Transcript
0:09 Father, as we consider your words to us in 1 Timothy 5, would you please enlighten our minds and soften our hearts and enable our wills to honor you? We ask in the name of Jesus. Amen. Amen. >> Please open your Bible to First Timothy 5. 1 Timothy 5 verses 17 and 18 is our text today. It says, "Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in
0:58 preaching and teaching. For the scripture says, "You shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain, and the laborer deserves his wages." The main idea of this passage is that a church should pay its elders. So, I'd like to preach to you on 1 Timothy 5:17 and 18 on this subject. Pay your elders. And you might hear that and go, uh, this is awkward. So, let's talk about that. Um, you might think it's awkward for you and maybe even awkward for me to talk about this, to preach on this. So, is it awkward for you to hear one of your elders preach a sermon about paying your elders?
1:43 It shouldn't be awkward. It shouldn't be any different than a typical sermon. So, I suppose that could be awkward for you if you want to disobey the Bible. Uh, and is it awkward for me, one of your pastors, to preach to you about paying your pastors? I don't think it's awkward. I'm simply doing what I do every week. Like, I I teach and explain and exhort what the Bible says. My job is to preach the Bible, and that includes this passage.
2:09 So now you might be thinking,"Well, wouldn't it be better if a man who isn't an elder of this church preached on this passage about paying your elders? Wouldn't that be better?" Well, I don't I don't think so. Um, that'd be like saying, "Wouldn't it be better if parents didn't teach their children about obeying their parents, but someone else taught them that?" I is it helpful when someone else teaches? Does that reinforce and supplement?
2:41 Absolutely. That's really valuable. But we don't need it to be that way. The normal natural pattern is for parents to teach their own children. And in a similar way, it should be normal and natural for our church's pastors to teach the church whatever the Bible says. So now you might be thinking, well, how's our church doing that paying our elders? And for a small self-supporting one-year old church, I think God has enabled us to start really well. I think we're on a good trajectory as we try to be faithful stewards of limited resources. So, on behalf of our pastors, thank you for investing in Christ the King Church. Thank you for cheerfully supporting your pastors in our church.
3:26 And you might be wondering, one more thought here. So why devote a sermon to this topic to paying our elders? Real simple. Three reasons. One, it's the next text. I'm preaching through First Timothy. I'm not skipping a single sentence. Second reason, it's good for us to hear this passage so that we can obey it in a mature way. So it it's good to do what God says. That's good. It's better to do what God says as you understand why. And it's best to do what God says as you understand why and as you love his good and brilliant design.
4:09 That's a mature obedience that honors God. So that that's good for us. And then a third reason to preach on this passage is it's good for the long-term health of our church to establish a culture in which the members cheerfully generously pay our pastors. God willing, Christ the King Church will exist for much longer than any of our pastors will be alive. So I'm teaching on this in a way I hope will be true of our church for decades, not just for while I'm alive. With God's help, we want our church to cheerfully obey whatever God says. And that includes this command for a church to pay their pastors. So now, let's approach this passage. I'm going to do so by asking four questions. First
4:52 question is, does verse 17 distinguish between two kinds of elders, ruling elders and teaching elders. Second question, what's the big idea here? What's the main command to a local church in the passage? Third question, why why should a church pay its elders, particularly the ones who labor in preaching and teaching? And then finally, should a church require that some elders not be paid? That's how we'll approach the passage. Let's start with that first question. Does first Timothy 5:17 distinguish between two kinds of elders, ruling elders and teaching elders? So, here's verse 17.
5:28 Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching. So most English translations say something like what the ESV says there, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching. The NIV seems to support the view that there are two kinds of elders. You got ruling elders and teaching elders. Here's what it says. The elders who direct the affairs of the church well are worthy of double honor, especially those whose work is preaching and teaching. That translation implies that there are some elders whose work is not preaching and teaching. So I'm going to review here some of what I taught
6:15 when I preached on 1 Timothy 3:1-7 by asking three clarifying questions. First, who argues that verse 17 distinguishes between two kinds of elders, ruling elders and teaching elders? And the answer is those with a Presbyterian polity. So, church polity refers to church government. Protestants hold four major views on how to govern the church. And what distinguishes those four views is how they answer the question, who holds final authority?
