Transcript
0:02 Let's pray together. Father, as we consider what you have revealed to us about your good design for men and women, would you please help us to love what you love and to hate what you hate? And we ask this in the name of Christ the King. Amen. Please open your Bibles to 1 Timothy chapter 2. 2 as I preach through 1 Timothy. The
0:48 next text in our series is 1 Timothy 2 9-15. So let's start by reading that together. 1 Timothy 2 9-15 Likewise also that women should adorn themselves in respectable apparel with modesty and self-control, not with braided hair and gold or pearls or costly attire, but with what is proper for women who profess godliness, with good works. Let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Rather, she is to remain quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and
1:38 became a transgressor. Yet she will be saved through childbearing if they continue in faith and love and holiness with self-control. Well, this is sermon two in a mini series on God's good design for men and women. So, here's the plan again from last week. In sermons 1-4, I'm zooming out to summarize what the whole Bible says about God's good design for men and women. And then in sermons 5-9, I plan to zoom right back in on that passage we just read. 1 Timothy 2:9-15. I keep hearing thumping.
2:16 Am I doing something wrong? Yeah, I don't want you to be miserable for the next little bit here. That should be better. All right. So, in sermons 1 through 4, here's what we did last week. Explain a spectrum of views on manhood and womanhood and explain two different types of complimentarianism. Do you all remember what the two types are from last week? Narrow and broad. And another word for broad complimentarian is biblical patriarchy. Okay, today I'm going to give five exhortations and then in the next two sermons I plan to give six arguments from the Bible in favor of biblical patriarchy and then we'll go back to 1 Timothy 2:9-15. So in this sermon, my five exhortations are for
3:04 brothers and sisters who affirm complimentarianism. Again, I'm using all these labels and sometimes you hear so many labels you can you can lose track of what we're talking about. So let me just remind you the label complimentarian means that men and women are both equal in value and dignity and that God designed them with beneficial differences. We read the Danverse statement today. That's that's mere complimentarianism. This view holds that a husband is the head of his wife and that only men may be pastors. The label egalitarianism or evangelical feminism means that men and women should share authority equally in the home and the church and society. So this view rejects
3:47 that a husband has author it rejects the view that a husband has authority over his wife and it says that women may be pastors. So I'm assuming that most of us are complimentarian. But as I give my five exhortations here, I'm also planning to address others who may be on the fence between complimentarianism and evangelical feminism. So let's start with exhortation number one. Study God's design for men and women for yourself. So many Christians have not done this. They haven't carefully studied for themselves what the Bible teaches about God's design for men and women. Many Christians have inherited this from the family they've been part of, from their church. But my
4:32 exhortation here is become deeply convinced about this because of what the Bible says. Don't believe something just because John Piper says it or just because Beth Moore says it or whoever. Believe it because the Bible says it. The primary source is the Bible. So carefully read and reread the Bible. It's the only must-read book. I'm about to suggest some other books to you, but just remember that statement I just said. The Bible's the only must-read book. Uh and you say, "Well, why would we need other books?" Well, we don't need them. But one of God's gifts to his people is teachers. That includes pastors. It also includes godly women who can teach younger women in
5:17 accordance with Titus 2. So we can learn from gifted teachers. That's how we can learn from from good books. And this is one of the reasons that Christ the King Church has given each household who are members a subscription to Canon Plus. I hope you're using that. It's full of good content. Our pastors are doing what we can to feed you on Sundays during the equip hour and the Sunday service, but that's only about two hours and the week has about 168 of them. So, we want you to fill those other hours with good teaching and we think that the resources on Canon Plus are a rich resource for you. So, our pastors don't agree with every single opinion that every single person on Canon Plus
5:59 expresses. Obviously, I'm guessing the people who are on that platform don't agree themselves with everything. U for example, we're not convinced that a church should baptize infants. And that's a pretty common view on that platform. And the the pastors of our church are not convinced that a church should let infants celebrate the Lord's supper before they can credibly profess to follow Jesus. That's another view that's prominent on that platform.
6:24 Basically, we don't agree with those who baptize infants regarding how the covenants, the major covenants in the Bible relate to each other, but we respect the reformed view historically so highly as our brothers articulate it. And we think you're mature enough to think critically as you benefit from the many resources there. So, Canon Plus is filled with outstanding audio books and sermons and lectures and videos and documentaries and podcasts that help you understand God's good design for men and women, especially in marriage and parenting. So, the resources I'm about to recommend to you are available on Canon Plus. I'm highlighting them since you all have access to them if you're a
7:04 member. And so you don't scramble to write down everything I'm about to show you, I have an email scheduled to send at 11:30 with everything I'm about to say. So just take it in visually and audibly. So I'll say this to start off. God has used books by Doug Wilson on the family to help me be a better man, better husband, better father. And here are 11 of those books. First, standing on the promises, a handbook of biblical child rearing. His practical parenting advice is gold. Her hand in marriage, biblical courtship in the modern world, full of wisdom about how to approach getting married. Federal husband, covenant headship, and the Christian man. A
7:55 husband is responsible before God to lead his wife and children. Authority flows to men who take responsibility. Father hunger. Why God calls men to love and lead their families. Doug Wilson defines masculinity as the glad assumption of sacrificial responsibility. That's what it means to be a man. So, Canon Plus has sermons on this topic, but the audiobook is not on Canon Plus because it's published by Nelson. Future men raising boys to fight giants. So, God created men to exercise dominion over the earth. They are to be fitted to be husband men tilling the earth. They are equipped to be saviors delivering from evil. They are expected
8:43 to grow up into wisdom, becoming sages. They are designed to reflect the image and glory of God. That's what a man is. And there's also a future men documentary, raising boys to fight giants. Lots of practical insights here. Reforming marriage, gospel living for couples. Wise advice for mar married couples. Sorry for the cover there. Uh, how to exasperate your wife and other short essays for men. This is wise advice for husbands with Doug Wilson's flare for wordsmithing.
