Listen on

How to Treat Accusations Against an Elder

Transcript

1 Timothy

01

Final Charge and Benediction

Andy Naselli

May 10, 2026
01

Four Charges to the Rich

Andy Naselli

Apr 26, 2026
01

Nine Reasons to Praise God the Father

Andy Naselli

Apr 19, 2026
01

Five Charges to the Man of God

Andy Naselli

Apr 12, 2026
01

Two Exhortations About Riches

Andy Naselli

Mar 29, 2026
01

What Does the Bible Teach About Money and Possessions?

Andy Naselli

Mar 22, 2026
01

Eight Marks of a False Teacher

Andy Naselli

Mar 15, 2026
01

(Part 3 of 3): What Does the Bible Say About Work?

Andy Naselli

Mar 1, 2026
01

(Part 2 of 3): What God Commands Slaves to Do and Why

Andy Naselli

Feb 22, 2026
01

(Part 1 of 3): Does the Bible Promote Slavery?

Andy Naselli

Feb 8, 2026
01

How to Treat Accusations Against an Elder

Andy Naselli

Feb 1, 2026
01

Pay Your Elders

Andy Naselli

Jan 25, 2026
01

Honor Widows

Andy Naselli

Jan 18, 2026
01

Manifested in the Flesh (Christmas)

Andy Naselli

Dec 21, 2025
01

How to Exhort or Appeal to Older Men, Younger Men, Older Women, and Younger Women

Andy Naselli

Dec 14, 2025
01

What Paul Charges Timothy to Do, Part 2 of 2

Andy Naselli

Nov 30, 2025
01

What Paul Charges Timothy to Do, Part 1 of 2

Andy Naselli

Nov 9, 2025
01

Some Will Depart From the Faith

Andy Naselli

Oct 26, 2025
01

The Purpose of What Paul Instructs Us in 1 Timothy

Andy Naselli

Oct 19, 2025
01

What Must Deacons Be? (Part 2 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Oct 12, 2025
01

Six Questions About Deacons (Part 1 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Oct 5, 2025
01

He Must Manage His Own Household Well (Part 2 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Sep 7, 2025
01

He Must Manage His Own Household Well (Part 1 of 2)

Andy Naselli

Aug 31, 2025
01

Not a Lover of Money: Four Exhortations About Wealth

Andy Naselli

Aug 10, 2025
01

What Does It Mean to Be Gentle? Qualifications for a Pastor, Part 2 of 6

Andy Naselli

Aug 3, 2025
01

An Overseer Must Be Above Reproach: Qualifications for a Pastor, Part 1 of 6

Andy Naselli

Jul 27, 2025
01

How to Discern If a Man Should Be a Pastor

Andy Naselli

Jul 13, 2025
01

What Shepherds Do

Andy Naselli

Jul 6, 2025
01

A Woman Will Be Saved Through Childbearing

Andy Naselli

Jun 22, 2025
01

Responding to Objections to What Paul Teaches in 1 Timothy 2:11–14

Andy Naselli

Jun 15, 2025
01

Two Reasons a Woman Must Learn Quietly and Submissively

Andy Naselli

May 25, 2025
01

A Woman Must Learn Quietly and Submissively

Andy Naselli

May 18, 2025
01

How Should Women Dress?

Andy Naselli

May 4, 2025
01

Part 4 of 4—Three More Arguments for Biblical Patriarchy

Andy Naselli

Apr 27, 2025
01

Part 3 of 4—Three Arguments for Biblical Patriarchy

Andy Naselli

Apr 13, 2025
01

God’s Good Design for Men and Women: Part 2 of 4—Five Exhortations

Andy Naselli

Apr 6, 2025
01

God’s Good Design for Men and Women: Part 1 of 4—A Spectrum of Views and Two Types of

Andy Naselli

Mar 30, 2025
01

Evidence That God Wants All Kinds of People to Be Saved

Andy Naselli

Mar 16, 2025
01

God Wants All Kinds of People to Be Saved

Andy Naselli

Mar 9, 2025
01

Why the Church Should Pray for Government Authorities

Andy Naselli

Mar 2, 2025
01

The Charge to Reject False Teaching

Andy Naselli

Feb 16, 2025
01

Hail to the King!