6:47 Does the bishop hold final authority? That's episcopal polity. Does the presbyterary hold final authority? That's so a presbyterary is a group of elders who represent the local congregations in a district. That is Presbyterian polity. Do the elders hold final authority? That's elder rule polity. Or does the congregation hold final authority? That's congregational polity. Under any of those four models of church government, a church can be robustly healthy and a church can be robustly, not robustly, it can be very sick.
7:33 Any four. So that tells you what's decisive for a church's health is not its polity. You can't bulletproof a church from problems if the pastors aren't qualified men. In my view, what is decisive for a church's health is whether qualified men are leading the church. And that can happen under any of these four polies. Now, while godly mature Christians disagree on which of these four polities is most biblical, my view is that the most biblical one is a form of congregationalism. That's the fourth one there. That is elder and congregation governed. The polity in the
8:24 bylaws of Christ the King Church is about as close to elder rule polity as you can get without being elder rule. Okay. So, uh, our model of church government is congregationally governed, but it's different than some other churches that are congregationally governed that think of themselves as like a a modern democracy, a democratic republic of some sort. So, they think of it as like uh you got leaders who represent the people. The people make demands on the leaders with a threat that they'll vote them out of office or maybe they'll hold a protest. Uh so our model is more like a combination of a monarchy, a senate, and a democratic republic. So it's a monarchy because we
9:07 have a king, Christ. It's actually in our church name. And it's a Senate because our pastors lead. And it's a democratic republic because members vote on certain important matters with the Bible as our constitution. So for Christ the King Church, members vote on only three matters. Remember what they are? You vote on affirming and removing members. We just did that together. We affirm members and we vote on affirming and removing pastors and deacons.
9:36 And then third, we update we vote on updating our foundational documents, bylaws, elder affirmation of faith, member affirmation of faith, and the covenant. So that the pastors and the members are responsible to make all our decisions under the authority of God's word. Our final authority is scripture. Scripture is our ultimate authority. Those with a Presbyterian polity argue that 1 Timothy 5:17 distinguishes between two kinds of elders, ruling elders and teaching elders. So here how here's how they would define those terms. Ruling elders focus on leading the church. These men are typically unordained laymen who function like managers, not like pastor teachers.
10:20 teaching elders or pastor teachers in the Presbyterian polity also help lead the church but they focus on preaching and teaching. So these ordained men typically have advanced degrees in the Bible and theology and the church pays them to concentrate on preaching and teaching. Some of you are members of our church and you came from a Presbyterian background. That's probably what you were familiar with. So uh that's that's a a very common model. uh it's part of Presbyterian church polity. That is our answer to the first question. Who argues that verse 17 distinguishes between two kinds of elders? Ruling elders and teaching elders.
10:59 So now I'd like to ask another clarifying question. Is a pastor different from an elder or overseer? So I think the answer is no. Pastor, elder and overseer refer to the same office. So our church does not distinguish between an overseer and a pastor and an elder. The reason is that the Bible uses those three titles to emphasize different aspects of one office. Overseer, pastor, elder, same office. Why? Four reasons. First, the New Testament uses pastor, elder, and overseer interchangeably. My friend Colin Smothers created this helpful vin diagram. So three passages are most
11:49 significant in the overlap here. Uh one is acts 20 verses 17 and 28 where it refers to elders and the flock and overseers who care or shepherd for the church. Another is Titus 1 5 and and 7 refers to elders and overseer. Same guy. And then another passage is first Peter. No, not that one. This one. 1 Peter 5 1:5, which refers to elders, fellow elder, shephering, and exercising oversight, which is related to the word for bishop or overseer. So, uh that's reason one, the New Testament uses pastor, elder, and overseer interchangeably. Reason two, the New Testament gives basically the same qualifications for overseers and elders
12:37 in 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1. the same role, the same function. The guy's called an overseer and an elder. And those lists are nearly identical. Reason three, pastors, elders, and overseers have the same function. So pastors, elders, overseers, they they do the same thing. They have the same function. These these aren't three terms that function like um like father and mother. The same person can't be both father and mother. It's impossible. You can try to do some of the same things, but one person can't be both. And the words pastors, elders, overseers are not like father and mother because they occupy the same office. It'd be like saying um husband and father, same guy.