9:16 Why children matter, more practical advice for parenting. There's also a series of short videos by the same title. Uh in our equip hour a few weeks ago, we showed one of those. We plan to do that again shortly. Get the girl. How to be the kind of man, the kind of woman you want to marry, would want to marry. And this goes together with get the guy, how to be the kind of woman, the kind of man you want to marry, would want to marry. So, these two books are fictional letters that Doug writes to his unmarried niece and unmarried nephew. I read both Get the Guy and Get the Girl out loud at our dinner table to my daughters, letter by letter, and it was really helpful to to
9:59 discuss what he's saying. It's just filled with practical insights about guys and girls, how to think about dating, courtship, and marriage. And one more, keep your kids. How to raise strong kids in an age of therapeutic sentimentalism. again more wise advice about how to parent in our secular evil culture. So Doug Wilson's books on the family are full of practical wisdom and encouragement. They're enlightening, inspiring, motivating, and a bonus is that he writes with a style that is a pleasure to read. And here are some more resources, not by Doug, but by some others that are also on Canon Plus.
10:38 Michael Clary, God's Good Design: A Biblical, Theological, and Practical Guide to Human Sexuality. I reviewed this book for American Reformer, and I concluded that overall, this book is timely. It's faithful, courageous, accessible, inspiring. A year or two ago, Pastor Tom Dods taught uh not Faithful Men, what you call it, Men on Mission for a group of men. And he used this as one of the the main textbooks for it. And you don't regret that, right? Good book. Here's another one. My dear hemlock by Tilly Dillah. So Tilly has co-hosted a podcast with Abigail Dod's pas pastor Tom's wife Abigail and she writes the forward to this book. So you can ask Abigail what she thinks
11:20 about it. Um so Tilly is writing here in the style of CS Lewis's Screw Tape Letters. So anyone read Screw Tape Letters? Okay, most of you. It's so good. So that's that's a diabolical ventriloquism. That's what CS Lewis called it. He's writing Riley in reverse from the perspective of demons. And Tilly tries to do that with the voice of women demons talking to each other, particularly focusing on how women are tempted to rebel against God. And in the email I'll send you, there's some other links of Doug Wilson interviewing Tilly about it, Rachel Jenovich and Abigail Dods talking to her about it, and then just Abigail interviewing her. Speaking of Abigail, a typical woman, free,
12:00 whole, and called in Christ. So unlike a woman who is currently a Supreme Court Justice of the United States, Abigail Dods knows what a woman is. Good job, Abigail. That's a low bar, isn't it? But she does more than just answer that question. Here's another one. Michael Foster and Non Tenant, It's Good to Be a Man, a Handbook for Godly Masculinity. And there's also a 49minute documentary, a map to manhood. And the book and the documentary motivate men to have a a weightbearing gravitas through God-honoring delightful duty. So it encourages men to have a mission with an excellent wife and a fraternity, a band of brothers. Build and fight. Zach Harris's Zack Garris's book
12:46 masculine Christianity is worth reading. Uh, I don't agree with how he exedates, how he interprets every passage like 1 Corinthians 11 and 14, but overall his approach is refreshingly countercultural and it's in line with what Christians have believed about men and women for millennia. Here are a few books by Rachel Jenovich. She is one of Doug Wilson's two daughters. And this is practical parenting advice for moms. And then this one, Fit to Burst, Abundance, Mayhem, and the Joys of Motherhood. more practical parenting advice for moms. She just released a new book uh titled No Time to Be Dumb. It's letters to I forget the subtitle.