Andy Naselli

Feb 2, 2025
01

How to Use the Law Lawfully

Andy Naselli

Jan 26, 2025
01

Warning Against Teaching False Doctrines

Andy Naselli

Jan 19, 2025
01

Introducing 1 Timothy: Fight the Good Fight of the Faith

Andy Naselli

Jan 12, 2025

Transcript

0:02 Let's pray together. Father, as we consider your words to us in 1 Timothy 5, would you please enlighten our minds through your spirit and soften our hearts and enable our wills to honor you? We ask in the name of Jesus. Amen. >> Amen. >> Please open your Bible to First Timothy 5. 1 Timothy 5. As I preach through 1 Timothy, the next text in our series is the very end of chapter 5. It's 1 Timothy 5:es 19- 25. So let's begin by reading our passage. 1 Timothy 5 starting in verse 19.

0:45 Do not admit a charge against an elder except on the evidence of two or three witnesses. As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all so that the rest may stand in fear. In the presence of God and of Christ Jesus and of the elect angels, I charge you to keep these rules without prejudging, doing nothing from partiality. Do not be hasty in the laying on of hands, nor take part in the sins of others. Keep yourself pure. No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments. The sins of some people are conspicuous, going before

1:33 them to judgment, but the sins of others appear later. So also good works are conspicuous, and even those that are not cannot remain hidden. In this passage, Paul instructs us about how to handle accusations against an elder. Does it surprise you that people would make false accusations against an elder? It shouldn't surprise you. Jesus teaches, "Blessed are you when others revile you and persecute you and are all kinds of evil against you falsely on my account. Rejoice and be glad for your reward is great in heaven. For so they persecuted the prophets who were before you. That's Matthew 5:11 and 12. Jesus

2:21 also teaches if they have called the master of the house beelible, how much more will they malign those of his household? It's Matthew 10:25. And Paul testifies, when reviled, we bless. When persecuted, we endure. When slandered, we entreat. That's 1 Corinthians 4:12-13. So, we expect that some unbelievers will make false accusations against an elder. But what happens when a church member makes accusations against one of his elders? Well, on the one hand, a church member might make a false accusation against his elder that may harm the

3:10 elers's reputation. So, one of Satan's strategies is to eliminate faithful pastors by means of false accusations. False accusations against a pastor may make people more suspicious and skeptical of that pastor. And the result is that some people will think that pastor is not above reproach. So, he's not qualified to be a pastor. But on the other hand, an elder may actually be morally disqualified and an accusation against him may be completely true and fitting.

3:44 So what should we do when a church member makes an accusation against an elder? Well, this passage instructs us how to treat accusations against an elder. So, I'd like to preach to you from 1 Timothy 5 19-25 on this subject. How to treat accusations against an elder. There are five main commands in this passage that instruct us how to treat accusations against an an elder. So, that'll be the the outline for the sermon, those five commands. And this outline is in your worship service guide. Command number one is admit an accusation against an elder only on the evidence of two or three witnesses. Verse 19 says do not admit a charge against an elder except on the

4:36 evidence of two or three witnesses. And this command in verse 19 raises at least six questions. So let's just work through these six questions. First, what does it mean to admit an accusation? It means to accept an accusation as true. Here's some other ways to translate verse 19. Do not Here's NASBY. Do not accept an accusation or here's the LSB. Do not receive an accusation. Here's NIV. Do not entertain an accusation against an elder except on the evidence of two or three witnesses.

5:17 So when the ESV says do not admit, that word admit translates a word. That means to acknowledge something to be correct. So you could translate it accept. You're accepting it to be true. Now it may be responsible for elders to listen to an accusation from a single individual, but they must not accept that accusation as true on the basis of just one person's testimony. Now, at the beginning of this paragraph, verse 17, Paul commands the church to consider the elders who rule well worthy of double what?

