Transcript
0:07 Let's pray together. Father, as we consider what you have revealed to us about your good design for men and women, please help us to love what you love and to hate what you hate. We ask in the name of Jesus. Amen. Please open your Bible to 1 Timothy chapter 2. 1 Timothy 2. Our text today is 1 Timothy 2 11-14. We'll begin by reading 1 Timothy 2 starting in verse 11. 1 Timothy 2 verse 11. Let a woman or a
0:57 woman must learn quietly with all submissiveness. I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Rather, she is to remain quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor. Well, if you're visiting with us today, you're visiting us in the middle of a sermon series on 1 Timothy. And this is a a section of 1 Timothy. 1 Timothy verses 9-15 that are quite controversial in this evangelical church today. And this is sermon 8 of nine on this passage. So, two
1:47 sermons ago, we focused on verses 11 and 12. And in that passage, God tells us what to do. A woman positively must learn quietly and submissively. And negatively, a woman must not teach or exercise authority over a man. Then in my last sermon, we looked at verses 13 and 14, which tell us why. Reason one, is how God designed creation. God created Adam, not Eve, first. And reason two is how Satan upended God's created order. The woman, not Adam, was deceived. So, in my past two sermons, I attempted to say and explain what the
2:39 text says. Now in our cultural context explaining the text in a straightforward manner raises a lot of objections. So in this sermon I would like to preach to you on this subject. Responding to objections to 1 Timothy 2 11-14. So my past two sermons I've already responded to quite a few objections. I won't repeat all of those now. I plan to respond to 13 more objections to what Paul teaches in this passage. And the objections are written out on your uh your worship service guide if you want to follow along. And just I'll tell you up front, a pastor's job according to to Titus 1 9 and 10 is not only to teach sound doctrine. It's also to refute
3:28 those who contradict. So as I explain this passage, I also need to refute those who contradict it. That's what this sermon is. Let's start with objection number one. Paul is wrong. Some evangelical feminists dare to claim that in 1 Timothy 2 11-14, Paul is simply wrong. The first evangelical I know of who did this is one of the professors who taught John Piper at Fuller Seminary. His name is Paul King Jwitt. And I'm grateful that John Piper thoroughly rejects this view. So in Jwitt's 1975 book, Man as male and female, he claims that Paul held two contradictory views. So on the one hand,
4:19 because of Paul's patriarchal Jewish background, he affirmed a hierarchy of authority for men and women. But on the other hand, because of Paul's new Christian theology, he affirmed that men and women are fully equal in Christ, equal in every way. And Juit concludes that Paul was wrong to affirm any form of hierarchy. He says that Paul's rabbitic understanding of the Old Testament is correct. Excuse me. Yeah. Paul's rabbitic understanding of the Old Testament is incorrect. In reply to that argument, to claim that part of the Bible is wrong is false teaching.
5:05 Here's what our church's member affirmation of faith says in article one on the scriptures. So, if you're a member of our church, you believe this. The Holy Bible is God breathed and was written by men who spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit. It is a perfect treasure of heavenly instruction. It has God for its author, salvation for its end, and here it is, truth without any mixture of error for its content. It reveals the principles by which God will judge us.
5:39 Therefore, it is and will remain to the end of the world, the true center of Christian fellowship and the supreme standard for evaluating all human conduct, creeds, and opinions. So we believe that the Bible is entirely true. So follow this logic. God, this is the the major premise. God is entirely truthful. He's without error. He's inherent and he's incapable of error. He's infallible. Here's the minor premise. The Bible is God breathed. So here's the conclusion that follows from that. Therefore, the Bible is entirely truthful without error, inherent and incapable of error,
6:28 infallible. Since the Bible is God breathed, God is a liar if it contains errors. The Bible is the standard of truthfulness. For Jesus said to God, "Your word is truth." The Bible, the entire Bible is true because God is entirely true. It's simply not a valid option to claim that part of the Bible is wrong. That's objection one. Now, objection two. This passage is not clear. A good principle for interpreting the Bible is to interpret the unclear in light of the clear. Is 1 Timothy 2:1-14 clear?
