has one will and it appears to us to have two aspects in order for us finite creatures to make sense of specific statements in scripture. We must distinguish two aspects of God's will. Two ways that God wills. You could describe them like this. What God would like to see happen and what God actually wills to happen.
8:57 So this table illustrates with biblical examples those two ways that God wills what God would like to see happen. Here's an example. Thus says the Lord, the God of Israel, let my people go. That was the word of the Lord to Pharaoh. That's what God wanted to happen. But that's not what happened initially. And and here's what God actually decreed. I will harden his heart. The Lord hardened the heart of Pharaoh. So distinction what God would like to see happen. what he actually decrees wills to happen. Or here's another example. Ezekiel 33, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way and live. So in one sense, God has no pleasure when the wicked die. In 1st
9:40 Samuel 2, the sons of Eli would not listen to the voice of their father, for it was the will, that's the same word over here, that's pleasure. It was the will of the Lord to put them to death. And here's the supreme example. God doesn't want people to murder. When you murder, that's sinful killing. You're guilty before God. You're culpable. And that's even the case with the death of Jesus. You, Acts 2 says, you crucified and killed Jesus by the hands of lawless men. So that the men who killed Jesus were guilty for killing Jesus.
10:16 On the other hand, at the same time, Jesus was delivered up according to the definite plan and fornowledge of God. Again, that's illustrating what God would like to happen, what he decrees to happen, what he actually wills to happen. Now, here's how this works out for the topic we're considering. God genuinely desires all people without exception to be saved. It's not the will of my father who's in heaven that one of these little ones should perish. And God sovereignly chose to save only some people. Jesus prayed, "I thank you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, that you've hidden these things from the wise and understanding and revealed them to little children. Yes,
10:55 Father, for such was your gracious will." Theologians distinguish these two aspects of God's will with several labels. Here are some of them. commanded will and decreed will. The commanded will is what God commands, like don't murder. Doesn't always happen. His decreed will is what God decrees. It always happens. No exceptions. Or here's another term, moral will versus sovereign will. God's moral will is what we should obey. God tells us what is right and wrong. And we often don't obey God. That's not obeying his moral will.
11:35 His sovereign will is what he ordains. It always happens. Or another distinction is revealed will and secret or hidden will. His revealed will is what he tells us we must do. It's what he's revealed to us to do. His secret or hidden will is what he does not normally reveal ahead of time. And here's an illustration that John Piper uses. looking at a painful or wicked event through a narrow lens. So God sees the tragedy or sin for what it is in itself and he's angered and grieved and looking at a painful or wicked event through a wide angle lens.
12:17 God sees the tragedy or the sin in relation to everything leading up to it and everything flowing out from it. He sees it in all the connections and effects that form a pattern or mosaic stretching into eternity. And that mosaic with all of its good and evil parts, he does delight in. So, does God desire that all people without exception be saved? And I'd say according to this view, this framework, yes, in the sense that he would like to see that happen. No, in the sense that he did not actually decree that to happen. We're not universalists. We don't believe. The Bible teaches that everyone will be saved. We reject universalism. Many are called, but few are
13:06 chosen. So, we must distinguish two aspects of God's will. Here's a second statement for this solution. God values something else more highly than saving all people without exception. I'm going to refer here to two different theological perspectives called Armenianism and Calvinism. They're just nicknames for different uh viewpoints that theologians have on what the Bible teaches about how God saves sinners and why God saves sinners.