13:27 He's doing doing it all. So, you might say, well, what about first Timothy 5:17? Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching. It sounds like you've got some who are ruling and some who are teaching. So here's my response to that that Presbyterian view. U all elders rule and a subset of those elders also labor in preaching and teaching. So all elders or pastors rule in the sense that they lead or they direct the affairs of the church. They provide effective leadership. Rule. The word rule doesn't mean doineer. It's a good word. That refers to using god-given authority in a fitting way. All elders should rule in
14:16 that sense. And all elders also teach. You can't be an elder who can't teach. That's a qualification in 1 Timothy 3. He has to be able to teach. That's why it's not fitting for a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Teaching and exercising authority are the two main activities that are fitting for a pastor. That's what all pastors do. So, I don't think it's right to distinguish pastors as if some are are non-eing. All of them teach. They need to be able to teach. But pastors don't spend the same amount of time on preaching and teaching. Pastors don't have the same gifting for preaching and teaching.
15:03 Pastors don't have the same training for preaching and teaching. And pastors don't put forth the same effort for preaching and teaching. So I just highlighted four factors that distinguish a subset of pastors who labor in preaching and teaching. So time. Some pastors spend more time to work hard at preaching and teaching. And then gifting. Some pastors are just more gifted at it. And training. Some pastors have more training at preaching and teaching. And then effort. Some pastors work harder at it. Every pastor is not a carbon copy of the other pastor. Uh each one is a member of a team. Each pastor contributes his own unique blend of gifts.
15:45 But that doesn't mean that we should divide pastors into two distinct categories. is those who teach and those who rule. All elders or pastors teach and rule to various degrees. And then reason four of why is uh a pastor is not different from an elder or overseer is that the New Testament never lists pastors, elders or overseers as separate offices. There's no evidence in scripture, for example, that you could be a pastor but not an elder or overseer.
16:16 Pastor, elder, overseer refers to the same office. That's why our church does not distinguish between pastors and elders. So Nathan Coloultock and I spend more time vocationally at pastoring than do Tom and Dustin. In some churches, they would call Nathan and me pastors, and they would call Tom and Dustin elders. We don't do that. We refer to all of us as pastors and elders and overseers. All of us are doing that. The Bible doesn't have a category for a man being a pastor but not an elder or an elder but not a pastor. All right. So, is a pastor different from an elder or overseer? Answer is no. No. No. No. Uh elder, pastor, overseer is the same office. Now, clarifying question three.
17:04 Why are there three terms for the same office? The answer is pastor, elder and overseer emphasize different aspects of the same office. So, what do they emphasize? Pastor emphasizes shephering. Elder emphasizes character and overseer emphasizes oversight, responsibility to oversee, watch over, lead, supervise, administer. The overseer must care for God's church. So our big question here is, does 1 Timothy 5:17 distinguish between two kinds of elders, ruling and teaching?
17:38 Answer, no. All elders rule and all elders teach. Now, question two. What's the main command to a local church in our passage? So, I'm going to read the passage again, and as I read it, see if you can identify the main command. Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching. For the scripture says, you shall not muzzle the ox when it tries out the grain, and the laborer deserves his wages.
18:09 So, what's the main command? You can see it in the very first line. Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor. In other words, the church must give double honor to their elders who rule well, particularly the ones who labor at preaching and teaching. So, this raises three clarifying questions which I have on the screen here. First, is that command, let the elders be considered worthy, a misleading translation? I think so. uh this is not a command to allow elders to be considered worthy of double honor. It's a command to consider certain elders as worthy of double honor. And we've already seen this as we've worked through 1 Timothy, this this construction in in Greek that's
18:53 called a third person imperative. We don't have this in English, so it's hard to carry over into Greek. We saw it, for example, in 1 Timothy 2 11, let a woman learn. You read that and it sounds like you need to allow women to learn, but that's not what it's saying. It's saying a woman must learn or we saw it in 1 Timothy 4:12. Let no one despise you for your youth. That's not it's not like allow no one to do it. No, it's saying Timothy, I'm talking to you and he's commanding them over here. No one must despise you for your youth. It's it's a weird construction that we just don't have in English. So here uh the translation sense would be something like this. The elders who rule well must
19:33 be considered worthy of double honor. So, let me read to you some other translations of of verse 17. Here's the NASBY. The elders who lead well are to be considered worthy of double honor. That gets it. The NET Bible. Elders who provide effective leadership must be counted worthy of double honor. That's good. And here's one more. NLT. Elders who do their work well should be respected and paid well. Those three translations get it. It's not about allowing something to happen. So I think the translation let is misleading because it sounds like it's commanding you to allow it. Second clarifying question here. What does double honor refer to? I say it refers to respect and
20:13 payment that is higher and more generous. So at minimum to honor an elder means to respect him. Listen to 1 Thessalonians 5:12 and 13. We ask you brothers to respect those who labor among you and are over you in the Lord and admonish you and to esteem them very highly in love because of their work. So there's no debate about that. Honoring an elder requires respecting him. But in this literary context, to honor an elder means more than that. It does mean to respect, but it also means to pay him.