13:27 Letters to teenage daughters, something like that. Uh the audio book's not out yet, so I haven't read it, but I'm I'm assuming it's another good one. John MacArthur, the war on children, providing refuge for your children in a hostile world. So MacArthur does not mince words on how our culture is corrupting children. Very good analysis. Even exile and the restoration of femininity by Rebecca Merkel. Becca is the other daughter of Doug and Nancy Wilson. So there's a documentary that goes along with this book. So I reviewed the book and then I endorsed the documentary. Uh here's what I said for the the documentary like her book. This documentary is timely, wise, witty,
14:10 motivating. I can hold up Rebecca Merkel as an example to my daughters of a Christian wife and mother who is at the same time wise, witty, skilled, well educated, and rock solid on believing and cherishing what God the Creator has revealed about men and women. And she recently recorded an interview for the podcast of Flames and Crowns called Feminine Ambition and Feminist Lies, which I'll link to to for you in the email. Very good. Here's another one, The Sin of Empathy, Compassion and Its Counterfeits by Joe Riggnney. This book is a result of more than a decade of Joe's writing and speaking on how empathy can be sinful. and he dedicates this book to Tom and Abigail and to
14:54 Jenny and me because uh Joe and the rest of us and Jenny Riggnney walk through some deep waters regarding sinful empathy in the context of Bethlehem College and Seminary and at the time our church context, Bethlehem Baptist Church. The truths in this book widely apply to the Christian life, but I'm highlighting it here because it applies particularly to God's good design for men and women. God designed women to have a holy and fruitful kind of empathy that nurtures children. That's really good. And it's good to be aware that empathy can be sinful when we untether it from the truth. When we untether it from reality and men who are leading need to be aware of that as uh we lead
15:40 so that we're not manipulated by a sinful empathy. We need to be aware how others want to put a steering wheel on our back. Thoughts for young men by JC Riyle. This a short one, just two hours, but it's a classic for men, the Fruit of Herands, Respect, and the Christian Woman. So, I'm going to show you a few books by Nancy Wilson. She's wife of Doug, and she's, I would say, the hidden treasure on Canon Plus. Check out her stuff. Uh, she has a podcast called Feminina. She's a model Titus 2 woman who trains younger women to be godly women. So this book and the next two are just filled with practical insights from a godly older woman.
16:20 Another one is Praer in the Gates, the calling of Christian motherhood and building her house. Common sensical wisdom for Christian women. Do you want some more? Is that enough for a while? I keep you busy. Okay. I think I'll keep you busy for at least a week. Uh we can talk about more next week if you'd like. There's no excuse not to be developing your own convictions on this and learning. There's so much that's right at your fingertips. You can do this while you're driving, while you're doing chores. Take advantage of this. Uh these resources wisely present what the Bible teaches. They cheerfully follow our creator's good design. And that's just a sampling of what's out there. So number one,
17:03 exhortation. Study God's design for men and women for yourself. Here's exhortation two. Beware of the ditches on either side of biblical patriarchy. The ditch on the right is authoritarianism. Men may misuse their authority and hinder women from being holy and happy the way that God designed. Doug Wilson calls a version of this view not the patriarchy but the patriarchy. The sin here is that men think they may selfishly misuse their authority. They misuse what the Bible says about men having authority in order to justify their sin like physical abuse
17:52 or just flatout harshness. This is wicked. God hates it so we should hate it. The ditch on the left is egalitarianism or feminism. This view claims that men and women should share equally authority in the home, church, and society. And some people hold a version of egalitarianism that's relatively mild or soft, but it's still a ditch because it's contrary to God's good design for men and women. Now, understanding these two errors is important as we analyze why we might struggle with what I'm calling broad complimentarianism or biblical patriarchy. So, let me just remind you what those terms emphasize. Complimentarianism emphasizes
18:39 that God designed men and women to complement each other. They're not interchangeable. You can see it right there in the word compliment. I can help you remember what that's referring to. Men and women compliment each other. Broad complimentarianism emphasizes that the way God created and designed males and females applies broadly in some way to all of life in the home, church, and society. It's not just narrowly, it's broadly. So the narrow view says it's just marriage and ordination. And the broad says no, no, it's all of life. And then the term patriarchy emphasizes that God designed fathers to rule. Remember pater is a word for father. Arco or ar rule. Father rule. God designed both
19:21 complimentarity and hierarchy. An increasingly popular view in complimentarian circles over the past decade or so is that we need a complimentarianism that is more generous, more progressive, more gentle, more egalitarian or at least uh more liberating to women they may say. And some Christian women who are in these complimentarian circles say they need to get out of that and recover from biblical manhood and womanhood. So what do you make of that when someone says he or she needs to recover from biblical
20:08 manhood or womanhood? Well, to recover means you're returning to a normal state of health, mind, strength. So if a woman genuinely needs to recover from God's design for men and women, what do you think the problem is? Is is it God's design or is it how people misuse the design? So the problem is probably one of these two ditches, authoritarianism or egalitarianism or feminism. So let's consider an an analogy here. What do you make of a a young teenage girl who testifies that she needs to recover from overbearing parents? Well, uh it's certainly possible that her parents may be sinfully doineering. That's possible.
20:54 It's also possible that the problem is primarily not her parents, but her own rebellious attitude that's chafing against the good, God-given authority of her wise and loving parents. Right? So on the one hand, the reason that some women feel like they need to recover from the male leadership in their home and church is that the males in their life have sinfully misused their authority. Physical abuse, for example, is evil and we should not dismiss it or tolerate it.
21:27 On the other hand, the reason that some women may feel like they need to recover from male leadership in their home and church is not that their male leaders are sinfully misusing their authority. It could be that women are rebelliously chafing against the God-given authority of godly husbands and pastors. Or it could be that their husbands and pastors are complimentarian in name only. That is, the men claim to affirm the concept, but they don't actively practice it. They're wimpy and they're passive. So, when men characteristically fail and disappoint the women they're supposed to be leading, they're supposed to be leading, what happens to the women? Well, the women may become embittered towards what
22:12 they think is God's design for men and women. So, my second exhortation is beware of those ditches on either side of biblical patriarchy. Exhortation three, discern which ditch you are more prone to fall into. So Joe Riggnney asks a helpful diagnostic question. Which slope is most slippery for you? In other words, are you more more likely to sin by falling into the ditch of authoritarianism or the ditch of egalitarianism? Which way are you more inclined to sin? And given what you know of your heart, your background, your context, which are you more prone to?