13:36 Before I tell you how they're different, I'll just mention how they agree. They agree in some significant ways. Armenians and Calvinists agree that not all people without exception will be saved. They're not universalists. We agree in some sense God wills in two distinct ways. what he what he desires at one level, what he ordains at another. And third, they agree God does not save all people without exception because God values something else more highly than saving all people without exception. But they disagree on what that is. What does God value more highly than saving all people without exception? What's that something
14:25 else? According to our minionism, God more highly values a genuinely loving relationship which requires us to have a free will in the sense that we can equally make alternative choices. That is, you can choose to accept Christ or to reject Christ. According to Calvinism, God more highly values displaying his glory in mercy and wrath and receiving all the glory for sovereignly saving individuals. So I think that according to the Armenian view, it implies that our choice is decisive or ultimate. What we choose ultimately decides the outcome. I
15:15 believe the Bible teaches that God's choice, not our choice, is the deciding factor. And that helps us make sense of a lot of passages. An example is in second Timothy 2. Paul writes, "God may perhaps grant them, give them repentance leading to a knowledge of the truth, and they may come to their senses and escape from the snare of the devil." Repentance, turning from our sins to Christ at conversion. That's a gift from God. He gives us. And here's a third statement that builds on those first two. God's desire to save people can be genuine even if he has decreed not to save them. And that's a jarring statement to some. So an example might help illustrate what uh I'm I'm saying
16:05 here to distinguish two ways that God wills and that it's not double speak. It's not disingenuous. And just before I share an illustration, which will help, I concede upfront that analogies about a human's will break down because they can't flawlessly illustrate God's will. So many have confused and mutually inconsistent feelings. You know what it's like to have these mutually inconsistent feelings inside you? God's never like that. Okay, so here's the illustration, and it's a true story. It's about a guy named Miguel Mendez who was head coach of a high school baseball team in Tampa, Florida. And while he was in that capacity, he had to make a difficult decision. He called it probably the
16:49 hardest thing I've had to do in my life. So, on the one hand, he wanted his oldest son to play on his baseball team. His name is Miguel Jr. On the other hand, he wanted to be a successful, fair head coach of a program that had just won the state championship in Florida in 2019 and that collegiate baseball had ranked as the number one high school team in America. So, he's he's the coach, head coach. He wants his son to be on his team and he wants to be first place and he wants to be fair and successful.
17:24 So what he did is he decided to cut his son from the team during baseball triyouts of his son's junior year. And you'd say, "Well, then that father didn't really want his son to play on the team. That was a fake desire. It was a false desire. Otherwise, the son would be on the team." No, no, no. He just more highly valued being a successful and impartial head coach. that illustrates that it's possible for a person to have two genuine competing desires and to act in accord with one desire without in any way making the other desire fake or false. So in a similar way, Jesus is not pretending to feel compassion when he laments, "Oh Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that
18:13 kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it. How often would I have gathered your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings and you were not willing." But it doesn't necessarily follow from that prayer that our free choice must be decisive or ultimate in order for Jesus's compassion to be genuine or for God's love to be genuine. It's sensible to distinguish two ways that God wills. So I agree that there are two aspects of God's will. God desires that all people without exception be saved in one sense and he doesn't desire it in another sense. He doesn't ordain it. I think that's an accurate and helpful framework and it might be what Paul
19:02 intends in 1 Timothy 2:4 when he says that God, our savior, desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth. That might be what Paul means. Personally, I'm not convinced that Paul intends to communicate that truth in this passage. I think there's a better way. what I'm calling solution two where all people means all kinds of people. According to this view, Paul intends to communicate in 1 Timothy 2:4 that God wants all kinds of people to be saved. In particular, people from different ethnicities, Jews and Gentiles, and people from different social classes, government authorities, and common folks. I think this is the correct way to interpret all people in 1
19:49 Timothy 2:4 for seven reasons. I'll go quickly. Reason one is the meaning of the word all. The phrase all men often means all kinds of people. Means that in Paul's writings and the rest of the New Testament, it doesn't always or even normally refer to all without exception. I demonstrated this in last week's sermon. I won't repeat all the arguments here. When people counter to this and say, "Well, all means all." And what they mean is all means all without exception as if it's self-evident. That's a logical fallacy called begging the question. It assumes what you need to prove. The word all might mean all without exception in a particular context, but it's not