20:50 When we considered the command to honor widows last week, 1 Timothy 5:3-16, I argued that to honor a widow means to give her respect and to financially support her. To honor someone means to give that person what he or she is due. So to honor a widow means you respect her and you financially support her. And the literary context of 1 Timothy 5 confirms that that honor does mean doesn't mean just respecting but also includes supporting. In 1 Timothy 5:4, make some return to the parents. Verse 8, provide for his relatives. Verse 16, if any believing woman has relatives who are widows, let her care for them. Let the church not be burdened so that it may care for those who are truly widows.
21:32 That's more than respect. That's financial support. In the very next paragraph is our passage, verses 17 and 18. The church must give certain elders double honor. So all the elders or pastors deserve honor, which includes both respect and payment. I'll come back to that. Those who rule well are worthy of double honor. So the question here is what does double honor refer to? It's I think it refers to respect and payment that is higher >> and more generous. Paul doesn't give us a mathematical formula for how to calculate what to pay a pastor who deserves double honor. It requires wisdom to apply this principle in a way that is fitting. Clarifying question three. What does it mean to labor in
22:17 preaching and teaching? It means to work hard at it. That's how the NASBY, CSB, and NLT translate it. Work hard at preaching and teaching. To preach and teach well is hard work. And that's time that a man could have spent making money doing something else. So, I'm going to give you a little peak behind the curtain right now about what goes on to prepare a sermon. And a few times in my life, someone's made a comment to me, "Must be nice being a pastor. Just work work Sunday morning.
22:50 That's all you do." And uh I just bite my tongue usually. And um some to obey this command, what's involved in working hard at preaching and teaching? Sometimes someone will ask me, "So, how long does it take you to prepare a sermon?" And my answer is changing every year. Uh currently my answer is about 45 years. Yeah, you got it. So, I'm 45 years old. It's a cheeky answer, but my point is that your entire life goes into a sermon. U all your experiences, your formal training, informal training, I'm constantly reading and writing and teaching and conversing and listening to podcasts and and studying subjects that aren't always directly related to the next sermon. U I'm always preparing. So, I've
23:35 devoted my whole life to understanding and applying God's words. All of that is training for preparing a sermon. So after you take all that into account, then how much time does it take me to prepare a sermon? Answer is it depends on the passage. My guess is that on average I spend about 30 hours for one sermon. And I'm guessing because I don't track my hours. And you might be thinking, 30 hours? What are you doing?
24:00 What is taking so long? Well, it takes me a long time because I think there's a lot to do and I don't take this sacred task lightly. So, I'm going to just kind of show you briefly the process I go through to prepare a sermon. My routine for preparing a sermon has 10 steps. Did you Does it surprise you that I would have a list for this? Um, and this is what it looks like if I'm preaching a passage on a particular scripture passage. If I'm doing a topical sermon, it it takes way longer because you have to look at more passages and correlate them. So, step one is pray.