7:18 Well, many who support women pastors claim that this passage is not clear and that we shouldn't use it as quote perhaps the most common weapon wielded against women pastors. End quote. Well, I chuckled with agreement when I read how Doug Wilson introduces this passage in his little commentary. We come now to a passage that has suffered much at the hands of expositors. I have no desire to take my turn at this, but the reason the passage has suffered is not because it is one of those parts of the Apostle Paul's writing that is hard to understand. The passage has been greatly abused and twisted because it is easy to understand.
7:57 So, there are at least two wrong conclusions that people can make after claiming that 1 Timothy 2 11-14 is unclear and extremely challenging to interpret. So wrong conclusion one we should not be dogmatic about what this passage means. So this you would say instead of being dogmatic about what this passage means we should be dogmatic that we should not be dogmatic about what this passage means. For example, Bill Mounts a complimentarian scholar who wrote a good technical commentary on first Timothy writes this. If one position, he's saying if either complimentarianism or evangelical feminism, if one position were truly clear or obvious, then there
8:48 would not be significantly divergent positions held by respectable scholars. Well, I strongly disagree with that statement. Simply because scholars disagree on a position does not prove that one view is not clearly correct. It's unfortunately quite common for people who say they are complimentarians to say that 1 Timothy 2 is unclear. So, you can imagine how frustrating it is for me when I hear Bible teachers in our circles describe people like me as intellectually dishonest.
9:31 Here's an excerpt from a podcast episode with Jen Wilin and JT English in 2019 titled A Generous Complimentarianism. JT says, "I love the term you just used, intellectual honesty." Anybody who says, I think of a passage like 1 Timothy 2:12, which is a passage that's often cited here. Look, we're we're being biblically faithful to the text. Anybody who tells you that text is abundantly clear, just look at the text, is being intellectually dishonest.
10:00 And Jen Wilin chimes in, well, we don't do that with baptism. I mean, historically there have been times where that's been the case, but like we're all like, "Hey, I'm cool with the way you baptize people. I get that you did the work and this is your well-formed position." But around this issue, and JT says, and even conservatives recognize that, Tom Shriner was a helpful resource for us as we walk through this text.
10:23 I'll come back to that. Speaking of 1 Timothy 2, he says this, "Scolars debate virtually every single word." Phil Reken goes on to say, "Put simply, this passage defies simple answers, and these are conservative scholars and theologians." And Jen says, ' And they're smarter than me. JT says, "But they're being intellectually honest. They're being intellectually honest by saying, "Guys, this is really hard. We need to do this prayerfully. We need to do this together. We do need to draw conclusions that make sense for local church contexts, but anybody who comes to you and says 1 Timothy 2, just look at it. It's easy." they're being intellectually dishonest. Another guy
11:01 chimes in. So, there are specific passages and 1 Timothy 2 is probably one of the more pronounced ones that are often treated as though this is abundantly clear one way or the other when it's not. So, that's a problem. Well, I think that's a problem. I think that 1 Timothy 2:9-15 is sufficiently clear and taking men like Tom Shriner out of context the way they did is not appropriate. So when when when Shriner says scholars debate every single word, he's not concluding from that and therefore we can't know what it means.
11:38 So scholars debate virtually every single word of Jesus saying, "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the father but by me. So is is the exclusivity of Christ now not something we should be dogmatic about because scholars debate every single word? So for one of my systematic theology classes, I require my students to survey a book by Wayne Gudum that's over 850 pages. It's called Evangelical Feminism and Biblical Truth, an analysis of more than 100 disputed questions. And what Grudam does, he's painstakingly responds to all these arguments for evangelical feminism. And I remember in one of my class discussions years ago, a student asked me, you know, what do you
12:21 think are the strongest arguments for evangelical feminism? And I can usually analyze a viewpoint I disagree with, like baptizing infants, and I can articulate aspects of it that I recognize, you know, that's actually a pretty good argument, but here's why I don't find it ultimately compelling. But when it comes to arguments for evangelical feminism, I can't do that. Like I've I've read countless hundreds of pages of arguments for evangelical feminism, and I can't think of a single argument for it that is even remotely compelling.