5:53 >> Double honor. That honor includes respect and payment. And that respect includes guarding an elder against an unsubstantiated accusation. So, here's an application for us. If elders should not receive as true an unsubstantiated accusation, then should you? So, brothers and sisters, we we live at a time when just about anybody can publicly accuse a pastor on the internet. So, be discerning. Don't waste your time entertaining baseless accusations against pastors. That's a cesspool that you can drown in.

6:41 It's not good for your spiritual health to feed on gossip and it's not fair to the reputation of pastors. So there there are some people I will not follow on social media. There are some websites I won't even dignify with my traffic. If I see it's from certain people, I won't even click on the link because some people who claim to be journalists are actually more like the slanderous reporter in the Harry Potter stories, Rita Ska. She's terrible. All right, so that's that's question one. What does it mean to admit an accusation? It means to accept an accusation as true. Question two, what is the rationale for an accusation being confirmed by two or three witnesses? The answer is it

7:28 protects a person against an unsubstantiated accusation. Here's how some other translations render verse 19. Don't admit a charge against an elder except on the evidence of or unless it's supported by unless it's confirmed by two or three witnesses. That's the idea. This wording comes from the Old Testament. If you're looking at your Bible, you might see a little footnote by verse 19 that says Deuteronomy 19:15. Listen to that passage. A single witness shall not suffice against a person for any crime or for any wrong in connection with any offense that he has committed.

8:10 Only on the evidence of two witnesses or of three witnesses shall a charge be established. So the rationale is that this standard protects a person against an accusation that is spurious, false, baseless, unsubstantiated. Unsubstantiated means it's not supported or proven by evidence. The goal is to confirm what is true. Now, since accusations against a pastor are so common, I think personally as a as a pastor, it's wise to be cautious about some one-on-one meetings. So, as a general rule, if a pastor suspects that a one-on-one meeting may be particularly controversial or that it could be misinterpreted or misrepresented, it

8:58 would be wise to invite at least one other person to the meeting. It's a safeguard for both parties. I've had some experiences of people making false accusations against me. And I'm so grateful in God's providence that accusations against me were made regarding what transpired in groups. So there were other people who could credibly testify as witnesses that the accusations were false. So there's there's safety in not being alone. So that's question two. Question three, does a later witness as opposed to an original witness count as one of the witnesses in 1 Timothy 5:19? My view is that a witness must have witnessed the alleged offense or witnessed a confession. So, for this question I'm

9:48 asking here to make sense, let me give you some background and define what I mean by original witness and later witness. Um, in summer 2022 when uh what is now the North Church used to be Bethl Baptist Church's north campus uh the elders of Bethleam Baptist Church were working on an elder policy on grievance process and there was one issue in particular that I investigated and it was how to understand 1 Timothy 5:19 this very verse. So at one point there's a draft of the document which I did not prepare.

10:24 I'm looking it over and at one point that this draft defines the word witness like this. A member who may or may not have witnessed I'll read that again. A witness is a member who may or may not have witnessed the offense or personal peacemaking interactions but can serve to confirm and adjudicate the grievance. So I'm reading along and a witness is a person who might not be a witness. So, I I didn't understand this definition. Uh, it's like saying a husband may or may not be someone with a wife. Uh, witness may or may not have witnessed. So, I emailed a bunch of pastor theologian friends, get their perspective on 1 Timothy 5:19. So, here's here's the the the email I sent them. It's short. I

11:11 said, um, I think we need to distinguish two types of witnesses. an original witness, someone who witnessed the alleged offense, and a later witness, someone who witnessed personal peacemaking actions regarding the alleged offense, and who can testify about that, original and later. It's possible to be both an original witness and a later witness, but I think it's crucial to distinguish when a later witness is not an original witness. So, my specific question is about 1 Timothy 5:19. Do not admit a charge against an elder except on the evidence of two or three witnesses. Does a later witness count as a 1 Timothy 5:19 witness who can bring a charge? And what I wrote