24:37 I pray that God would illuminate my mind to understand what he intended to communicate in the passage. I need God's help to do this and I keep asking for help throughout the whole process right up to the moment I start preaching. Step two, repeatedly read the passage in its literary context. So I read the sermon. I I read the passage over and over and over in English and I also read it in the original language, Hebrew, Aramaic or Greek. Then step three, I trace the argument as a phrase diagram. And I do that in a program called Bible Arc. So I sometimes you see this while I'm preaching. I'll put up on the screen the passage and there'll be phrases that are indented. That's my phrase diagram
25:17 exerted. You're not seeing the whole thing. Um so an argument diagram, this is a bigger category, is a way to graphically display the text logical flow of thought. And you do this by you divide up the text into propositions and phrases. and then you show how they relate to each other. My favorite kind of argument diagram is a phrase diagram where you're indenting clauses and phrases above or below what they modify and you can add symbols and arrows and labels to explain how the propositions and phrases logically relate. It's my favorite method for tracing the argument because I think it's simple, it's clear, it's flexible.
25:52 I love it. And when I do this, I I do it in both the original language and in the ESV. Step four is draft a sermon outline based on my phrase diagram. So I don't start writing the sermon outline until I've done those first three steps. So for step four, uh I'm coming to the text with one of two two questions predominant. Either I could be asking what can I say about this text or I could ask what does this text say? The difference between those two questions is monumental because if I'm asking the first question, what can I say about the text? That affects everything about how I prepare, what resources I I reach for to help me prepare. But if my main question is, what does this text say? That also
26:38 affects everything about what resources I'm looking for to help me, how I'm going about the process. That first question, what can I say about this? Is like the very last thing I think about. it it's important but it's way down the list. I've got nothing to say until I know what the text says. So my main question is what does this text say? That's that's what I'm asking as I come to it. And it's not even uh what does this text mean for me? I I I want to apply it but I don't want to get there first. I want to first understand the text so that I can rightly apply it.
27:11 This is really freeing for me because as you know by now I'm not naturally funny, creative, entertaining, but I can study a passage and explore it and discover what's there and show you what's there. I can do that and it's freeing to me because I don't I don't have this this weight of every week I've got to entertain you. All I have to do is study, explore, discover, and show you. I love that. So that's why when I'm looking at the text, I'm thinking, what's the main idea? How does Paul or whoever say it there? Is it one main command with two reasons and a purpose?
27:49 Is it just five commands? Is it like what's the structure? And then I want to show you that and that shapes the sermon as well. So I work hard to discover a passage's main idea and discover how the rest of the passage supports that main idea. Step five, I compare English translations. There's so many good ones. Our church typically uses the ESV, but there are many others. And I like to benefit from a spectrum of translations. So, some are more formbbased.
28:17 So, if you know another language, there's a way to translate like from Spanish to English that is so rigidly form-based, no one talks that way and it sounds funny. Um, well, it's not quite that bad, but some English translations are more form- based where they're they're just tighter to the the word order of the Greek text, like the the NASBY. Helpful. I use the NASBY and the LSB and the ESB. Others are more meaningbased, trying to get the idea and not following the form as much. So, the the NLT is an example of that. And then some are in between like the the NIV and the CSB and the NET Bible. So, I I carefully look at all of those, a bunch of them, and I'm tracking down all I'm
28:55 looking at all the translators notes, looking at cross references. That's incredibly fruitful. Step six is when I draft the sermon manuscript after doing all that. So, by this point, the sermon's coming together. I've drafted a preaching outline. I think I know the main idea of the passage, how it unfolds. I still may have unanswered questions at this point, so I've written them down like, you know, what what does that word mean? Um, I'm not sure how this passage relates to another passage.
29:18 How do they correlate? what's the best way to translate that word or how to you know I've got I still got questions I've written them down and as I'm drafting the sermon manuscript I'm adding those comments and questions to remind me to give them more attention later but at this point I'm just trying to write it out write out what I see in the text and a governing question is uh what does this passage mean for Christ the King church as I'm writing it out I'm not writing the sermon for the internet I'm writing it for the members of this church and the people who meet with this church so I'm preparing the sermon primarily to serve a meal to you. And as I draft the manuscript, I'm working as
29:52 hard as I can to be clear. I don't try to sound smart. John MacArthur was interviewed several years ago and he said this during the interview. It's very easy to be hard to understand. It only requires that you not know what you're talking about. And if you don't know what you're talking about, nobody else will either. It's very hard to be crystal clear because in order to be crystal clear, you have to have mastered the text.