20:38 convincing just to assert that. You have to demonstrate it with arguments that support that reading. A second argument is that the historical cultural context of first Timothy supports that all means all kinds of. So in first Timothy, do you remember what Paul is combating throughout this letter? He's combating false teaching. And most New Testament commentators agree that this false teaching is some kind of exclusivism heresy that salvation is for only certain people like Jews and not for other people like non-Jews or for really bad sinners like Paul. Paul begins the letter by urging Timothy to charge certain persons not to teach any different doctrine nor to devote themselves to myths and endless
21:24 genealogies. myths and endless genealogies. What does that mean? Uh, in my sermon on 1 Timothy 1:3-7, I argue that it likely means to be preoccupied with pretend stories or legends about people in Old Testament genealogies. And I suspect that because 1 Timothy 1:7 says that these people wanted to be teachers of the law of the Mosaic law. And Titus 1:14 refers to Jewish myths. And in Titus 3:9, Paul connects genealogies with quarrels about the Mosaic law. He says, "Avoid foolish controversies, genealogies, dissensions, and quarrels about the law, for they are unprofitable and worthless." So in the historical cultural context of first Timothy, Paul's opposing false teaching
22:13 that's distinctly Jewish. And it was really common for Jews to regard Israel as God's people to the exclusion of Gentiles. Paul combats this wrong teaching in First Timothy by emphasizing the universal nature of Christ's atonement. And when I say universal, I don't mean universalism. I don't mean that God's going to save all people without exception. I mean universal in the sense that God wants to save all kinds of people throughout the world, not just Jews. That's reason number two. Number three is the immediate literary context of 1 Timothy 2. You have your Bible open to 1 Timothy 2. Look at verses 1 and two. Paul uses the phrase all men there to refer to all kinds of people. We
23:00 should pray for all kinds of people, for government authorities, kings, and all kinds of ethnicities. In other words, Paul's saying in verses 1 and two, pray for all kinds of people, particularly specifically for government authorities. I think he's using all people in verse four the same way he's using it in verse two. And then you have your Bible open there. Look down to verse 5. In verse 5, Paul gives evidence that God desires all people to be saved. There is one God and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus. In other words, there's not just one one way to God for Jews and another way to God for non-Jews. There's just one way to God.
23:43 And God wants all kinds of people to be saved, not just Jews. If there was more than one God, then there'd be a God for Jews and a God for the Romans and a God for the Chinese. That's not the way it is. And then in verse six, Paul says that Christ Jesus gave himself as a ransom for all and that this testimony is given at the proper time. At this point in the history of salvation, God's people are not primarily Jews, but both Jews and Gentiles. And in verse 7, Paul says that God appointed him to be a teacher of the Gentiles. Why is he emphasizing Gentiles here in this passage? Because God wants all kinds of people to be saved, Jews and Gentiles. In verse 7, he says, "I'm
24:25 telling the truth. I'm not lying. This was an extremely controversial matter." So, he's emphasizing this. And here's an important connection to kind of wrap this up here with the the context. In Acts 22, Paul's describing how God called him to serve the Gentiles. And he says that Ananas told him, this is Acts 22:15. You will be a witness for him to everyone. That's everyone. That's the phrase, all men. Same phrase from from Acts, same phrase as 1 Timothy uh 2:4.
24:52 You'll be a witness to everyone of what you've seen and heard. Who is that? Everyone. A few verses later in Acts 22:21, God says, "Go, for I will send you far away to the Gentiles." everyone, all men, Gentiles, same people. That's in Acts 22. Paul's mission to the Gentiles reflects Christ's intention to die, not just for Jews, but also for non-Jews. So, there's a a New Testament scholar named Steve Ba who who paraphrases what Paul is saying here. I think he gets it right. Here's his paraphrase. Uh this is of uh of 1 Timothy 2. If God is one and there's only one mediator with one way of redemption and if God has chosen me to save some of the
25:42 gentile peoples in the scope of my apostolic mission, then we can legitimately conclude that God desires any sort of person to be saved regardless of ethnic origin. This was true in Old Testament times only on rare occasions, but now it's the norm by which the worldwide missionary effort of Christianity must be guided. I think that's right. That's reason three. Reason four is the larger literary context of the pastoral epistles. The pastoral epistles are Paul's first and second letters to Timothy and Titus. And in Titus 2, Paul instructs about different categories of people.