12:58 This issue is remarkably clearer than more complex matters like credto baptism versus pedo baptism or your view of the millennium. So that's the first wrong conclusion. We should not be dogmatic about what this passage means. Here's a second wrong conclusion. We should interpret 1 Timothy 2 11-14 in light of Galatians 3:28, which is a clear passage that supports evangelical feminism. So this view is saying Galatians 3:28 is clear. It teaches feminism. Let's interpret 1 Timothy 2 in light of Galatians 3:28. That's the argument.
13:37 Well, let me show you the immediate literary context of Galatians 3:28. I'll just read verses 27 to 28 to 29. For in Christ Jesus, you are all sons of God through faith. For as many of as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ. And here's the the passage that people claim supports evangelical feminism. There is neither Jew nor Greek. There's neither slave nor free. There is no male and female. For you are all one in Christ Jesus. And if you are Christ, if you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham's offspring, hes according to the promise.
14:16 So those three contrasts in verse 28, uh Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, the point of those three contrasts is that all of those people are one in Christ Jesus. So what Paul's doing, he's rhetorically pairing uh mankind in these three pairs. So uh it's all mankind from the perspective of ethnicity, Jew or Greek. All mankind from the perspective of law, slave nor free, all mankind from the perspective of sex, male and female. The evangelical feminist argument misreads this passage and misapplies it. So Paul's point is that diverse people are one in the sense of having something in
15:05 common but without obliterating distinctions. For example, Paul writes elsewhere, "He who plants and he who waters are one." That's one in purpose. It's 1 Corinthians 3:8. He writes in Romans 12:5, "We though many are one body in Christ." So oneness is not sameness. I like how Piper and Grudam explain this passage. There's a few sentences here. The context of Galatians 3:28 makes abundantly clear the sense in which men and women are equal in Christ. They're equally justified by faith. Verse 24, they're equally free from the bondage of legalism. Verse 25, equally children of God. Verse 26, equally clothed with Christ. Verse 27, equally possessed by Christ. Verse 29, equally heirs of the
15:49 promises to Abraham. Verse 29. He does not say you're all the same in Christ Jesus. You're all one in Christ Jesus. He's stressing unity, not sameness. And it's only very recently in church history that Christians have argued that Galatians 3:28 supports evangelical feminism. It's yet another attempt to reinterpret God's words to justify what God forbids. That's objection number two. Now, objection number three. I agree that Paul teaches that a woman may not be a pastor, but I don't like it.
16:30 This is not full obedience. This is a form of disobedience. This is thinking like you know better than God. We should never talk about the Bible in a way where we put ourselves over it and we critique it and we apologize for it. It's never appropriate. God not only tells us the rules, he tells us the reasons for the rules. So, it's good to do what God says. It's better to do what God says as you understand why. And it's best to do what God says as you understand why. And love his good and brilliant design. That's mature obedience.
17:14 That's obedience that honors God. His rules are not arbitrary. His rules make sense. Objection four. Women were more easily deceived in the historical cultural context of the first century. But that's not the case. Now, evangelical feminists attempt to explain away this passage by arguing that the historical cultural context of Ephesus restricts how we should apply it in our culture today. So, this objection is another version of the women in Ephesus were not educated argument, a claim I addressed in the sermon on verses 11 and 12. Here's an example of someone who argues this way. William Webb says this, the research, not the ex Jesus of the Bible, but the research shows that
18:05 gender is not a significant issue in detecting deception. Women in Paul's day were generally more easily deceived than men. Women in patriarchal societies generally married at a younger age than men were not permitted the range of experiences and social exposure of men and were often restricted in their formal education. The best solution then is to say that the social data has changed from Paul's day to ours. Applying 1 Timothy 2:14 today requires that we work with the underlying transcultural principle. Seek teachers and leaders who are not easily deceived.
18:45 In reply, that is simply not the transcultural principle that Paul states in the text. Paul says in verses 13 and 14 that a woman should not teach or exercise authority over a man because of the created order, not because of some temporary matter in that culture at that time. I addressed that in my sermon, my last sermon on verses 13 and 14. Objection five, we should reject what the Bible says about women submitting to men in the same way that we should reject what the Bible says about slavery.