11:53 back in 2022 is, "My sense is that the burden of 1 Timothy 5:19 is to protect elders from spurious accusations and that a witness who is qualified to bring a charge must be an original witness." And I understand that the reply would be, "But what about one-on-one sins such as sexual sins for which there aren't other witnesses?" So that's my email. I got responses from about 20 different friends who are pastor theologians. And after processing all of that and weighing the the responses, I remain convinced that we should distinguish between an original witness and a later witness with the understanding that a later witness could subsequently witness evidence after the initial offense that

12:37 has a bearing on the proceedings and thus could make him count as a witness regarding a charge. So for a person to count as a witness in this 1 Timothy 5:19 sense, he must have witnessed the alleged offense or witnessed a confession. You don't have to uh you don't count as a witness if he didn't witness the alleged offense, but you just believe the accusation is true. All right. So here's what uh Pastor Doug Wilson uh told me back in 2022. He said, 'Your instincts are correct. Suppose a man says that he saw an elder shoplifting and then he confronts the elder and brings a second witness. If the accused denies having done anything of the kind, the second witness brought is a witness

13:26 of the denial only, not of the shoplifting. But it does frequently happen in Christian circles that the second witness becomes a witness of the primary allegation through how the act through how the accused responds. He might say, "You can't prove that I did it and she deserved it." Or something like that. Like, "Oh, that was You can witness a confession in a moment like that." All right, that's question number three.

13:50 Question four, but what about one-on-one sins such as sexual sins for which there aren't other witnesses? One person's accusation alone is not sufficient evidence, but additional evidence could count as a witness. So here's a principle from Deuteronomy 19:15-21. That's is the passage, the paragraph that Paul's citing here in 1 Timothy 5:19. Here's the principle. If there's only one witness, then judges may investigate the matter further and consider any other relevant evidence to establish whether a person is innocent or guilty. There might be other evidence beyond a human witness that can help prove guilt. So in our day, that could be an authentic video or an authentic

14:39 text message. An additional evidence could count as a witness. But here's the important reason. And this is in 1 Timothy 5:19. We must not treat an accused person as guilty without sufficient evidence. And one person's accusation alone is not sufficient evidence. The innocent until proven guilty standard comes from the Bible. And that means that some guilty people may not be condemned in this life. But this standard protects innocent people from wrongly being condemned as guilty.

15:21 So my question uh question four, one person's accusation alone is not sufficient evidence, but additional evidence could count as a witness. Now question five, should there be negative consequences for someone who makes a false accusation? Yes. If a church member were to make a false accusation, then at the very least he should publicly repent of the sin of slander. It is common for people in our culture to make false accusations. This happens everywhere. Happens in politics, in sports, in the business world, in schools. Basically, false accusations happen wherever sinners are. So, it shouldn't surprise us that false accusations also happen in the church.

16:07 It's also common for people in our culture to make false accusations and then when proven to be wrong, they suffer no negative consequences. It's very easy to falsely accuse someone. But think about the damage that a false accusation can do. Shouldn't there be some kind of negative consequence for that? So Paul cites Deuteronomy 19 to establish the principle that two or three witnesses are necessary to establish that an accusation is true. I want to read to you the paragraph from Deuteronomy 19.

16:46 So after the sentence Paul cites because this is relevant for my question here. Paul says, Moses says, "A single witness shall not suffice against a person for any crime or for any wrong in connection with any offense that he has committed. Only on the evidence of two witnesses or of three witnesses shall a charge be established." That's the sentence Paul cites in 1 Timothy 5:19. Now, here's the rest of the paragraph. If a malicious witness arises to accuse a person of wrongdoing, then both parties to the dispute shall appear before the Lord before the priests and the judges who are in the are in office in those days. The judges shall inquire diligently.

17:31 And if the witness is a false witness and has accused his brother falsely, then you shall do to him as he has he had meant to do to his brother. So you shall purge the evil from your midst, and the rest shall hear and fear and shall never again commit any such evil among you. Your eye shall not pity. It shall be life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot. That is a principle that applies in this sense. There should be some kind of negative consequence for making a false accusation. It shouldn't be you can just make false accusation, false accusation, false accusation, and you're repeatedly shown to be wrong and nothing happens.