26:17 Older men, older women, young men, younger men, excuse me, young women, younger men, and bondervants. So after talking about all these categories in Titus 2:11 he says for the grace of God has appeared bringing salvation for all people. All people same phrase that we have in 1 Timothy 2 all people. Paul again is using that phrase to refer to all kinds of people not all people without exception. And that sentence that begins in Titus 2:1 says in verse 14 that Christ gave himself for us to redeem us that is us believers.
26:51 That's reason four. Reason five is the larger literary context of Paul's letters. So first Timothy is one of Paul's 13 letters. His most famous letter is Romans which includes this statement. Is God the God of Jews only? Is he not the God of Gentiles also? Yes, of Gentiles also. Since God is one who will justify the circumcised, that's that's the Jews by faith and the uncircumcised that's the Gentiles through faith.
27:22 So what he says here in Romans 3 is remarkably similar to 1 Timothy 2 5 and 6 when he says for there there's one God and there's one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus who gave himself as a ransom for all. Paul's point is that there's not one God for Jews and another God for Gentiles. No, there's only one God and Christ Jesus is the mediator who gave himself as a ransom for Jews and Gentiles. That phrase gave himself as a ransom for all does not mean that Christ died for every single person in exactly the same way. A ransom for all means all kinds of people both Jews and Gentiles.
27:59 That's why he says there's only one God. Reason six is the larger literary context of the New Testament. So other New Testament passages emphasize that God is saving individuals from different language groups throughout the world. Here's an example from Revelation 5:9. By your blood, you ransomed people for God from from every tribe and language and people and nation. That same universal scope is present in 1 Timothy 2. To say that God wants to save all kinds of people does not mean he's actually ransomed every single person in the history of the world without exception.
28:41 But to say that God wants to save all kinds of people is consistent with Revelation 5:9 that Christ ransomed people for God from every kind of people. My final argument is systematic theology. Systematic theology answers the question, what does the whole Bible say about fill in the blank? Systematic theology attempts to correlate everything that God has revealed to show that it's logically and beautifully coherent. God does not contradict himself. He's not illogical. There may be mystery involved, but never illogic. So, what does the whole Bible say about whom Christ intended to die for? 1 Timothy 2:6, for example, says that Christ Jesus gave himself as a ransom
29:29 for all. What does the word for mean? Does it mean in the place of? And what does ransom mean? Does it mean that Christ offered himself in order to take the punishment in the place of? I think it does. In other words, it's an actual ransom, not a potential ransom. And if that's the case, what does that say about what all means in this context? Did Christ actually take the punishment in the place of all people without exception? If that's the case, if if if Christ actually paid for the penalty of every single person without exception, then nobody would need to go to hell because Christ paid everyone's penalty.
30:18 That's the reason I think Jesus did not die for every single person in exactly the same way. So there are two basic ways that theologians understand what Christ intended to accomplish when he saved sinners. According to Armenianism, the intention of Christ's atonement is general. That is, it provides salvation for all people without exception. Christ's atonement provides payment for the sins of all people without exception. But God applies it to only those who repent and believe, that is the elect. According to Calvinism, the intention of Christ's atonement is definite. Some call this limited atonement. I prefer the term definite atonement. It provides and accomplishes
30:59 salvation for only the elect. Christ's atonement provides payment for the sins of only the elect. And God applies it to only the elect. The pastors, not all the members, but the pastors of Christ the King Church affirm definite atonement. That is Christ intended for his death to actually save a definite group of people. So when we answer the question, what does the whole Bible say about the intention of Christ to die for people? We must factor in that scripture repeatedly emphasizes that Jesus saves his people from their sin. He died for his bride. He died for his sheep. The father, the son, and the spirit together save a particular
31:50 people. The father elected them. The son lived, died and rose again for them. And the spirit regenerates them. same group of people. That is, here's how I like to summarize it. Salvation planned, salvation accomplished, and salvation applied. The father chose to save a particular group of people. And the spirit regenerates every single person in that group without exception. It would be putting the members of the trinity at odds with one another if Christ actually paid the penalty for every single person in world history without exception. The father, son, and spirit work in unity to sha to save the sheep, not the goats. That trinitarian
32:39 argument I'm giving here is not original to me. One who made it made it famous is the Puritan John Owen in his book The Death of Death in the Death of Christ. Now, I'm I'm going quickly here. If you'd like to study this topic more, a good entry point for you I'd recommend is Mike Ricardi. It's R I C A R DI. He wrote his PhD dissertation on this topic and it's phenomenal. The published version is called to save sinners. But you can go to sermonaudio.com the search on Mike Ricardi and there's a a playlist titled O Perfect Redemption 14 sermons in which he teaches on Christ's atonement. It's phenomenal. So I'd encourage you to check that out. So question two, does God desire all people
33:27 to be saved in in the sense that he wants all people without exception to be saved? So here's my answer. No. It probably means that God wants all kinds of people to be saved. That's how I take it in 1 Timothy 2:4. I think solution two is more compelling than solution one. But whether you take solution one or two, I think we should be able to apply this passage in the same way. And that leads to our third question. How should we apply the truth that God wants all kinds of people to be saved?