22:56 And I don't want to assume that the answer is the same for each one of you. Joe Riggnney suggests a diagnostic test. Here it is. Uh for ladies, let's imagine you have an opportunity to teach the Bible to other ladies, whether in a small group or one-on-one context. That's a scenario. For men, you have the opportunity to teach or preach. Okay? So, uh uh some kind of lesson. And here's the diagnostic question. Which truth are you more eager to say out loud and clearly? And which truth are you more reluctant to speak clearly? And you're more inclined to have layers upon layers of qualification. Let's say these are your two options. You can teach on one of these two passages. Husbands,
23:37 love your wives and do not be harsh with them. Would you rather teach on that or wives, submit to your husbands as is fitting in the Lord? Which would you prefer to teach on and why? Does this ask yourself that question? It's help you just diagnose which error you may be more prone to fall into. If you were to teach on those passages, would you teach one of them more forthrightly? You know, right down the middle, clear, strong, and would you feel obligated to teach the other one um differently, like with a whole bunch of nuances, walking on eggshells, treading carefully? So, in our conservative evangelical circles, my guess is that most
24:23 teachers would prefer to teach or preach on this first text, husbands, love your wives and don't be harsh with them. And they would hammer that truth home that with a a clear, forthright, convictional message that husbands must sacrifice for their wives like Christ does the church. And amen to that message. But I suspect that most teachers in our circles would be more hesitant to teach on wives, submit to your husbands as is fitting in the Lord. And if they did teach on that passage, they'd probably qualify it so much that they would focus more on what it doesn't mean than on what it does mean. They'd be more comfortable teaching about what God commands husbands to do than what God
25:10 commands wives to do. Why? Why is that? That's I said a lot to get to this question. It's a very important question. Why in our culture or even our Christian culture are people more inclined to hammer the guys and tread carefully with the ladies? Why is that? The reason, I think, is that feminism is the air culturally we're breathing. It permeates our culture. We live in an egalitarian age. In our culture, it's much easier to preach on Christlike headship. It's much more countercultural to preach on Sarahike submission. So, let me test this theory with you. Think over all the sermons that you've heard in your life on Mother's Day and Father's Day. You've probably heard a bunch of those sermons.
26:00 You tell me on Father's Day, is the preacher more likely to call out sins that men are prone to commit, tell him to man up, or is he more likely to praise and affirm godly men? And then on Mother's Day, is the preacher more likely to call out sins that women are prone to commit? Or is the preacher more likely to praise and affirm godly women? Or does the preacher even do that? Um, is the preacher more likely to empathize with all of the women who are not mothers? You the way that some pastors talk about mothers on Mother's Day? It I envision it's like a mom hosting a birthday party for her child and he's got all these other kids there and she's like, "Okay, all you other kids, I'm so
26:44 sorry it's not your birthday. This must be so hard for you." And it's like, "It's a birthday party." Uh, that's what Mother's Day feels like for many, many people. Uh, I don't recall hearing a Mother's Day sermon that called out feminine sins, but I can recall many Father's Day sermons that called out masculine sins. Man up. Why is that? Preachers and our culture are more inclined to challenge men and to coddle women. They they treat guys like a thermos banging around in the back of your pickup truck. And they treat women like this delicate porcelain. Like, just be really careful. And in a sense, that's good. We don't want to treat men and women identically. They're
27:25 different. We should have different approaches. My point is that if we can't address women with the directness and clarity that the Bible does, then something is off. I'm simply pointing out we have to take into account observations like this as we evaluate pressures in our cultural context. So that's exhortation three. Discern which ditch you're more prone to fall into. Now, exhortation four. Don't be embarrassed about anything the Bible teaches. Love and celebrate how God has designed men and women. My mentor DA Carson told me a story once about how he was c he was counseling this couple as a husband and a wife and they were egalitarians. They were evangelical feminists. and he
28:15 showed them passage after passage in scripture that teaches the opposite. And they got to the point where the couple said to him, "Okay, you convinced us, we concede the Bible teaches complimentarianism, but we don't like it." And Dr. Carson replied to them, "Okay, you're halfway there. You're halfway there." What he meant by that was, "It's good to believe what the Bible says, but it's better to delight in it, to love it, to see it how God sees it, to have our hearts lined up with what is reality as God made it." So my my exhortation here is this. We should not be satisfied with dutifully going along with what God has revealed
29:05 to us in his word, even if it doesn't make sense to us. That's immature obedience. That's better than disobedience. But a mature obedience is ideal. A mature obedience understands the underlying reasons God gives for what he commands. So when our obedience is mature, we love and praise God for how he brilliantly designed everything, including how he designed men and women. Now, some people who claim to be complimentarians think that God's design for men and women is embarrassing.