18:12 There should be consequences for that. In the context of a local church, what should that consequence be? Well, it's going to require wisdom on a case-byase basis for a church to determine what negative consequences would be fitting. If a church member were to make a false accusation, then at the very least, he should publicly repent of the sin of slander. So, here's a scenario. Imagine this. A church member makes a false accusation against an elder. The elders weigh those accusations. They find the charges insubstantial. They pronounce the elder not guilty. Justice is served.

18:47 But that's not all. The time and energy it takes for the elders to deal with such accusations is significant. And the damage a false accusation can do to an elers's reputation is substantial. There was a time when I endured a period of people slandering me as a pastor and professor and my dad was coaching me and he he explained to me, Andy, the process is the punishment. So in other words, at the end of the process, your name may be clear, but that doesn't erase the pain and damage that false accusations can cause. So, it seems fitting that a church member who makes an unsubstantiated charge, a false charge, should publicly repent for slandering an elers's reputation. That

19:35 seems fitting. Finally, question six. Is an independent investigation by a third party an ideal way to ensure due process? No. especially if a church is abdicating their responsibility. Independent investigators basically collect data by talking to people and then they weigh their perspectives. But independent investigators do not automatically guarantee due process because independent investigators can be as biased as anyone. So, I don't know of any biblical warrant for a church to give up their authority on a matter to independent investigators and say, "Hey, you be the judge and jury." Independent investigators might be helpful as

20:25 consultants, but they should not replace the authority that God has given to a church's pastors and members. For a church's pastors and members to give away or transfer that authority is to abdicate their responsibility. So that is command number one. Admit an accusation against an elder only on the evidence of two or three witnesses. Now let's consider command number two. If an elder persists in sin, publicly rebuke him so that the whole church may stand in fear. Listen to verse 20. As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all so that the rest may stand in fear.

21:14 This command raises at least four questions. First, who does those who persist in sin refer to? It's the very first line, those who persist in sin. This sentence connects to the previous sentence in verse 19. So those who persist in sin refers to those elders who persist in sin. This isn't referring to just any believer. So who does those who persist in sin refer to? Answer: elders who persist in sin. Question two, what does persist in sin mean?

21:56 It's the sort of sin that makes a man not above reproach. In other words, it's a sin that disqualifies a man from serving as an elder. So, what does it mean to persist in sin? Answer: sin in a way that disqualifies a man from serving as an elder. Question three, what does rebuke mean? As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all. Rebuke means to expose an elers's sin for the purpose of correcting him. It translates a word that means to express strong disapproval of someone's action.

22:32 Reprove. Correct. So what does rebuke mean? Answer. Expose an elers's sin for the purpose of correcting him. And then question four. What does all and the rest refer to? So uh rebuke them in the presence of all so that the rest may stand in fear. What does all refer to? What does the rest refer to? There are two main ways to interpret each of those groups. All and the rest. So for the word all here, rebuke it in the presence of all. It could refer to all the elders. Rebuke this elder, this this sinning elder in the presence of all the elders or it could refer to the whole church. Rebuke this elder in the

23:20 presence of all the church. And then so that the rest may stand in fear. There are two ways to take that. The rest could refer to the rest of the elders. Rebuke this elder so that the rest of the elders may stand in fear. They be fearful of sinning. Or it could mean so that the rest of the church would stand in fear. So when the elders rebuke an elder, the whole church would be fearful of sinning. I think it's most likely that all refers to the whole church. This is a public rebuke in front of the whole congregation. It's not merely a private rebuke in front of the elders. God holds pastors to a higher standard.

