Listen on

What Does It Mean to Be Gentle? Qualifications for a Pastor, Part 2 of 6

Transcript

1 Timothy

01

Final Charge and Benediction

Andy Naselli

May 10, 2026
01

Four Charges to the Rich

Andy Naselli

Apr 26, 2026
01

Nine Reasons to Praise God the Father

Andy Naselli

Apr 19, 2026
01

Five Charges to the Man of God

Andy Naselli

Apr 12, 2026
01

Two Exhortations About Riches

Andy Naselli

Mar 29, 2026
01

What Does the Bible Teach About Money and Possessions?

Andy Naselli

Mar 22, 2026
01

Eight Marks of a False Teacher

Andy Naselli

Mar 15, 2026
01

(Part 3 of 3): What Does the Bible Say About Work?

Andy Naselli

Mar 1, 2026
01

(Part 2 of 3): What God Commands Slaves to Do and Why

Andy Naselli

Feb 22, 2026
01

(Part 1 of 3): Does the Bible Promote Slavery?

Andy Naselli

Feb 8, 2026
01

How to Treat Accusations Against an Elder

Andy Naselli

Feb 1, 2026
01

Pay Your Elders

Andy Naselli

Jan 25, 2026
01

Honor Widows

Andy Naselli

Jan 18, 2026
01

Manifested in the Flesh (Christmas)

Andy Naselli

Dec 21, 2025
01

How to Exhort or Appeal to Older Men, Younger Men, Older Women, and Younger Women

Andy Naselli

Dec 14, 2025
01

What Paul Charges Timothy to Do, Part 2 of 2

Andy Naselli

Nov 30, 2025
01

What Paul Charges Timothy to Do, Part 1 of 2

Andy Naselli

Nov 9, 2025
01

Some Will Depart From the Faith

Andy Naselli

Oct 26, 2025
01

The Purpose of What Paul Instructs Us in 1 Timothy

Andy Naselli

Oct 19, 2025
01

What Must Deacons Be? (Part 2 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Oct 12, 2025
01

Six Questions About Deacons (Part 1 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Oct 5, 2025
01

He Must Manage His Own Household Well (Part 2 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Sep 7, 2025
01

He Must Manage His Own Household Well (Part 1 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Aug 31, 2025
01

Not a Lover of Money: Four Exhortations About Wealth

Andy Naselli

Aug 10, 2025
01

What Does It Mean to Be Gentle? Qualifications for a Pastor, Part 2 of 6

Andy Naselli

Aug 3, 2025
01

An Overseer Must Be Above Reproach: Qualifications for a Pastor, Part 1 of 6

Andy Naselli

Jul 27, 2025
01

How to Discern If a Man Should Be a Pastor

Andy Naselli

Jul 13, 2025
01

What Shepherds Do

Andy Naselli

Jul 6, 2025
01

A Woman Will Be Saved Through Childbearing

Andy Naselli

Jun 22, 2025
01

Responding to Objections to What Paul Teaches in 1 Timothy 2:11–14

Andy Naselli

Jun 15, 2025
01

Two Reasons a Woman Must Learn Quietly and Submissively

Andy Naselli

May 25, 2025
01

A Woman Must Learn Quietly and Submissively

Andy Naselli

May 18, 2025
01

How Should Women Dress?

Andy Naselli

May 4, 2025
01

Part 4 of 4—Three More Arguments for Biblical Patriarchy

Andy Naselli

Apr 27, 2025
01

Part 3 of 4—Three Arguments for Biblical Patriarchy

Andy Naselli

Apr 13, 2025
01

God’s Good Design for Men and Women: Part 2 of 4—Five Exhortations

Andy Naselli

Apr 6, 2025
01

God’s Good Design for Men and Women: Part 1 of 4—A Spectrum of Views and Two Types of

Andy Naselli

Mar 30, 2025
01

Evidence That God Wants All Kinds of People to Be Saved

Andy Naselli

Mar 16, 2025
01

God Wants All Kinds of People to Be Saved

Andy Naselli

Mar 9, 2025
01

Why the Church Should Pray for Government Authorities

Andy Naselli

Mar 2, 2025
01

The Charge to Reject False Teaching

Andy Naselli

Feb 16, 2025
01

Hail to the King!

Andy Naselli

Feb 2, 2025
01

How to Use the Law Lawfully

Andy Naselli

Jan 26, 2025
01

Warning Against Teaching False Doctrines

Andy Naselli

Jan 19, 2025
01

Introducing 1 Timothy: Fight the Good Fight of the Faith

Andy Naselli

Jan 12, 2025

Transcript

0:09 Father, as we consider qualifications for a pastor in 1 Timothy 3, would you please enlighten our eyes through your spirit to understand your words? And would you please equip us for every good work? We ask in the name of Jesus. Amen. >> Amen. Please open your Bible to 1 Timothy 3. 1 Timothy chapter 3. As I preach through 1 Timothy, the next text in our series is 1 Timothy 3:3, specifically three of the qualifications there. But let's read verses 1-7 and then focus on verse three. 1 Timothy 3, we'll start reading in verse 1.