29:48 They'd rather not talk about it. They definitely prefer not to emphasize it or celebrate it. They hold to it reluctantly because they think, well, that's what the Bible says, even though it doesn't really make sense. So, they concede, you know, God made these rules. These are the rules, but the rules seem kind of arbitrary. If they teach on God's design for men and women, they practically apologize for it. They claim to affirm it, but they don't love it. That is not how we should think about what God has revealed. We must not only believe what God reveals to be true, we should cherish it. It's not okay to say, "Well, the Bible teaches that, but I don't like it." It's a bad sign if we want to
30:31 ignore or apologize for what God has revealed in the Bible. If we have a problem understanding the nature and rationale of what God has revealed in his word, then the problem is not with God and his word. The problem is with us. We shouldn't reluctantly affirm God's design for men and women. Nor should we follow it while thinking it seems arbitrary or even a little bit illogical. We should love it. We should celebrate it. It's wise, fitting. It's good, beautiful, and true. It's how God designed men and women to flourish.
31:08 That's exhortation four. Don't be embarrassed about anything the Bible teaches. Love and celebrate how God has designed men and women. And finally, exhortation five. Don't misuse the theological triage model to justify disobeying God. I'm going to unpack this by answering four questions. What is the theological triage model? What are its benefits? What are its dangers? And how does God's design for men and women fit in that model? So question one, what is the theological triage model? The word triage refers to sorting something according to priority or urgency. So medical triage is assigning
31:57 degrees of urgency to a wound or an illness to decide in which order you're going to treat a patient. In a similar way, theological triage distinguishes the importance of truths the Bible teaches. And whenever I start talking this way, some people get nervous. They think, "Whoa, whoa, you're saying that some things in the Bible are more important than other things." What gives you the right to even think that way? That's a good question. Uh, so Al Mhler helped popularize this model and many other theologians have explained it. So I'm not I didn't make this up, but this makes sense to me. Start with 1 Corinthians 15:3 where Paul writes, "I delivered to you as of first importance
32:39 what I also received." That phrase first importance is important. If if some things are of first importance, then that means that there are other truths that are not first importance. Right? So you have two categories, first importance and not first importance. And then Jesus refers to weightier matters of the law suggesting that there's some truths are weightier than other truths which suggests some kind of a scale. So the the theological triage model that Al Mhler has popularized and others suggest three parts to it. Some suggest four or five. The point is that we recognize not everything is of first importance. So here's here's the model.
33:20 first level, second level, third level, or we could call them essential for the Christian faith, crucial for church health but not essential for the Christian faith. And then important but not essential for the Christian faith or crucial for church health. Or you could think of these as dogma, doctrine, and disputable matters or fundamental teachings, denominational distinctives and matters of conscience. So for first level issues, these are essential and most central to Christianity. You can't deny this and be a Christian in any meaningful sense. For example, truths like God is one and three. There's one God and three persons, the Trinity. Or Jesus is truly God and truly man. You
34:05 can't deny that and be a Christian. or Jesus rose bodily from the dead after he sacrificially died for sinners or were justified by grace alone through faith alone and Christ alone and Jesus is coming back that's level one truths second level issues are crucial for church health and they create boundaries between Christians like different churches different denominations we regularly pray for other churches in this area uh that are real churches filled with real Christians But they may be a little different than we are in some ways. We may not join those churches, but we recognize they are real churches filled with real Christians. And these issues have a bearing on what sort of
34:49 church you join. For example, you don't have to hold a particular view on baptizing infants or only believers to be a Christian. But it's challenging for a church to have healthy unity when its leaders disagree on those matters. And then third level issues are disputable matters or matters of conscience. They're not unimportant. This is one thing if I could write a second edition to my book conscience with JD Crowley, I'd clarify this bit that don't I'm I'm jumping ahead, but uh that this third level is not unimportant. It's just relatively not as important. So this is these are the kind of issues where the fellow members of this church could disagree and still maintain close fellowship and
35:36 celebrate the Lord's supper together as members. So it could be a theological issue like how you interpret passages and put them together like are angels made in the image of God. Some of you might think that one through and think, "Yeah, I think they are." And others might say, "No, only humans are made in the image of God." And I think we could disagree on that and still celebrate the Lord's supper together as fellow members. Or it could be a practical question like, "How should we think about video games?" There is a right answer to that question. If you want to know, ask me afterwards. But my point is, these aren't uh things that are just up for grabs. We should care about them
36:09 and think rightly about them, but we can disagree on them and still be fellow members. Okay? So, uh, I'm talking about weighing Bible teachings. It's actually more complicated than I just said, than just weighing teachings to distinguish their relative importance. There are other factors to consider than the weightiness of the doctrine itself. Joe Riggnney wrote an article titled How to Weigh Doctrines for Christian Unity.
36:30 It's online and it's very good. And uh he explains that we would need to take into account different stances toward a doctrine and why and how. One theologian helpfully suggests some tests for stratifying doctrine. And I paraphrase it like this. Uh when we're trying to figure out if something is a first level issue, we'd ask, well, is that what the Bible most clearly and explicitly teaches? And is it central to the gospel? And is it vital for partnering together as Christians? And if it's really important for partnering as churches, but not just as Christians, it would be more of a second level issue. Okay, that was question one. What is it? Now I'd like to explain some benefits and dangers. So
37:17 question two, what are benefits of this model? And I think this model has at least three benefits. Benefit one, it helps us not treat every theological issue as essential to the gospel. It helps us keep true teachings in perspective. Not everything is a gospel issue. Not everything is of first importance. Benefit two, it helps us recognize that other Christians who disagree with us on issues that are not essential to Christianity are fellow brothers and sisters in Christ.