33:59 1 Timothy 2:4 means that God wants all kinds of people to be saved. God wants to save people from every ethnicity, Jew and Gentile. God wants to save people from every class, king and commoner. God wants to save people from every economic status, rich and poor. God wants to save people from every social standing, famous and obscure. God wants to save people from every moral status, the seemingly virtuous and the villain. God wants to save people from both sexes, male and female. We should never look at a fellow human being and think God couldn't save that person or I don't think God would want to save that kind of person. No, God
34:48 wants to save all kinds of people. Further, Christians should reject what's called hypercalvinism. Phil Johnson helpfully defines what a hypercalvinist is. A hyperalcalvinist is someone who either denies that the gospel call applies to all who hear or denies that faith is the duty of every sinner or denies that the gospel makes any offer of Christ salvation or mercy to the non-elect or denies that the offer of divine mercy is free and universal or denies that there's such a thing as common grace.
35:28 or denies that God has any sort of love for the non-elect. All five varieties of hypercalvinism undermine evangelism or twist the gospel message. So in contrast to this false teaching, we should believe that the gospel call applies to all who hear and repentance and faith is the duty of every sinner. And the good news about Jesus is a genuine offer to every single person whether God has predestined him or not. And common grace exists. That is God graciously gives blessings to people apart from
36:15 salvation. And God has a sort of love for the non-elect in that he is gracious and patient and merciful. This is actually a big issue for the famous preacher Charles Spurgeon. Historian Ian Murray wrote a good book about it titled Spurgeon versus Hypercalvinism, the battle for gospel preaching. So, back to question three. How should we apply the truth that God wants all kinds of people to be saved? Answer, we should proclaim the gospel to all people without distinction. That applies to people in our households, our church community, our neighborhoods, our cities, our state, our nation, and every other ethnicity in the world. God wants to save people from every ethnicity,
37:04 American and foreigner. By the way, I keep using that word ethnicity instead of race. I'm doing that on purpose because I believe that we shouldn't look at the color of people's skin and call that a race. There are two races. Those who are in Adam and those who are in Christ. And there are many ethnicities. God wants to save people from every economic status. The wealthy, middle class, the poor. God wants to save people from every moral status.
37:29 Those who are seemingly virtuous, those who are villains. That's the universal scope of God's saving desire. Christ is in the process of ransoming people for God by his death. People from every tribe and language and people and nation. And we get to be part of that. We get to be some of the people he ransoms. We get to be people who broadcast the good news that God wants to save all kinds of people. Let's pray. Father, thank you that your plan to save sinners is global in scope.
38:08 You're not saving just a few people from one geographical area or just one ethnicity. You're saving people from every tribe and language and people and nation. So, as people who live at the end of the earth in the Twin Cities far away from Jerusalem, we are grateful for your plan to save all kinds of people. We thank you that you want to save all kinds of people. So, would you please enable us to proclaim the gospel to all kinds of people. We ask in the name of Christ the King. Amen.
No transcript available.