0:57 The saying is trustworthy. If anyone or any man aspires to the office of overseer, he desires a noble task. Therefore, an overseer must be above reproach. the husband of one wife, sober-minded, self-controlled, respectable, hospitable, able to teach, not a drunkard, not violent, but gentle, not quarrelome, not a lover of money. He must manage his own household well with all dignity, keeping his children submissive. For if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how will he care for God's church? He must not be a recent convert or he may become puffed up with conceit and fall into the condemnation of the devil. Moreover, he must be well thought of by outsiders so

1:48 that he may not fall into disgrace into a snare of the devil. Last week, we considered the first seven qualifications. In this sermon, we're going to look at the next three. not violent but gentle, not quarrelome. And those three qualifications seem to be different ways of stating the same basic virtue. Not this, but that and not this either. So negative, positive, negative. I think it's relatively easy to say what not violent means and what not quarrelome means. I think it's much harder to say what gentle means. And if we can precisely

2:36 articulate what it means for a man to be gentle, I think we can better understand all three of these qualities. So I would like to preach to you from 1 Timothy 3:3 on this subject. What does it mean to be gentle? Everybody agrees that gentleness is good. It's a good virtue. It's virtuous for a man to be gentle. In fact, gentleness is a virtue that God requires of all Christians. All Christians should value gentleness and grow in gentleness.

3:10 Here's just a little sampling from the New Testament. Jesus taught, "Blessed are the meek or the gentle." The NASBY translates it, "For they will inherit the earth." The fruit of the spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control. God exhorts us in Ephesians 1, walk in a manner worthy of the calling to which you've been called with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love. God commands us in Colossians 3, put on then as God's chosen ones, holy and beloved, compassionate hearts, kindness, humility, meekness, and patience, sparing with one another. At the end of our letter, First Timothy, Paul

3:56 commands, "As for you, oh man of God, pursue righteousness, godliness, faith, love, steadfastness, gentleness." Pursue gentleness. That's a command. Peter tells wives that a gentle and quiet spirit is very precious in God's sight. And God commands all of you, let your reasonleness or gentleness, your graciousness be known to everyone. That's just a sampling. The point is repeatedly God commands us to be gentle. That much is clear.

4:30 Here's the challenging part. What does that mean? What does it mean to be gentle? And what does it mean for a man to be gentle? Is a gentleman, it's a good word, isn't it? A gentleman. Is a gentleman a soft man? Is it sinful for a man to be aggressive? What exactly does the Bible say about gentleness? It's crucial when we answer that question, we focus on what is gentleness according to the Bible, not what is gentleness according to our modern cultural sensibilities. So, I'm going to attempt to answer that question. What does gentleness mean according to the Bible? By asking and

5:20 answering seven probing questions. And these are on your worship service guide. The outline is there. Question one, how do you figure out what the word gentle means in the Bible? How how do we answer this question? So, in order to discover what the Bible says about gentleness, a word study on gentleness is a good place to start. So, here's a basic way to do a word study. First, you want to choose a word or a concept to study. I've chosen gentleness. And then you want to study all the relevant Bible passages that address that that topic, that word or concept. Then you want to discover that word's range of meaning because words don't always mean exactly the same thing. And then determine what the word

6:05 most likely means in key passages. There are a lot of dangers to doing word studies, but if you do it responsibly, a word study is enormously fruitful. And in this case, it's challenging because there's not just one Hebrew word and one Greek word that our English translations render gentle. Can you guess how many there are? There are a cluster of at least 13 different words. So, there are five Hebrew words and eight Greek words and they occur a lot.

6:36 So, I did an exhaustive and exhausting word study on gentleness. I looked them all up. I'll spare you the details, but the gist is I carefully studied every single passage that uses the word or concept for gentleness. Then I reflected on those various passages and I attempted to synthesize them. That's what I'm planning to unfold. That synthesis, I plan to unfold that in the rest of this sermon. So, question one, how do you figure out what gentle means in the Bible? Start by carefully studying every occurrence of the word for gentle in the Bible. Question two, what is gentleness like? and not like according to the Bible. So, as I carefully studied all these passages on

7:20 gentleness in the Bible, I discovered the range of meanings, I determined what these words for gentleness most likely mean in key passages. But what most helped me define the word was meditating on pictures or illustrations for gentleness. I'm going to show you 10 of those. In these 10 illustrations, the Bible compares and contrasts gentleness. In other words, God tells us gentleness is like this. It's not like this. So, I'll show you those 10 illustrations in a table.