19:26 Some evangelical feminists argue that we should adopt what's called a trajectory hermeneutic. You heard that term before, trajectory hermeneutic. In other words, they argue that we should interpret the ethical trajectory or the movement of the Bible beyond the Bible. For example, they argue the Bible doesn't explicitly condemn slavery, but we should follow its trajectory and condemn slavery today. And in a similar way, we should follow the Bible's trajectory on men and women, which means that now we should adopt feminism.
20:02 In reply, what the Bible says about slavery is not a ground for us to reject what the Bible says about women submitting to men. Here's why. The issues are not parallel. Because God's rules for men and women are based on how he designed men and women from the beginning of creation. The Bible does not root slavery in the created order. Read Genesis 1 and 2. You see anything about slavery at the beginning? There's nothing.
20:36 There's nothing in the Bible about God's design from the beginning for some humans to own other humans. Later in the Bible, God regulates slavery. But he did not institute slavery like he did marriage in the family. Slavery is more like divorce. Divorce was not part of the created order. Divorce is a result of sin. and God mercifully regulates it. Now, I plan to come back to this and talk more about slavery when I preach on 1 Timothy 6 1-2, but for now, I'll just say that objection six. This one's a little more complex argument, so see if you can follow this.
21:17 If the argument from creation in 1 Timothy 2:13-14 is a transcultural basis for women not teaching or exercising authority over men. That's what I've argued. Then it is inconsistent to conclude that the argument from creation in 1 Corinthians 11:8-10 doesn't mean that wives should wear head coverings. Today I'll try to say this a few more times so you understand the argument. Basically both 1 Timothy 2 and 1 Corinthians 11 make arguments from creation. In 1 Timothy 2 it's women don't teach or exercise authority over men because creation in first in 1 Corinthians 11 it's women should wear head coverings
22:08 because creation or that's the argument here. Let me just show you that passage from 1 Corinthians 11. For a man ought not to cover his head since he's the image and glory of God, but woman is the glory of man. For man was not made for woman, but woman from man. Neither was man created for woman, but woman for man. That is why a wife ought to have a symbol of authority on her head because of the angels. Nevertheless, in the Lord, woman is not independent of man, nor man of woman.
22:39 For as woman was made from man, so man is now born of woman, and all things are from God. And it's that bit in the middle I'm referring to. Here's the argument from creation verses 8 and 9. And then the conclusion, therefore, wear wear a head covering. Now, I don't have time now to explain 1 Corinthians 11 2-16 in detail. You're welcome to check out my article on that at christoverall.com. It's titled Women in Head Coverings, explaining and applying 1 Corinthians 112-16.
23:08 For now, I'm highlighting how Paul argues in 1 Corinthians 11:8 and9. Paul argues from creation. So the principle here that transcends cultures is that God has designed husbands and wives different differently. Paul is applying this principle to first century Christians regarding head coverings in their Greco Roman Greco Roman context. Most complimentarians today don't insist that 1 Corinthians 11 requires women in all cultures to wear head coverings. But we do argue that based on 1 Timothy 2:13-4 that that that is that women should not teach or exercise authority over a man because of creation. But here's the thing in both passages,
23:56 Paul's arguing from creation. But here's the solution to the tension I presented in 1 Corinthians 11. When Paul argues from creation, the principle, the transcultural principle is not the specific application that women should wear head coverings. The transcultural principle is that God has designed God has designed men and women differently with distinct callings that are not interchangeable. And then he applies that to that situation. I think Tom Shriner put it well when he says we must distinguish between the principle and the cultural outworking of a principle. So for reasons I explained in my article in 1 Corinthians 11, I don't think that women
24:43 must wear head coverings in church services for all time in all cultures. But I would advocate that women do that before I would advocate that we disobey first Timothy 2. That's objection six. Objection seven. Although a woman may not be a pastor, a woman may preach if she does so under the authority of a church's pastors. So some narrow complimentarians hold this view, which is closer to evangelical feminism than it is to biblical patriarchy.