30:21 That's what he said. So, it just it takes a lot of work to understand a challenging topic and then to talk about it in an understandable way. You have to work even harder to explain complicated topics in a way that's both accurate and accessible. So, that's my goal is to explain complex topics in a way that a non-expert can understand. Step step seven is when I turn to secondary literature. So this is commentaries for example that other men have written, other books, other articles. Sometimes I may even listen to other sermons or lectures on a particular passage or topic. And as I'm working through secondary resources, I'm updating the sermon manuscript, constantly tweaking it, adjusting it,
31:04 sharpening it. One advantage I have is that I'm I'm also a research professor. So I get to teach New Testament systematic theology and ethics at Bethlehem College and Seminary. And I get to not only teach but also research and write. So over the last three decades I've compiled roughly 60,000 items in my library. Uh only a thousand of those are in print. Most of them are electronic and I've organized them very carefully.
31:28 I think uh my TA and one other person on the planet has access to that and that's Nathan Koultock. Uh so for uh for example for each book of the Bible I have a lot of commentaries in the New Testament about 125 commentaries for every book for Romans for example I have 218 for 1 Corinthians 185 this is my life I just I I love this and for each chapter of the New Testament I've compiled dozens and dozens of additional resources so for first Timothy got dozens of books and articles on each of the chapters in first Timothy the literature in 1 Timothy 29-15 in particular is enormous. And for this series on 1 Timothy, as an example, as I prepared each sermon, I have consistently read what I think are the
32:12 top 35 or so commentaries in addition to other resources that are relevant for a particular passage. And I can read at different levels. Sometimes it's really slow micro reading. Often it's this macro reading or surveying where you're you're you're moving quickly. So I'm on the lookout for unans my answers to unanswered questions and for arguments I haven't considered. Step eight after I've worked through secondary literature is prepare slides to go along with the manuscript. So I do this um I think because it helps more people. Some people are just straight up audio learners. They don't need to see anything and they might even find it distracting. In my experience, an
32:54 audiovisisual presentation helps more people. And that's also why I include the sermon outline in the worship service guide. Um, my goal is that as you're listening to a sermon I'm preaching, you're never wondering where I am or what I'm trying to say. So, I want to clearly communicate and I think slides help me do that. Step nine, I solicit feedback. So, I place all my sermon manuscripts in a Google Drive folder that I share with my fellow pastors and their wives. I warmly welcome feedback. If the passage is particular particularly challenging like 1 Timothy 2 9-15, I'll share that with some other pastor teacher friends, pastor theologians. And then finally, step 10, I read the manuscript aloud at
33:34 least twice. Usually it's on the Friday before the Sunday I preach it. And then early on Sunday morning in my garage walking on a treadmill. I do that because uh I think the you can write something that's okay, but it's different than the spoken word. It might be fine on the page, but when you try to speak it, you're like, I need to rephrase that. And also, while I'm preaching to you, I'm not chained to my manuscript. Sometimes I'll I'll uh I think the Lord might bring something to mind that I I judge is worth mentioning, and I'll I'll share that. So, that's my routine for preaching and teaching. I'm I'm sharing that with you because this passage refers to pastors who work hard
34:13 at preaching and teaching. That's how I do it. You can ask Pastor Nathan what he does. He doesn't do what I do. He's got his own system. He works hard at it as well. We have different God made us differently and we we come at it differently. There's not one right way to do this. My point is whatever your method is, you need to work hard at it. God calls us in 1 Timothy 4:13 to devote ourselves to exhortation and to teaching.
34:40 2 Timothy 2:15, this is a command of pastors. do your best to present yourself to God as one approved, a worker who has no need to be ashamed, rightly handling the word of truth. So when I stand before you to preach the word of God, I'm thinking I'm going to give an account to God for this. And I want to stand before God unashamed as someone who has consistently fed you nutritious meals. I want to unleash the word of God before you so that it will reprove you and correct you and rebuke you and train you in all righteousness so you'll be equipped for every good work. That is my answer to question two.
35:22 What's the main command? It is give double honor to your elders who rule well, particularly the elders who labor in preaching and teaching. Question three. Why should a church pay its elders, particularly the ones who labor in preaching and teaching? Look at how Paul argues in verse 18. For the scripture says, "You shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain, and the laborer deserves his wages." And you notice their quotation marks around those two sentences. You shall not muzzle an octre out the grain.