7:57 First, Isaiah 8:6 says, "The waters of Shiloh flow gently or slowly." So running water can flow gently or violently. So gentleness is like a slowly flowing stream. Gentleness is not like dangerously surging rapids. This is helpful, isn't it? Trying to figure out what this word means. That's illustration one. Illustration two, this is from a passage you probably know. First Kings 19. The word of the Lord came to Elijah. Go out and stand on the mount before the Lord. And behold, the Lord passed by, and a great and strong wind tore the mountains and broke in

8:45 pieces the rocks before the Lord, but the Lord was not in the wind. And after the wind, an earthquake, but the Lord was not in the earthquake. And after the earthquake, a fire, but the Lord was not in the fire. And after the fire, the sound of, and how does the King James put it? A still small voice. The ESV says, a low whisper. Other translations say a gentle blowing, a gentle whisper, a soft whisper. This is helpful.

9:11 Gentleness is like a soft whisper. Gentleness is not like a great and strong wind or an earthquake or a fire. Illustration three is from 2 Samuel 18. Here, King David ordered his military commanders Joab, uh, Abashai and Iti. He said, "Deal gently for my sake with the young man Abselum." So what were his military commanders tempted to do? Not deal gently. They wanted to take him out. He says, "Deal gently." This illustrates, by the way, the qualifications for an elder in 1 Timothy 3:3, not violent, but gentle. So not a bully. Uh violence is intentionally using physical force to hurt, damage, or

10:00 kill. A bully tries to harm or intimidate people he thinks are vulnerable. Gentleness in contrast to all that is like soldiers dealing mercifully with an enemy. Gentleness is not like violence. Aren't these helpful? Helpful illustrations fig gentleness is. Okay. Number four. Ezekiel 17:22. Thus says the Lord God, I myself will take a sprig from the lofty top of the cedar and will set it out. I will break off from the topmost of its young twigs a tender one. And I myself will plant it on a high and lofty mountain. So the word for gentle here is the word tender, translated tender, with reference to a twig. So to me, this it seems like the

10:48 concept of gentleness here is how God treats a tender twig. So gentleness is like carefully handling a tender twig and nurturing it so that it can flourish. Gentleness is not like breaking snapping a twig. Illustration five is from Proverbs 15:1. A soft or a gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger. Gentleness is like speaking in a peaceful way that reduces the intensity. You know what I'm talking about? When someone is really angry, the anger is just starting to simmer and boil. You

11:38 can respond to that anger in a way that deescalates the situation, calms and subdues. My wife is really skilled at this. In contrast, gentleness is not like speaking harshly. When someone is angry, you can respond in a harsh way that actually intensifies that person's anger, makes it worse, turns into a flaring temper. Illustration six is from Proverbs 25:15. With patience a ruler may be persuaded and a soft tongue or a gentle tongue will break a bone.

12:22 A tongue is one of the softest parts of the body. A bone is the hardest. And in this proverb, tongue symbolizes your speech. And a bone symbolizes an authority over you who seems immovable. Gentle or soft speech can persuade somebody who stiffly opposes you. Gentleness is like speaking softly and patiently with the result that you disarm and persuade. Gentleness is not like speaking harshly. Illustration 7 is from Acts 24:4. So here Paul is appearing before Felix at Cesaria and he politely makes this request to detain you no further. I beg you in your kindness, that's the word,

13:11 to hear us briefly. I beg you in your kindness. So gentleness is like a disposition that is kind, generous, and gracious. Gentleness is not like a disposition that is unkind, ungenerous, and ungracious. Illustration 8 is from Acts 27. When the south wind blew gently or or you could translate that when a light wind began blowing, supposing that they had obtained their purpose, they weighed anchor and sailed along Cree close to the shore. But soon a tempestuous wind, a violent wind, a wind of hurricane force, a wind of typhoon strength called the noraster struck down from the land. So, blue gently translates a Greek word that contrasts

14:00 with a tempestuous hurricane force wind. Gentleness is like a light breeze that is refreshing, desirable, pleasant, and helpful. Gentleness is not like a hurricane force wind. Example nine, 1 Peter 2:18. servants or household slaves, be subject to your masters with all respect, not only only to the good and gentle, the good and considerate, but also to the unjust, those who are harsh. So gentleness is like a good and considerate master. Gentleness is not like an unjustly harsh master.

14:40 And final example, final illustration is Jesus himself. He exhorts in Matthew 11, "Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am gentle. I am gentle and lowly in heart, and you'll find rest for your souls." Paul in 2 Corinthians 10 appeals to Jesus's gentleness. I, Paul myself, entreat you by the meekness and gentleness of Christ. Jesus in Matthew 21:5 embodies gentleness in his triumphal entry. Behold, your king has come unto you humble or the NIV translates that gentle and mounted on a donkey, on a colt, the fo of a beast, a burden. And you notice here, gentleness is intertwined with humility. Gentleness is like Jesus.