25:19 They argue that Paul forbids a woman to hold the office of pastor, but a woman may do what pastors do. Women may teach and preach and exercise authority over men. In reply, in 1 Timothy 2 11-14, Paul prohibits women from what pastors do, not just from the office of pastor. And I don't know if you if you have your Bible open to 1 Timothy 2, if you just look at the next paragraph, unfortunately, there's a chapter break.
25:51 So, it's chapter three and following. The very next paragraph gives qualifications for elders or pastors. And one of them is in chapter 3:2, able to teach. The kind of teaching Paul has in mind in 212 is the same kind he highlights in 3:2. It's the kind that's fitting for an elder for a pastor. And then later in the same letter in 5:17, Paul writes, "Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching." So what does an elder or pastor do in according to 5:17? There are two actions. Ruling or exercising authority and teaching and preaching.
26:38 That corresponds to chapter 2:12. Exercising authority and teaching. Now, Paul could have written in 2:12, "I do not permit a woman to be a pastor." That's not what he said. He wrote, "I do not permit a woman to teach or exercise authority over men." He's emphasizing the activity, not just the office. Paul highlights what pastors do. Paul is saying that a woman may not be a pastor, but he's saying more than that. He is also saying that a woman may not do what pastors do.
27:11 Now, objection eight. Although a woman may not be a pastor, highcapacity women should be in the room where it happens in order to represent women. Very common argument. People say we're complimentarian, but we also want women in our elder meetings, not to vote as elders, but just to represent women and to contribute. Here's an example. Two evangelical New Testament professors argue this in a book they co-authored. Even on this understanding that is that only a man may be the senior pastor.
27:48 Most evangelical churches have a long way to go before coming anywhere close to violating Paul's teaching. And we need to consider many more ways of getting women active and using all their gifts. One can exercise the gift of pastoring or deliver sermons as a preacher, for example, without holding the office of elder or senior pastor in a congregation. In addition, the use of the term elder in many churches today confuses the issue and ends up imposing more restrictions on women than are justified by even a complimentarian interpretation of Paul's argument. In traditions in which elder refers not to senior pastor but to a leadership or decision-making team or pastoral
28:24 advisory board, there's no biblical justification for excluding women from this group since this is not the New Testament meaning of elder, the senior teaching authority. In fact, it is inadvisable not to have representation of women on such a board given that probably more than half of the congregation are women and their perspectives require firstirhand representation. It's a very common argument even in complimentarian circles. In reply, if we use that same logic, then it is unjust for a father and mother to make decisions for their family without some of their children being present in the room where it happens in order to represent the children. Same logic. This kind of
29:12 thinking is worldly. It's the same kind of thinking that underlies DEI policies, diversity, equity, and inclusion. For example, a company's board must have a certain percentage of different ethnicities and sexes. This kind of thinking is what happens after you have been pressed into the world's mold. It is not what the Bible teaches. Objection 9. What Paul teaches in 1 Timothy 2 11-14 has nothing to do with what a woman may do outside of the specific context of a church's weekly worship service.
29:53 So is Paul prohibiting women only from preaching in the Sunday morning worship service or is he prohibiting other forms of public teaching? For example, may women teach men in Sunday school or other church classes that are different than the Sunday morning worship service. May women teach theology courses to seminary students to seminaries that are training pastors. We should wisely apply the logic Paul uses here to all of life. So, we should ask further questions. Should women be upfront as much as possible as leaders during a church's weekly worship service? Should women serve as police officers or military figures in combat?