23:59 And I'm not certain whom the rest refers to. Here's my guess. It refers specifically to the rest of the elders and then more generally to the whole church. So when the elders rebuke an elder, the rest of the elders would be fearful of sinning. But even then, the elders wouldn't be the only ones who should be fearful of sinning. If the elders were to rebuke a former elder in front of the entire church, then the entire church should be fearful of sinning. And this parallels Deuteronomy 19:20, which says, "The rest," that is the rest of the congregation shall hear and fear and shall never again commit any such evil among you. So my answer to question four is who does all and the

24:41 rest refer to? All probably refers to the whole church. Exc. And that all probably refers to all of the whole church. All the church. And the rest refers to specifically the rest of the elders. More generally to the whole church. That's command number two. If an elder persists in sin, publicly rebuke him so that the whole church may stand in fear. Now command number three. Don't practice favoritism toward an elder or toward a witness who makes an accusation against an elder. Look at verse 21. In the presence of God and of Christ Jesus and of the elect angels, I charge you to keep these rules without prejudging, doing nothing from partiality.

25:28 And this command raises at least two questions. First, why does Paul appeal to God and Christ Jesus and the elect angels? I think Paul appeals to them to make this command more solemn. His appeal is fitting because God has entrusted all judgment to his son. John 5:22, Acts 17:31, 2 Timothy 4:1-2, and then angels will be present at the final judgment. Matthew 25:31, Revelation 14:10. And just a side note here, you see that phrase elect angels, that could refer to all of the unfallen

26:18 angels or just a subset of them. So, you know, originally you got all these angels, some of them fall, and now we we don't call them angels anymore. We call them demons. So, you have unfallen angels and demons. And my guess is that elect angels refers to a subset of the unfallen angels because if he said just angels that would refer to all the good angels. So u again as a side note not important interesting elect angels.

26:49 Okay. Okay. So, Paul's appeal underscores that church discipline situations are difficult and that elders should remember that as they deliberate a matter, they're doing it in the presence of God and of Christ Jesus and of the elect angels. And it requires wisdom to conduct the church discipline matter for an elder without any favoritism. So, that's question one. Why does Paul appeal to God and Christ Jesus and the elect angels? Answer, it makes the command more solemn.

27:15 Now command number two. What does it mean to act without prejudging or partiality? Negatively it means to act without favoritism. Positively it means to do justice. So what is justice? Justice is getting what you deserve and giving others what they deserve. Justice does not show favoritism. Justice is impartial. It's objective. Justice applies equally to everyone regardless of wealth or status or connections or ethnicity or intelligence or skills.

27:57 And this is why images of Lady Justice often depict her wearing a blindfold while holding scales and a sword. So the blindfold symbolizes impartiality. Justice is blind. The scales symbolize fairness and weighing the evidence. And the sword symbolizes enforcing the law. So what does it mean to act without prejudging or partiality? Answer. Negatively act without favoritism. positively do justice. That's command number three. Don't practice favoritism toward an elder or toward a witness who makes an accusation

28:46 against an elder. We want to pursue justice. Now, command number four, don't prematurely appoint an elder. The first line, the first command, verse 22, is do not be hasty in the laying on of hands. This command raises at least two questions. One, what does it refer to? The laying on of hands. Well, listen to two other translations that give you the sense. The CSB says, "Don't be too quick to appoint anyone as an elder."

29:19 The NLT says, "Never be in a hurry about appointing a church leader." I think that that rightly captures the sense. The NASB is more formbased. Do not lay hands upon anyone too quickly. So in the literary context, laying hands on a man means to officially ordain or install a man as a pastor. So what does the laying on of hands refer to? Answer, ordain or install a man as a pastor? Question two, why should a church beware of hastily appointing an elder?

29:56 When a church hastily appoints an elder, that increases the likelihood that down the road the church will have to deal with a disqualified elder. So the safeguard is to take extra precautions on the front end to avoid headaches and heartaches on the back end. It's relatively easy to appoint a man as a pastor. It's much harder to remove a pastor. So don't rush the process. Don't rush the process of testing whether a man would fit well as a pastor for this church with this current team of pastors. That's question two. Why should a church be aware of hastily appointing an elder? Answer to decrease the likelihood that the church will later have to remove a disqualified elder.