15:27 Gentleness is not like people who are arrogant, hardened, and brash. So our answer to question two, what is a precise excuse me two, what is gentleness like and not like according to the Bible is 10 pictures or illustrations helpfully illustrate gentleness. So now I'd like to attempt to define gentleness. What's a precise way to define gentleness? Here's my attempt in one sentence. Gentleness is the virtue of humbly and wisely showing tender kindness to someone. Gentleness is the virtue of humbly and wisely showing tender kindness to someone. Now, I should qualify here. Uh there are at least two different senses to the word

16:18 gentle or gentleness. And the one I'm focusing on is the one that denotes strength. uh like how gentleness is a virtue for masculine leaders like a pastor or a husband or father. There is another sense of gentleness that denotes weakness and vulnerability. So the gentle or meek are often parallel to the poor or downtrodden in various Old Testament passages. Okay. So now I'd like to unpack my definition here in four parts. So here's the definition.

16:49 Part one, gentleness is a virtue. A virtue is a morally good quality in a person. Morally good as God defines that. A Christian should be growing in the virtue of gentleness. Second, you express the virtue of gentleness when you treat a person with tender kindness. Kindness is the quality of being friendly, generous, considerate. But expressing kindness alone is not gentleness. You must express that kindness tenderly. with compassion or sympathy. So, what might it look like for a father to be gentle toward his children?

17:29 A lot of you men have children. Uh I think it looks like a father treating his children tenderly with tender kindness when they are hurting, when they're sick, when they're scared, like taking the earrings out of their ears for the first time. We did that last night with one of our daughters. uh when they are confused or squabbbling or obnoxious. Yes, kids, you can be obnoxious or inconveniencing you or irritating you.

18:05 There's a way that a father can respond to a child in those situations that is full of tender kindness. This is obviously easier said than done. We need God's grace to be gentlemen. Uh third part here, gentleness requires both strength and humility. Here's why I say that. All of the commands in the Bible to be gentle presuppose that you have the capacity not to be gentle. You have the capacity to be sinfully harsh. So when you have that ability to be sinfully harsh, you need strength to harness that power. You need self-control so that you don't give in to your passions.

18:47 That's what I mean when I say that gentleness requires both strength and humility. So the one of these words of I think the eight Greek words for for gentleness, one of the words refers to not being overly impressed by a sense of your self-importance. So a gentle person is not so insecure that he needs to show everybody how strong he is to show off his strength. A gentle person has the strength to be forceful and harsh like a surging rapids or like a hurricane force wind. But a gentle person humbly harnesses that strength for the good of others like a slowly flowing stream or a light breeze.

19:31 You can see this and you contrast two scenarios. So, scenario one, imagine there's an infant incessantly crying and then an irritated father becomes irrationally angry and shakes the baby. That's scenario one. Scenario two, an infant is crying after pinching her finger and a compassionate father securely holds and comforts the baby. Which one is gentle? Obviously, it's that one. You have a strong father showing tender kindness. And then fourth here, gentleness requires wisdom.

20:15 That's why I include the word wisely in the definition. Gentleness is the virtue of humbly and wisely showing tender kindness to someone. Wisdom is a skill. It's an ability. To live wisely is to live skillfully. Wisdom is the skill to live prudently and astutely. And I think wisdom is necessary to be gentle. I'm going to unpack that in the next question. But for now, that's question three. What's a way to define gentleness? The virtue of humbly and wisely showing tender kindness to someone. That leads to question four.

20:50 Why is wisdom necessary to be gentle? Gentleness requires wisdom because there are times when we should not be gentle. And I'm I'm going more slowly here because this is a place where not all Christians agree. I think we need God's wisdom to know when to be gentle and to what degree. Gentleness is not simply niceness or mildness. Now, I'm guessing that most English speakers today misunderstand gentleness as essentially or primarily being nice. Think a gentle person, he's

21:41 nice. In other words, if you look up gentleness in a dictionary, you'd expect to find a picture of this man. Do you guys know who that is? Some of the kids don't know who that is. That's Mr. Rogers. He had a reputation for being pleasant and agreeable. He really was a just a calming presence on his show. Very calm, which is really great for kids. He was an all-around nice guy. Now, I'm not trying to throw stones at Mr. Rogers. I'm not thinking it's bad to be nice, okay? My question is, is Mr.

22:19 Rogers, the best way to illustrate what it means to be gentle according to the Bible. So, dictionary definitions might lead you to say, "Yeah, that's that's a great illustration." Let me show you two diction two definitions from the New Oxford American dictionary. One, gentle means having or showing a mild kind or tender temperament or character. Second definition, moderate inaction, effect or degree, not harsh or severe.