30:38 Should women serve as political rulers like President of the United States? So, based on what God has revealed in scripture and in nature, what is most fitting? That's the question. based on what he's revealed in scripture and nature, what is most fitting. Some people argue that 1 Timothy 2:12 prohibits a woman from being a pastor or from preaching a sermon on a Sunday morning, but that a woman may teach the Bible and theology to men in any other context outside of that. But I'd say based on the spirit and the logic of 1 Timothy 2, not to mention what God has revealed in the rest of the Bible and in nature itself, it is not fitting for a woman to authoritatively
31:28 teach the Bible and theology to men. Objection 10. If a church does not allow a gifted woman to preach, then that church is sinfully silencing and suppressing her spiritual gift. This view is wrong for at least three reasons. Reason one, this view misunderstands what a spiritual gift is by thinking of it as an ability that an individual must publicly express to be fulfilled. Looks like I didn't write that out for you. I'll say that again. This view misunderstands what a spiritual gift is by thinking of it as an ability that an individual must publicly express to be
32:16 fulfilled. So what is a spiritual gift? I think a lot of Christians misunderstand this. They they take spiritual gift tests and they walk away thinking, I've got these spiritual gifts and now I've got to figure out how I can use these and only these gifts in this context. A spiritual gift is a ministry that the spirit distributes to and empowers in an individual Christian for the common good. I'll say that again. A spiritual gift is a ministry the spirit distributes to and empowers in an individual Christian for the common good. Paul writes this in 1 Corinthians 12:7. to each is given the manifestation of the spirit for the common good. So this objection thinks about spiritual gifts the way
33:05 that pagans think about expressive individualism. In other words, this argument presupposes that if I have a particular spiritual gift, I must be able to freely express my spiritual gift so I can be fulfilled. That's not the point of spiritual gifts. The point of spiritual gifts is for the common good, to build up the church. A second reason this view is wrong is that it misunderstands what the common good is for the church.
33:31 Who defines what the common good is in 1 Corinthians 12:7? Well, God does, right? And God has designed his creation in such a way that a woman teaching or exercising authority over men is not for the common good. It's not good for a woman to teach or exercise authority over men. And then a third reason this objection is wrong is that this view overvalues public ministry and it undervalues private ministry. If God has gifted a woman to teach, then there are many fitting ways that a woman can use that gift to build up her family and her church. But one of the ways that it is not fitting for a woman to do that
34:20 is to teach or exercise authority over men. I'll use my wife as an illustration here. Heads up, I didn't tell you I was going to do this. My wife Jenny has the gift of teaching. She is gifted at explaining complicated topics clearly and concisely to children. It really is remarkable. And she uses that gift every day. Every weekday at the breakfast table, she's reading the Bible with the kids and she's answering hard questions. She does it throughout the day around the house as their daughters ask thousands of questions about God's word and God's world. She uses it as she interacts with some of you in our church.
35:01 I'm so grateful that the spirit of God distributed the gift of teaching to my wife and that he empowers her to use that gift for the common good. But that doesn't mean that Jenny should be preaching sermons to our church. That would not be fitting because it rebelss against God's good design for women. So when our church does not allow Jenny to teach or exercise authority over men, we are honoring Jenny. We're not sinfully silencing her and suppressing her. We want Jenny and all the ladies in this church to be faithful and fruitful. Part of being a faithful and fruitful woman means that you
35:50 cheerfully learn with all submissiveness when your pastors teach and exercise authority. It would be bad for Jenny and it would be it would be bad for our church if we encouraged her to rebel against God. Objection 11. A church that does not allow women to preach fosters abuse. In reply, four statements. Number one, the word abuse has become so elastic that it is imprecise. I pretty much avoid using that word anymore.
36:31 The word abuse used to refer to physical harm or sexual harm. So physical abuse is intentionally harming someone's body. Sexual abuse is having inappropriate sexual contact with someone's body. But what's happened is the word abuse has expanded to include emotional and psychological mistreatment or what people perceive as mistreatment. And some use the word abuse for what they think is neglecting to show sufficient care and concern.
37:03 My point here is that the word abuse has become a vague word. So instead of using abuse, I can think of at least four better terms. Uh physically attack, sexually assault, oppress, mistreat. Those are clearer. Statement two, sociological studies on complimentarian churches show that nominal Christianity, not complimentarianism, leads to mistreating women. So nominal Christianity refers to men who claim to be conservative Protestant but who don't regularly meet with the church. They're just Christian in name only. So for here, I recommend an article in 2019 at ninemarks.org. by Caleb Morell, M O R E L L, titled Nominal Christianity, not complimentarianism leads to abuse.