30:46 That's command four. Don't prematurely appoint an elder. And finally is command five, which is the end of the passage. Starting with the second line of verse 22. So let's read that. Says, "Nor," we could translate it, "do not, do not take part in the sins of others. Keep yourself pure. No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments. The sins of some people are conspicuous, going before them to judgment. But the sins of others appear later. So also good works are conspicuous and even those that are not cannot remain hidden.

31:25 So I'll explain this passage by asking five questions. Question one, are the two commands at the end of verse 22 basically the same. Look at those commands in verse 22. Do not take part in the sins of others. Keep yourself pure. Those two commands I think are basically the same command stated negatively and positively. So negatively don't take part in the sins of others positively keep yourself pure. So my answer to this question is yes.

31:58 They are basically the same commands stated negatively and positively. Question two, how do you obey those two commands? Don't take part in the sins of others. Keep yourself pure. Here's how. Keep yourself pure by not receiving as true an unsubstantiated accusation against an elder. Verse 19. Keep yourself pure by publicly rebuking an elder who persist in sin. Verse 20. Keep yourself pure by not practicing favoritism. Verse 21. Keep yourself pure by not prematurely appointing an elder.

32:35 Beginning at verse 22. In other words, keep yourself pure. Don't take part in the sins of others by obeying the previous four commands. Now, question three, what does it mean to take part in the sins of others? The the middle command in verse 22 is do not take part in the sins of others. What does that mean? The NASBY and the LSB translate this don't take part in they say it like this. Don't share responsibility for share responsibility for I think that gets it. To take part in the sins of others is to share responsibility for those sins to some degree.

33:19 Say how well I didn't commit the sin. How would I be sharing in that responsibility? Here's an illustration that will make it this better to easier to understand. Here in 2 John 10:11, John writes, "If anyone comes to you and doesn't bring this teaching, do not receive him into your house or give him any greeting, forever greets him, takes part in his wicked works." So if you have so-called Christian fellowship with a false teacher, then you are complicit to some degree in that false teachers wicked works. Again, that's 2 John 10:11. In a similar way, if you hastily and irresponsibly appoint an unqualified man as an elder, then you are complicit to some degree in

34:08 the damage that man causes to the church. So, take great care on the front end before you appoint a man as a pastor. You don't want to share responsibility for those sins to any degree. Question four. Why does Paul tell Timothy to stop drinking only water and to drink a little wine? You notice the ESV for verse 23 helpfully puts parenthesis around that sentence indicates it's parenthetical advice specifically to Timothy. So after commanding the elders to keep themselves pure, Paul has this aside to Timothy which you could paraphrase like this. By the way, Timothy, it's okay to drink wine for medicinal purposes. Go ahead and do that. That's what he's saying.

34:54 So, alcohol could sterilize impure, unhealthy water. And if Timothy drank a little wine, it would help him not get sick. So, what's going on here? Why would Paul say this? Well, earlier in this letter, you remember chapter 3, it says that a an elder, an overseer in verse three must not be a drunkard. And then 38 says that a deacon must not indulge in much wine. I just looked at our two deacons. All right. Now, but but it is permissible to drink a little wine. 5:23. Now, I'm not sure why Paul adds that aside to Timothy here. The text just doesn't say. So, I'm going to have to guess. So, I'm not authoritatively saying this is what the text means. I'm guessing now.

35:42 My guess is that Timothy's stomach illnesses are related to all the pressures he's dealing with in Ephesus. He's responding to false teachers. He's correcting church members who are misbehaving in the household of God. He's caring for widows. And according to this passage, he's probably dealing with accusations against elders. And just that alone can be very stressful. So relational pressures like these can be stressful and lead to stomach ailments.