22:53 What do you think of those definitions? I don't think they are entirely bad. And gentleness does involve kindness and tenderness and gentleness is not harsh. So, that part's right. That's really good. But those definitions, I don't think adequately capture what the Bible means by gentleness. Gentleness is not fundamentally a mild temperament. And the essence of gentleness is not being moderate. Moderate means average in amount and intensity and quality, a degree.

23:37 So, I'm concerned that some people think that a gentle man is basically a more feminine man. In other words, when people want a man to be gentle, what they really want is for a man to act more like a woman. They want to neutralize the testosterone. But our goal should not be for men to be more like women. Our goal should be for men to be godly men. Proverbs 20:20 says, "The glory of young men is their strength." Men are generally strong compared to women and children. Not moderately

24:27 strong, really strong. I was watching a competition yesterday, a highlight, and it was a competition where people were trying to max out on their squats, and the guys were all like in the 500s, and like the top women athletes were in the 200s. One might have crested 300. Like, these are top tier athletes. The the the worst male athlete blew the best female athlete out of the water. Men are strong, and that's good. God designed men to be strong and the temperament of men on average is more aggressive than the temperament of women. And that's how God designed men.

25:07 These are characteristics that are a feature. They're not a bug. So, we shouldn't define gentleness in a feminine way that emasculates men. When God commands men to be gentle, he's not commanding men to be less like men and more like women. God wants women to be gentle as women should be gentle. And God wants men to be gentle as men should be gentle. And knowing how to apply this requires wisdom. Listen to James. This is in James chapter 3. The wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, open to reason, full of mercy and good fruits. impartial and sincere. A wise and understanding person acts in the meekness or in the gentleness of wisdom.

25:55 The humility that comes from wisdom. In contrast, the wisdom that doesn't come down from above is earthly, unspiritual, demonic, and it's marked by jealousy and selfish ambition. So, question four, why is wisdom necessary to be gentle? Well, there are times when we should not be gentle. So, we need God's wisdom to know when to be gentle and to what degree. And that raises question uh number five. So, is it sometimes sinful to be gentle?

26:31 >> When you put it that starkly, it makes you pause and like yes, because I have I have some friends, some fellow professors who would say no. Like, you should always be gentle. We've we've had a friendly debate about this. I would answer the question, is it sometimes sinful to be gentle like this? Yes. In some situations, it would be sinful to be gentle. Example, men, if a violent man breaks into your home when your family is at home and he's threatening your family, that is not a time for you to showcase your virtue of gentleness.

27:11 That is a time to be aggressive and confrontational to protect your family. Is the ideal man always like Mr. Rogers? Is there anything noble about a sacrificial fighter pilot like Pete Mitchell in Top Gun Maverick played by Tom Cruz? Aren't you glad that people like that exist? Or think about David and his mighty men in the Old Testament. They were aggressive. So some people, I think, have gutted the biblical virtue of gentleness to mean universal niceness.

27:56 The word universal tips you off to a little controversy about gentleness. So on the one hand, is gentleness an allencompassing virtue? That is, should we always be gentle? Or is gentleness a situational virtue? That is, should we usually be gentle? But not in every situation without exception. In some situations, would it be sinful to be gentle? So, let me give you an argument for this first view that I'm arguing against. Um, in Dane Nortland's book on Jonathan Edwards, he says that for Jonathan Edwards, gentleness is an all-encompassing virtue. Here's what he writes.

28:38 Gentleness is not only for all Christians, but also for all times. It's not a mode into which a believer shifts on occasion. In this way, gentleness is different from many other Christian virtues. Courage, for example, or chastity is summoned forth by specific concrete circumstances. Gentleness is not summoned from time to time. It is what we are. That's that's the argument for this first view. I'm not convinced of that argument. I think it's more accurate to say it like this. Gentleness should be what we are as a general default mode, but not in every circumstance without exception.

29:21 So, I think gentleness is a situational virtue. It's it's like courage in that specific circumstances call for it. Here's an example. Um, the dogs recently had a bunch of kittens. They're really cute. Uh, and they like to hold them and pet them and cuddle them. Uh, the way that our kids and their kids hold those kittens is with a type of gentleness, right? It's with a tender kindness. Is that the same way that we should treat a pit bull if it were about to attack a daughter with tender kindness?

30:05 No. No. If a pit bull is going after a child, the virtue of gentleness is probably the last one you want to showcase at the moment. That's where you need courage. and conviction. You want to protect, you want to help, you need wisdom and courage to do what needs to be done. CS Lewis says courage is not simply one of the virtues but the form of every virtue at the testing point which means at the point of highest reality.