37:53 Yesterday I was on a panel with four other theologians and one of them Fred Sanders is a Wesian. That's a a form of Armenianism and I did just taught on predestination and John Piper just taught on providence and then there's this this guy and uh we talked about that. I didn't walk away thinking he's not a Christian, he's just wrong. We said that with a smile. Yeah, we disagree on that. So here's an example. John Wesley held an Armenian view of predestination. And if you if you study his life, you know that he and George Whitfield very strongly disagreed on these matters. I want to have the same spirit about Wesley that George Whitfield and Charles Spurgeon did.
38:34 Charles Spurgeon compared his ministry, he's a Calvinist, next to George Whit, excuse me, next to John Wesley's as a farthing candle next to the sun. That was that was Spurgeon. And then Whitfield requested that Wesley preached the funeral sermon for him. And some Calvinists questioned whether Wesley was even saved, whether he was converted. Someone asked George Whitfield, "Do you think you'll expect to see Wesley in heaven?" And George Whitfield replied, "I fear not, for he will be so near the eternal throne, and we at such a distance, we shall hardly get a sight of him."
39:13 Benefit three, this model helps us discern whom we may faithfully partner with in Christian ministry to various degrees. I can partner with a non-Christian for all kinds of good causes in which I don't affirm that everyone involved is a Christian. For example, I can co-belligerently oppose abortion with just about anybody, but I can't partner in Christian ministry with a non-Christian. As soon as you call it a Christian cooperation, that narrows who you can partner with. I can celebrate the Lord's supper with a fellow church member who has a different conviction than I do about whether we should have a flat tax. There's a right answer on that. You can ask me afterwards. Um but so for a
40:00 helpful uh article on what I'm talking about here, I recommend a chapter by Wayne Grudum called Why, when, and for what should we draw new boundaries? It's free online in a in a PDF of a book called Beyond the Bounds. So those are three benefits. Now, let's talk about three dangers, three dangers of theological triage. I almost never hear people talk about the dangers of this model. Uh Christians tend to love this model because it's so easy to use for your own purposes. So beware that this model has at least three dangers. Danger one, we may misuse the model to trivialize anything that is not essential to Christianity. It's a grave error to reason like this. That issue is not a gospel issue.
40:47 It's not a level one issue. It's not essential to Christianity. So it doesn't matter. So let's stop arguing about it and let's stop dividing over this. Let's just unite on what's essential to Christianity and not worry about the rest. That's a really common way people use this theological triage model. And I'm responding here, no. Whatever God reveals to us is important. It all matters. Every word matters. And we dare not minimize anything that God has revealed. Danger two, we may misuse the model to rationalize disobeying God. To disbelieve God is to disobey God. It's just a fundamental way that we sin. We think we know better than God does and we rob glory from him. It's
41:34 it's an idolatrous arrogance that belittles God. So, can you just imagine standing before God on judgment day and and saying this to him? Uh, but Lord, I I didn't obey what you said here because that's a second level issue. A lot of Christians disagree on that. How's that going to hold up? Here's an example. 1 Timothy 2:12, what does God say? I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man, but rather to be in submission.
42:14 As I plan to show you in upcoming sermons, as to remain quiet, not be in submission. As I plan to show you in upcoming sermons, the recent movement called egalitarianism or evangelical feminism has done exeetical and theological back flips to change I do not permit to mean voila, I do permit. That's what they do. I do not permit. No, it actually means I do permit. Let me show you how. That's what they've done. And someone may reply, lower the temperature, Andy. You know, uh, God's design for men and women in the church is not essential to Christianity. It's level two. It's not level one. Let's just agree to disagree about it and not make a big deal about this. And my my point here is that if
42:59 that's how we're using the theological triage model, then we're doing it wrong. We're misusing the model. We dare not use any theological model to justify disobeying God. Just listen to the the grave purpose statement at the end of this sentence in first it's uh it's in Titus 2. Older women are to teach what is good and so train the young women to love their husbands and children to be self-controlled, pure, working at home, kind, and submissive to their own husbands. And here's the purpose clause.
43:32 that the word of God may not be reviled. That's not a minor thing. It means if you get this wrong, you're reviling the word of God. And then danger three, we may misuse the model to weigh all level two issues equally. So level two issues are crucial for church health. But just as your physical health appears on a spectrum from robustly healthy to deathly sick, sole level two issues appear on a spectrum from more important for church health to less important. I think that God's design for men and women is far more important for church health than say a church's position on the miraculous spiritual gifts, speaking in tongues and prophecy. So I'm I'm comparing men who are cessationists.