37:52 Statement three, we meaning our pastors of this church and our church as a whole, we hate it when a man physically attacks or sexually assaults or oppresses or mistreats a woman. When a man does that, he is sinning against God and against that woman. And our church hates what God hates. That means we hate the sin of misusing authority. We hate that particular sin in the home when a husband misuses his authority over his wife and children. And we hate that sin in the church. When a pastor misuses his authority over the members, we don't tolerate the sin of misusing authority in the home or the church. We don't turn a blind eye to that.
38:33 And finally, statement four, it's actually mistreating a woman to allow and encourage her to preach because that's encouraging her to rebel against God. So it might seem like we are pro-women if we encourage them to preach. But we would actually be anti-women if we did that. It would be bad for women. It'd be bad for a church if we encourage women to rebel against God. Objection 12. It's inconsistent to say that only pastors may teach and exercise authority and then allow men who are not pastors to preach. A consistent principle is that a woman may do anything an unordained man may do.
39:22 So I was a pastor of the North Church for about nine years. But when I was not a pastor, I preached a lot of sermons. So, for some of those sermons, I was a college student or a seminary student preparing for ministry. For some of those sermons, I was actually training future pastors as a professor, but I wasn't a pastor yet. For some of those sermons, uh, were the final five months of last year when I was in between being a pastor of the North Church and preparing to plant this church. So, when I preached all those sermons, not as as not a pastor, was I wrong?
39:57 I was just a faithful church member. I wasn't a pastor. Does that undermine everything I've been saying? I don't think so. And it'll make us even more more tensionfilled uh in the future. The pastors of this church plan to have other men teach and preach to our church. And some of those men may not be pastors when they do that. We've already done that by inviting Andrew Wittenberg and Clint Manley to give exhortations.
40:28 So, it's already happened. We've we've invited non-pastors to teach from the pulpit. Are we being inconsistent? No, that's not inconsistent. No, we should not adopt the feminist leading principle that a woman may do anything an unordained man may do. Here are two reasons. Reason one, a church needs to be able to hear a man teach before we can affirm that he's able to teach. 1 Timothy 3:2 says that an elder must be able to teach. So, how do you know if he's able to teach? If it's a qualification for a pastor, you have to be able to assess that to affirm it. If a man's not a pastor and we're considering whether to call him as a pastor, we need to know, is he able to
41:15 teach? How will we know that? We hear him teach, right? A man who isn't a pastor needs the opportunity to publicly teach in order for the church to call him to be a pastor. Does a woman need that same opportunity? No. Because it's not a faithful option for her to be a pastor. So such public teaching opportunities for a man is similar to a medical residency or an internship. A person who aspires to do heart surgery needs a period of practical training in which skilled surgeons supervise and evaluate and coach him. And it's similar for a pastor in training. A second reason is it's not fitting for a woman to teach or exercise authority over a man, but it is fitting for a man to do that if he's qualified
42:01 to be a pastor, but is not currently a pastor. I'm not saying that any man may preach a sermon. He must meet the qualifications for a pastor in 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1. Such teaching is fitting because it's in line with the created order as God designed men and women. For example, here are some categories of people whom I would happily invite to preach to our church even though they're not currently pastors. One category is former pastors. Example, John Piper.
42:31 He's not currently a pastor, but it would be fitting for him to preach a sermon to our church. Another example is John Ericson who leads the Treasuring Christ together network. He was a pastor but he's not now. Another category is some of my colleagues at Bethlehem College and Seminary. Some of them are not currently pastors. John Beckman, Jared Compton, Zack Howard, Lance Kramer, James Mclofflin, Brian Tab, and we have one sitting right here visiting us today from Bethlehem Baptist Church downtown.
43:00 it'd be fitting for uh Timothy Devi to preach to us even though he's not currently a pastor. Another category is some students at Bethlehem Seminary. These men are training to be pastors. Some of them has been pastors before like Clint Manley before he came to seminary. But most of those men I trained were not previously pastors. Like Nathan Koltock, he was not a pastor. Came to seminary and now he's a pastor. But while he was in seminary, I think it would have been fitting for him to preach. And another category is some men in our church who are not pastors. Some men in our church have not been a pastor before, but they aspire to be or at least they're open to the
43:42 possibility of someday serving as a pastor. So even though those men are not currently pastors, it's fitting for them to preach God's word because they're qualified men. And finally, objection 13, last one. Deborah exercised authority over men as a leader in Israel. So, a woman may exercise authority over men in the church. I added this one because I was talking to some of the guys a few weeks ago and one of them said, "What about Deborah?"