30:36 So, I mentioned I had some friendly debates about this with some of my fellow professors about this and uh one or two of them uh are convinced that gentleness is a universal all-encompassing virtue and they point to some passages in the Bible that might suggest that it is an all-encompassing virtue. Here are the two passages. 2 Timothy 2 says, "The Lord's servant must not be quarrelome, but kind or gentle to everyone, able to teach, patiently enduring evil, correcting even his opponents with gentleness. God may perhaps grant them repentance leading to a knowledge of the truth." So the argument there is, look, you're supposed to be gentle to everybody and even even your opponents

31:25 you're supposed to be gentle with. And then Titus 3, remind them to be submissive to rulers and authorities, to be obedient, to be ready for every good work, to speak evil of no one, to avoid quarreling, to be gentle or kind, and to show perfect courtesy always, to be gentle toward all people. So, you're supposed to be gentle to show gentleness toward all people. So, here's my question for you. Do those two passages require that a man must always be gentle to everyone without exception? Because on the face of it, that might be what those are saying. And if that's the case, we need to have that view.

32:08 Well, one way to confirm what Paul means in these passages is to analyze how he corrects some of his opponents. He says, "Correct your opponents with gentleness." Let's just see how Paul did that. And scripture does not contradict scripture. So the scripture I'm about to show you, I'm just going to pick four passages. I think these are just four examples. These passages don't contradict these passages. Scripture doesn't contradict scripture. So what I'm going to show you is not breaking Paul's rule about being gentle toward all people. Example one, Galatians 5. But if I, brothers, still preach circumcision, why am I still being persecuted? In that case, the offense of the cross has been removed. I

32:56 wish those who would unsettle you would emasculate themselves. Oo, that's kind of strong language. Castrate or mutilate themselves. So Paul's opponents he's talking about here, they're theologically wrong about circumcision. Kids, if you don't know what that is, ask your parents. Um he's saying he wishes that the false teachers would not stop with the foreskin but would go all the way. That's what he's saying. >> He says just make yourself Unix while you're at it. And in the very next paragraph of of Galatians 5, guess what he exhorts them to do? He exhorts Christians to love each other.

33:35 It's right there. Or 1 Timothy 5:20. As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all publicly so that the rest may stand in fear. So Paul commands Timothy to publicly rebuke unrepentant sinners. And to some people that doesn't sound very nice, does it? Here's an example of him doing that. 2 Timothy 4, Alexander the Coppermith. You all know who he is. The people you're writing to. Alexander the copper, that guy, he did me great harm. The Lord will repay him according to his deeds. Beware of him yourself, for he strongly opposed our message. So, he's warning believers about a specific troublemaker by name publicly and pronounces that God's going

34:20 to judge him. And here's another example. Romans 16, appeal to you brothers to watch out for those who cause divisions and create obstacles contrary to the doctrine that you've been taught. avoid them for such persons do not serve our Lord Christ but their own appetites and by smooth talk and flattery they deceive the hearts of the naive. That is just four examples. I could cite many more not just from Paul. I could cite them from Jesus flipping tables pronouncing woes on Pharisees who are hypocrites. And when I consider such examples, the virtue of gentleness is not what comes to mind.

35:05 But not for a moment do I think that Paul or Jesus or Old Testament prophets should have been more gentle in those situations. Rather, I think that gentleness is a virtue that requires wisdom to know when to express it and to what degree. Here are some additional reasons I think that gentleness is not an all-encompassing virtue. This is really important. In 1 Corinthians 4, Paul contrasts coming to the Corinthians with a rod versus with love in a spirit of gentleness.

35:36 So there's a contrast between applying the rod of discipline versus showing a gentle spirit. And I think with love should also describe how we use the rod. We shouldn't use the rod in anger. But that means that in some sense applying the rod of discipline is not gentle. When you administer discipline appropriately, discipline is painful, not gentle. That's what Hebrews 12 says. For the moment, all discipline seems painful rather than pleasant. Or you could say painful rather than gentle.

36:13 But later, it yields the peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who have been trained by it. Gentleness is not the virtue that best describes a father when he faithfully disciplines his child with a rod. Another argument, it requires wisdom to know when to give a soft answer or a gentle answer. Proverbs 15 and 25. A wise person speaks in more than one register, not exclusively in the gentle register. Jesus and Paul and Old Testament prophets did not speak exclusively in the gentle register.

36:52 And third, God himself is not always gentle. Sometimes he pours out his wrath on his enemies. In such a case, he's love. I think love is an all-encompassing virtue. And you can manifest love in some cases by pouring out your wrath on someone and that's showing your love to someone else. So, I think love is all-encompassing. I don't think gentleness is the same way. U so back to those two passages I showed you. So what about these two passages?

37:19 What does it mean that we should be kind to everyone? I think it means that our general posture should be friendly, generous, considerate. I don't think it means that a man should be friendly to a rogue who is attempting to hurt his wife. So situational. Or what does it mean to be gentle toward all people? It means that our general posture should be to humbly and wisely show tender kindness to others. It does not mean that a pastor should be nothing but tender to a schismatic false teacher who boldly and shamelessly is trying to lead church members astray.