44:20 They believe those guests cease like like John MacArthur or Tom Shriner as opposed to men who think to continue like John Piper or Wayne Grudam or Da Carson. I'm not thinking of of what I call charismaniacs who teach a false prosperity gospel. So my view is that to be wrong on tongues and prophecy while you're healthy in other areas is kind of like having a mild cold. means you're not in perfect health, but it's not a serious threat to the health of the church. But to be wrong on God's design for men and women is like having a uh an acutely contagious viral disease like smallox that compromises the immune system. It's a gravely serious threat to church health. And I noticed something from
45:08 about 2014 to 2000 2021. Some church leaders in our circles swapped some of what they used to place in levels two and three. For example, a pastor may claim to personally personally he believes that only men should be pastors and that God is meticulously sovereign, but he would swap that to a level three issue and take what should be in level three and put that at level two if not a level one. And he would say that we must acknowledge a particular kind of systemic racism and oppose that structural sin in a very specific particular way or else we're not being faithful Christians. And I believe when you when you get these out of whack, when you get them out of line, when you
45:46 weigh these things wrongly, it's bad for the church's health. On your handout, I have a diagram here by David Adterbury, which helpfully adapts an insight from Edward Lei. He's a Westminster theologian from the 1600s. and his diagram helpfully distinguishes two kinds of second order matters. So this top top line is what I was just explaining to you. So you have first order disagreement cooperation is non-existent. You have second order disagreement where you have cooperation with limitations and then third order disagreement cooperation with forbearance. Now here's the insight from uh this theologian Lei. He he doesn't have something that corresponds to the level three and he does have something
46:28 that corresponds to level one. He calls them errors that are a direct assault to the foundation. Here's what I find is so helpful for the level two. He distinguishes, he calls it circa and Citra between errors that dig out and destabilize the foundation versus errors that divide us and cause no harm to the foundation. So let me give you some examples I'm talking about. For this one, errors that dig out and destabilize it. I think of an example like affirming the inherency of scripture. There are some British evangelicals who I have no doubt are genuine Christians who don't affirm the inherency of scripture. They don't think that the Bible is fully truthful and everything it affirms. I
47:06 think that's wrong. Dangerously wrong. So important that uh we've we have it in our member affirmation of faith. You get that wrong, you have dominoes where you get other stuff wrong. But it's possible to be a Christian and get that wrong. But my point is that's not just getting any doctrine wrong. You get that wrong, you're digging out and destabilizing the foundation. And that leads to question four. Where does God's design for men and women fit in this model? This this model here, where would that go? Would it would it be uh something that digs out and destabilizes or just something that divides us and it's not that big a deal? So, to answer this question, I'm going to briefly
47:45 contrast my view with Tim Keller's view. Tim Keller was a well-known pastor in New York City who died in 2023. And I just want to say I've learned a lot from Tim Keller. I don't think everything he says is bad. In fact, uh, he was very kind to me for over the 17 years that we interacted. He endorsed a book I wrote, How to Understand and Apply the New Testament in 2016, and I've learned a lot from him. But Tim and I started veering apart around 2016 regarding whether a particular kind of winsomeness is a virtue or a vice. And shortly before he died, he wrote a little book titled The Decline and Renewal of the American Church. It's free online as a PDF. And he presents what he calls four
48:28 zones for evangelicalism. Zone one he calls fundamentalism. Here's how he describes it. This this zone this is anti- any talk of social justice. Militant, super complimentarian, not just complimentarian, but super complimentarian, rigid gender roles. Trump, I don't know why that got in there. Uh, antivax. This group rejects any strong emphasis on social justice as liberal or Marxist and denies the reality of structural injustice. Though, you can tell by how he describes that. You think that's his favorite view? Okay. And then second is conservative evangelicalism which he divides into two parts. He calls it zone 2 A and zone 2B. 2A he says is complimentarian but unlike that super
49:19 one that's really rigid. This one is more flexible and less rigid about gender roles. Strict doctrinally you know biblical inherency penal substitution atonement. We'll talk of social justice but but in a guarded way muted way and it is addressed only through individual and private charity. much more stress on traditional family and sexuality than on race and justice. They basically see the woke left as a far bigger threat. That's 2 A. 2 B, he says, is also complimentarian. I would I would add barely and conservative by believing in systemic racism and structural injustice. More willing to address injustice with structural measures than just private charity. And here's the key, more willing to work
50:00 with egalitarians without ranker. Then zone three he calls evangel excuse me egalitarian evangelicalism which he also divides into two versions. So 3A is mainstream evangelicals. He says they're not nearly as doctrally oriented. Shies away from using the terminarcy. Less willing to say there's an exact biblical position on everything. Puts far more emphasis on social justice than traditional family and sexuality. mainly egalitarian in the church but grounding views in the Bible rather than saying Paul was wrong or we must get beyond him often willing to affirm husband's leadership in the family and non-inchangeable gender roles in the family cooperative with complimentarians he think that's great
50:43 and more open to their views not at all open and affirming to gay homosexual marriage and ordination that's 3A and then this one right here if you notice it's getting worse now 3B more consistently and insistently egalit arian not willing to make common cause with complimentarians because of a conviction their view is inherently misogynist and unjust unwilling to say the Bible's teaching on women is now outdated excuse me it is willing to say that the Bible's teaching is outdated still affirming traditional church pro prohibition of homosexual acts but much more willing to affirm and work with celibate gay Christians and then finally is zone four which he calls ex or post evangelicalism
51:24 or progressive Christian I would question the word Christian being a noun for this view at all. He describes this view as open and affirming to all LGBT egalitarian obviously. Unlike the older mainline, they do not just dismiss or ignore evangelicalism and fundamentalism, but think that it is destroying the country that even zone 3 forms are abusive and bad for people. Okay, so you got your bearings. That's how he he lays out the spectrum. And here's his solution for what he thinks is the way forward.