44:15 So, this is for you. You know who you are. Evangelical feminists often cite the prophetus Deborah in Judges 4. Here's what Stanley Gren asserts. Deborah served as the highest leader of her people. Although she was married, her leadership role included the exercise of authority over men. The example of Deborah confirms that neither God nor the ancient Hebrews found female leadership intrinsically abhorentt. On the contrary, a woman could and did exercise authority over the entire community, including men.
44:57 So, what about Deborah? In reply, I agree with three insightful comments from Wayne Gutam on this on this passage. I can't improve them. I'll I'll paraphrase them. So, one, Deborah affirmed fitting male leadership over God's people. If you read Judges 4, you'll see that she didn't summon the people of Israel into battle. She encouraged Bareric to do this. So she didn't assert herself as a leader. She affirmed the rightness of male leadership. And then when Bareric hesitated and insisted that she come with him. Do you remember what she said to Bareric? She said, "I will surely go with you. Nevertheless, the road on which you are going will not lead to your glory, for the Lord will sell
45:40 Cicora into the hand of a woman." It's a rebuke. A second insight is that the the passage in Judges 4 doesn't say that Deborah ever ruled over God's people. She didn't teach them the word of God. She wasn't their military leader. This is important because in the Old Testament, the priests taught the scriptures. She never served in that priestly role and she refused to lead the people in battle. She insisted a man do that. And then a third insightful comment here is that the Bible views Deborah's leadership, whatever that was, not as a model, but as a rebuke to the absence of male leadership. So then you might have the question, well, does the story of Deborah show that when men
46:28 aren't taking the lead in the right way, that women should step up and take the lead? And reply to that, no. Deborah didn't even do that. The story of Deborah should motivate women in situations to do what she did, which is encourage and exhort a man to do what God's called him to do, not for her to supplant him or replace him. You think about it. Uh the way the Old Testament portrays women in story after story after story, you see patterns developing. In in Kevin D. Young's book, Men and Women in the Church, he highlights five patterns throughout the Old Testament. One of them is that only men exercise official leadership.
47:09 Another is that godly women display a wide range of heroic characteristics like strength and courage and resourcefulness. Another is that godly women help men. Think Rahab, Deborah, Ruth, Abigail, Esther. Another pattern is that unlink that ungodly women influence men for evil. So think Jezebel, Delilah. And ungodly men mistreat women like Tamar and Bath Sheba. And another pattern is that women find purpose because of God's design and pain because of the fall associated with bearing and caring for children. Think Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel, Hannah.
47:52 So, those are 13 objections to what Paul teaches in 1 Timothy 2:1-14. They're actually a lot more. I just chose some of the most relevant ones, the ones I hear the most in our circles. So, once again, here's what Paul writes in this passage. A woman must learn quietly with all submissiveness. I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Rather, she is to remain quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve, and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor.
48:26 Verses 11 and 12, God tells us what to do. Verses 13 and 14, God tells us why. And when you explain this text in a straightforward way, people object in lots of ways. I just I attempted to respond to 13 objections. But my prayer now after all of that is that as as we have all considered this passage and objections to what Paul teaches that at this point you understand what God says about his design for men and women and that you want to obey what God says about men and women and that you understand why God says what he says about men and women. And here's the
49:16 the next level to get to a mature obedience that you love God's good and brilliant design for men and women. Let's pray. Father, please open our eyes so that we rightly understand what you have revealed to us in scripture and in nature about your design for men and women. Please give us grace to obey what you have commanded. Please help us understand the reasons for your rules so that we recognize your rules as reasonable and sensible.
49:54 And please help us love your good and brilliant design for men and women. We ask all this in the name of Christ the King. Amen.
No transcript available.