38:08 Or what does it mean to avoid quarreling? It means we shouldn't squabble about trivial matters. It does not mean that we should never fight. Some things are so precious that they are worth fighting for. We should contend for those things without being sinfully contentious. Jude 3 commands us that we are to contend for the faith. I think the theological message of first Timothy is fight the good fight of the faith. And what does it mean to correct your opponents with gentleness? I think it means when you're attempting to help your opponents see the error of their ways, you do so in a gentle manner. It does not mean that a pastor should be nothing but tender to false teachers. We should have

38:57 different postures when we're trying to win the person versus when we're trying to protect the flock. When you're trying to win the person, gentleness is the way. 1 Peter 3:15 says, "In your hearts, honor Christ the Lord is holy, always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason of the hope that is in you. Yet do it with gentleness and respect, having a good conscience, so that when you are slandered, those who revile your good behavior in Christ may be put to shame.

39:30 Now, the problems of untethered empathy and untethered winsomeness are similar to untethered gentleness. It's misguided to think that the only mode in which a man should operate is gentle. Pastors should comfort and correct the sheep. with gentleness. Pastors should correct fools sometimes with gentleness. Pastors should fight wolves, not with gentleness. Also, there may be a difference between treating someone gently from God's perspective and treating someone gently from their perspective. It's possible for a person to wrongly perceive that a pastor's correction is not gentle in the sense of sinfully harsh.

40:21 So compare this with the command of love. God commands you to love your neighbor. He doesn't command you to make your neighbor feel loved. Now often when you love your neighbor, that person feels loved. But sometimes when you love your neighbor, your neighbor doesn't feel loved. The command is not make your neighbor feel loved. The command is love your neighbor. And then one important qualification here before I move on.

40:45 It's relatively uncommon that a pastor should not be gentle. Gandalf doesn't fight a balrog every day. A man should be ready and prepared to go into aggressive protector mode at full strength when necessary. But gentleness should be his default mode. His character should incline toward that virtue. My point here is simply that for a pastor to be gentle does not mean that he always expresses gentleness toward every single person without exception.

41:21 So that's question number five. Is it sometimes sinful to be gentle? Yes, in some situations it is sinful to be gentle. Gentle. Question six. What does it mean for a man to be pastoral? You you use that word sometimes, pastoral. That guy's pastoral. He's really pastoral. I think when people use that word today, what they mean is basically that guy has a good bedside manner. He's he's gentle in the sense of caring, sensitive, calming, comforting.

41:56 Now, think about those qualities. Caring, sensitive, comforting, calming. Those are qualities that characterize women more than men, aren't they? I think that signals that something is off if we think that those are the defining characteristics of pastoral. The office of pastor is a masculine office. It is fitting for a man to be a pastor. It is not fitting for a woman to be a pastor. So if we define pastoral in a primarily feminine sense, then we're not thinking accurately. Now, is it good for a pastor to be caring, sensitive, calming, comforting? Of course, that's

42:47 good. Those are good qualities for a pastor of people to have. They're good qualities for a shepherd of animals to have. But being pastoral is more than being tender. It also includes being tough. A faithful pastor must shepherd the sheep. I'm trying to make pastoral great again here where when we think of it, we don't just think nice, but we think masculine protector. is part of pastoral. Sometimes a faithful pastor must protect the sheep by killing wolves or bears or lions.

43:33 Sometimes a faithful pastor must protect the sheep by grabbing that sheep before it wanders off a cliff. And the sheep doesn't feel loved in that moment. But it's exactly what it needs. Being pastoral is a wise combination of strength and gentleness, authority and compassion. So here's one way to apply this virtue to a pastor. The vibe of a pastor should not be feminine. No, should be masculine. He should not be floppy Mr. Nice Guy. A pastor should project a godly strength and discipline.

44:18 People shouldn't think of a pastor as a feminine kind of tender, except for the rare instances when he must be a masculine kind of tough. No, pastors must be both tough and tender in a masculine way in a way that is fitting for a shepherd who knows, feeds, leads, and protects the sheep. So what does it mean for a man to be pastoral? It does not mean merely caring, sensitive, calming, and comforting. Pastoral means being both tough and tender.