51:55 Here's a way forward. Generally speaking, the way forward is to divide, separate from zones one and four. Those are bad in different ways. and to bring both individuals and leaders and some older institutions most likely from the right half of zone 2 and the left half of zone 3 into a new zone 5 and then do strategic initiatives and launch the mission projects and start new institutions. So he's saying the sweet spot on that spectrum is to combine the squishiest complimentarians with some egalitarians. That's what we want to do. That's the way forward.
52:38 I guess by my adjective squishy, you you think you know what I believe. You were correct. Uh Keller's strategy was basically to treat God's design for men and women as a third level level issue. Not that big a deal. He's not even saying it's second level, but like a common cold. I'm arguing that this is more important than that. It's it's it's not not even this that God's designed for men and women. you get that wrong, you're digging out and destabilizing the foundation. But let me clarify what I mean by that. Because when you ask where does where does this fit in theological triage, I can think of several ways to answer it. Uh for example, if a man who were a member of our church were to
53:25 affirm that God permits a man to marry a man or a woman to marry a woman, then our elders would recommend to the church that we no longer affirm that that man is a Christian because such a belief is incomp incompatible with Christianity and it's contrary to our member affirmation of faith. So that would be a level one issue. Or here's another example. What if two members of our church disagree on the wisdom of whether a mother should work for pay while her children are young? So both agree that a mother of young children should prioritize being at home with the children, but one member thinks that it's wrong to work for pay at all. and the other things that well she could do that responsibly
54:13 maybe part-time but it could work out while still prioritizing being a faithful wife and mom. Is that disagreement a level one issue? Not even close. It's not even level two. That's a matter on which Christians should be able to disagree and still have close fellowship. But what I'm trying to put my finger on right here is what do we do if a professing Christian holds an evangelical feminist view? thinks that a woman may be a pastor, for example. Does that automatically mean that person's not a Christian? No. It's not level one in that sense. It's possible to hold a wrong view about God's design for men and women in the home, church, and society and still be a Christian. So, I
54:55 think it's a level two issue. But what kind? I don't think it's it's the kind that merely divides us, but it's not that big a deal. I think it digs out and destabilizes the foundation. Or to change the analogy to health, it's not like having a common cold. It's like having a deathly serious contagious disease that compromises the immune system and can spread through the church like gang green. That's what I think being wrong on God's design for men and women does to a church. Over a year ago, I was teaching on this to a room full of pastors in another state. And right before the the talk began, the the the pastor who was hosting the conference had his assistant come up and say, "Hey, you see that that
55:39 lady over there? She's lead pastor of an Assemblies of God church in the area." He's like, "Oh, I didn't know I haven't met her before. She's not come before." And I looked at him and said, "You do know I'm talking about 1 Timothy 2:12 in my talk." He's like, "Oh, yeah, that's great." So, okay. So, I I walked over to her on my way to the front and met her. I think she's in her 30s. And this I was just kind to her and went up to the front to get ready to speak. And right before I got up to speak, the pastor, the hosting said, "I like all the lead pastors to stand up and introduce yourselves." Okay. So now you got a room full of lead pastors standing. They go one by one and the last one standing is
56:16 this lady. So now it's everybody knows there's a lady pastor here. And now I get up to speak. So I was forced with a decision. Do I be nice and tone this down or skip this? What do I do? What would you do? Uh, what do you think I did? Well, I didn't change a word that I planned to say. I wasn't a jerk about it, but I think what I did by saying what I had planned to say was good for everyone in the room. It was good for all the people who felt anxious that I was saying what I was saying in her presence because we shouldn't feel anxious and embarrassed about what's true. And it was good for her because she should feel some shame for what she's doing. And hopefully it would lead
57:00 to repentance. It's good to speak the truth in love. Now, what we believe about God's design for men and women is foundational to our Christian lives. And the pastors of Christ the King Church believe it's crucial not only that our pastors be aligned on these matters, but that our members be aligned as well. Because what we believe about God's design for men and women directly affects how we preach and teach and pray and sing and counsel everything. It's how we disciple. It's how we make disciples. We So making disciples is teaching people to obey everything that Jesus commanded. That includes obeying what God says about his design for men and women. Okay. So, thus far in these first
57:49 two sermons on God's design for men and women, I've laid out a spectrum, distinguished two types of complimentarianism and given five exhortations. And in the next two sermons, God willing, I'll give you six reasons for biblical patriarchy. That's what's coming. For now, let's close by praying that God would help us heed these exhortations. Father, would you please help each of us to study your good design for men and women and to develop personal convictions about the truth? Would you please help us beware of the ditches on either side of biblical patriarchy? Would you please help us discern which ditch we're more prone to fall into?
58:34 Would you please help us not be embarrassed about anything you revealed in the Bible? And would you please help us not misuse the theological triage model to justify disobeying you? We ask all this in the name of Christ the King. Amen.
No transcript available.