36:06 So I'm speculating, but that's my guess for why he has an upset stomach. But why does Paul tell him to drink a little bit of wine? And how does that connect to the previous commands? So there are two plausible options. I'm going to tell you both of them. And I think the second one's a little more plausible. So maybe Timothy was drinking only water to avoid the possibility of indulging in wine and becoming drunk. If that's the case, then Timothy thought that avoiding wine entirely was a way to stay pure. I'm not aware of any evidence that early Christians thought that it was sinful to drink alcohol, especially since Jesus turned water into wine. So, I'm not inclined to think that's the

36:46 most plausible explanation here. I think this one's a little little better. Maybe Timothy was drinking only water as a form of aseticism. So since Paul addresses the heir of aestheticism in 1 Timothy 4:1-5, it's possible Timothy was tempted to adopt the aesthetic practice of denying himself the pleasure and health benefit of drinking wine. And if this is this is the case, then Timothy wrongly thought that not drinking wine would be a way to stay pure. So Paul corrects him here.

37:18 So that's my guess of why Paul says this. I'm not I'm not totally sure. Question five, why does Paul say that a person's sins and good works may or may not be obvious? Now, so let's read verses 24 and 25. The sins of some people are conspicuous going before them to judgement, but the sins of other people appear later. They trail behind them. They're revealed later. So also good works are conspicuous. They're easy to see and even those that are not cannot remain hidden.

38:02 So how does verse how do verses 24 and 25 fit into Paul's argument here? I think these two sentences explain the end of verse 22. So keep yourself pure. And then he specifies that with this advice here in 24 and 25. Sometimes, verse 24, a person's sins are glaringly obvious. And sometimes a person's sins don't become evident until later. That's verse 24. This is why it's important not to appoint an elder hastily. If deacons must be tested first, that's what 310 says, how much more should elders be tested first? It's obvious for some guys that they're not qualified to be an

38:49 elder. It's obvious that they're immature. They're not qualified to shepherd a flock. But some guys may seem to be qualified but actually are not. So be careful. And then verse 25, good works are evident and good works that are less obvious will eventually become evident. So if a man is genuinely above reproach in his character, that will eventually become evident. I was trying to figure out a way to illustrate this and not give you a sports analogy.

39:19 So, I'm going to go gardening. All right, guys. Garden, too. So, consider the difference between growing lettuce and growing tomatoes. When you plant lettuce seeds, the time to harvest lettuce is about 30 to 60 days. When you plant tomato seeds, the time to harvest tomatoes is about 90 to 120 days. So, here's the point of the analogy. It takes more time for a tomato plant to flower and get pollinated and for the fruit to ripen.

39:54 What will happen if you plant lettuce seeds and tomato seeds at exactly the same time? If all the conditions are working rightly and they grow at a normal rate, what's going to happen? Well, the lettuce will be obvious as lettuce first and later the tomatoes will be obvious that they're tomatoes. And here's how this illustrates the end of chapter 5. A man may be able to hide his deeds in the short term like a tomato plant. But eventually, everyone's deeds will be out in the open. As Jesus says, nothing is covered that will not be revealed or hidden that will will not be known. So verses 24 and 25 are a warning. Be careful when you're considering whether to recommend that

40:44 the church appoint a man as one of the elders. Don't treat your first impressions about that guy as infallible. Don't hastily appoint an elder. Don't assume, well, he's a good guy. Surely he's ready. He's qualified. You don't know that for sure. So, proceed with caution and prayerful discernment. So, why does Paul say that a person's sins and good works may or may not be obvious? Now, answer. It's a warning to be careful when you're considering whether to appoint a man as an elder. That's command five. Keep yourself pure. So, what should we as a church do if a church member makes an accusation against an elder? There are five main commands in this passage that instruct us how to treat accusations

41:26 against an elder. Admit an accusation against an elder only on the evidence of two or three witnesses. If an elder persists in sin, publicly rebuke him so that the whole church may stand in fear. Don't practice favoritism, whether it's toward the elder or toward a witness who makes an accusation against an elder. Don't prematurely, hastily appoint an elder, lest you increase the likelihood of having to deal with a disqualified elder.

41:58 And keep yourself pure. Let's pray. Father, thank you for instructing us about how to treat accusations against an elder. Would you please help us obey what you command in this passage? We ask in the name of Christ the King. Amen.

No transcript available.