44:49 Finally, question seven. So, must a man be weak to be gentle? I hope you know the answer by this point. No, a man does not need to be weak to be gentle. Men should be both strong and gentle, tough and tender. Here are three literary examples of both strength and tenderness. And I realize this is the fourth week in a row that one of your pastors has mentioned the Lord of the Rings. Next week we'll break the streak probably. So here are three literary examples of both strength and tenderness. I'm going to draw them from Gandalf in Tolken's Middle Earth and Alan and Lewis's Narnia and Professor Albus Dumbledore in Rawlings Harry

45:37 Potter. Okay, these three figures show tender compassion to others. For example, Gandalf shows tender compassion to Gollum and he encourages Frodo to do the same. Alan shows tender compassion to Reapuchep and his mice with the cut off tails. Professor Dumbledore shows tender compassion to Harry Potter after Voldemort murders Harry's parents. So we agreed these three figures show tender compassion often, but gentleness is not the virtue that comes to mind when Gandalf slays the great goblin in the Hobbit, right? Or when Alan attacks the white witch in the

46:27 lion, the witch in the wardrobe. Or when Dumbledore duels Voldemort in the lobby of the Ministry of Magic. Gandalf and Dumbledore are not tame wizards. Alan is not a tame lion. So those are just examples from literature. Here is the supreme model of tough and tender. It's God himself in Isaiah 40. Just consider what God is like here. Behold, the Lord God comes with might and his arm rules for him. What's he like to his people? He will tend his flock like a shepherd. He will gather the lambs in his arms. His same arm that's tough. He will carry them in

47:16 his bosom and gently lead those that are with young men. We should aim to be like that, strong and tender, strong and gentle. Brothers, God made us strong. The glory of men is their strength. We must use our strength to serve others, not to oppress them. So that's the danger, isn't it? We're strong and we're tempted to misuse our strength. All of us have different strengths and weaknesses the way God made us. And I think it's interesting you look at the way that God addresses us in the Bible.

48:02 He knows that as he admonishes us. So think about how God addresses wives. Wives are sinfully inclined not to submit to or respect their husbands. So God says wives submit to your own husbands as to the Lord. Let the wife see that she respects her husbands. Her just one husband respect her husband. Children are sinfully inclined to disobey their parents. So what does God command? Children, obey your parents in everything for this pleases the Lord.

48:36 And now this is why I'm working up to it. Men, when we're husbands, we're sinfully inclined to be harsh with our wives. So, what does God command? Husbands, love your wives and do not be harsh with them. And parents, fathers, we're inclined to be sinfully angry with our children, to provoke them to wrath. So God commands fathers, do not provoke your children, lest they become discouraged. So right now I'm focusing on the men.

49:11 God made us to be strong and we must use that strength for the good of all those around us. That strength is a gift that we must steward. Some men do misuse that strength. They sinfully oppress other people and that's wicked. But masculinity as God designed it is not toxic. It's great. It's good. Strength is good when we use it the way that God intended. Strength plus gentleness, tough plus tender. Gentleness is the missing virtue that God rebukes false shepherds for. In Ezekiel 37, he says, "The weak you've not strengthened. The sick you've not healed. The injured you've not bound up.

49:56 The stray you've not brought back. The lost you've not sought. And with force and harshness you have ruled them." That's what false shepherds do. They use force and harshness in a way that does not build up the people they're accountable for. They disregard the health of their sheep. So, question seven, must a man be weak to be gentle? No. Men should be both strong and gentle, tough and tender. Now, I like to conclude by sharing one quotation from Douglas Wilson and then I'm going to pray. It's a really good quotation.

50:33 It's he's explaining that a good analogy for a man is to be a velvet covered brick. Three slides. Here we go. A husband must be hard in order to take on masculine responsibility. A husband must be soft in order to avoid crushing those for whom he is responsible. Maintaining these twin imperatives in balance requires great wisdom. far more than men have or may have apart from the grace of God. Some men are all velvet.

51:11 Other men are all brick mostly between the ears. And I think in our church if we were to on one side it would be all brick. Other men, which I would prefer that error, other men prefer to alternate between the two, bricks when angry and abdicating velvet when covenantally lazy. They managed to incur all the negative consequences of both kinds of sin. This is the kind of husband whose wife thinks he's a tyrant, although he's never made one clear decision in all their years together.

51:48 A man cannot honor a woman unless he is tender with her. The Bible tells men to be hard and it tells them to be soft. Around each command, we find men clustering according to their own wishes and desires. So one husband hears loud and clear the command to be hard and so he engages himself to be harsh, critical, unloving, dense, imperious, stubborn, unbending, idiotic, and proud. Another man hears the command to be soft. So he vacasillates, waffles, abdicates, whines, complains, suffers, agonizes, and goes generally limp.

52:29 A man who does the former, he's too hard, does so in the name of strength, but he has no notion of what biblical strength really is. A man who does the latter, he's too soft. Does so in the name of kindness, but has no idea what biblical kindness actually is. A man who is not strong enough to be tender is not strong at all. Everything he projects is nothing but counterfeit bluster. Instructed by biblical wisdom, strength and tenderness are not actually two different things. We may picture the two together by means of various analogies in combination, velvet and brick.

53:10 But the two things together actually constitute one virtue. A virtue we may identify as essential to biblical masculinity. So I exhort you men, be a velvet covered brick. Let's pray. Father, would you please enable the men of our church to be strong and gentle, tough and tender, authoritative and compassionate, brick and velvet. We ask in the name of Christ the King. Amen.

No transcript available.