36:05 What's that quoting? If you have a Bible, there'll be a footnote to tell you. Deuteronomy 25:4. And then the laborer deserves his wages. What's that quoting? Luke 10:17. It's quoting the words of Jesus. So, let's talk about that first quotation. You shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain. In Old Testament times, one way to separate the grain from the wheat in it uh from a tusk was to direct oxen to walk on wheat stocks in order to crush them. And that would separate the wheat from the chaff. So that's why some translations of of the of the first quotation of verse 18 go like this.
36:46 Don't stop an ox from eating while it helps separate the grain from the straw. That's the idea. Deuteronomy 25:4 commands that when an ox is doing that kind of work on your behalf, you must not muzzle the ox. Instead, you must allow the ox to eat some grain as it works on your behalf. Don't muzzle and starve the hardworking ox. Feed the beast. In a similar way, a church must pay a hardworking elder. Don't keep the hardworking elder poor. Be generous to him. That's the argument. And then Jesus says in Luke 10 7 uh 7, the laborer deserves his wages. It's wrong for an employer not to pay his employee when the employee has done the job. And in a
37:33 similar way, a church must pay an elder. Now, side note, this is not part of the main idea of the passage, but I'm a systematic theology professor. I can't not say this. Uh notice it says for the scripture says and then he quotes Deuteronomy and Jesus in the gospels. This is really significant for the doctrine of scripture. Uh so Paul's referring to a quotation of Jesus from the gospels as scripture. Usually that word scripture graph is referring to the old testament. So that's showing that Paul the apostle is viewing the Old Testament scripture and New Testament scripture as one scripture. That's that's significant. Okay, back to the main point. So how should a pastor think
38:15 about paying pastors and how should members think about it? So first pastors should not fleece the sheep. A pastor must not be a lover of money. Must not be greedy. A pastor should not serve a church primarily to make money. And a pastor's heart should be to glorify God by faithfully shephering the church that God has entrusted to him. Serve with contentment. That's ideal for a pastor. Now, what about a church? A the members of a church should not be stingy toward a pastor. They should support a pastor generously, cheerfully, gratefully.
38:48 That's the ideal relationship where you got a pastor and members who are thinking rightly about God's design for supporting a pastor. Finally, one last question. Should a church require that some of its elders not be paid? And the answer, I think, is no. You may recall back in March of last year, I taught about this in a members meeting. So, I'm going to review briefly what I taught then. So, we at that meeting, we shared the church's budget, which included a line item for the salary of the four pastors.
39:30 And I don't think it makes you go, "What? We're paying Pastor Andy." I don't think it surprises you. I'm I'm making approximately a half-time salary. I'm lead pastor doing most of the preaching and teaching. Nathan has a full-time salary. He's devoted himself to this work. That doesn't surprise you. What the surprising part is that there's a line item for pastors Tom and pastors pastor Dustin. And in most churches in our circles, that that doesn't happen.
39:56 What happens is you have staff pastors and volunteer pastors, lay pastors who don't get paid. So that's the issue I want to address here. What's our rationale for paying all pastors? So I'd like to show you two principles with a conclusion. And I'll make a case for this. Principle one, the New Testament teaches that a pastor deserves to be paid. Principle two, the New Testament also teaches that a pastor may choose not to accept his payment.
40:26 Conclusion. Therefore, a church should pay every pastor for his work and a pastor may choose not to accept his payment. So, I'll briefly just unpack those three statements. The first one I don't need to spend much time on because that's our passage. We just looked at it. We've already seen this principle. A pastor deserves to be paid. The second principle is a new one here. That is that the New Testament teaches that a pastor may choose not to accept his payment. So, I'm going to just really briefly show you what Paul's arguing in 1 Corinthians 9.
41:01 So, in this literary context, Paul's illustrating a principle in 1 Corinthians 8 with his own lifestyle as an example to imitate that he's given up his rights for the sake of the gospel. And he says in the first two verses here, am I not free? Am I not an apostle? Have I not seen Jesus our Lord? Are not you my workmanship in the Lord? If to others I'm not an apostle, at least I am to you, for you're seeing the seal, for you are the seal of my apostilhip. So I'll stop right there and to say he's asking rhetorical questions here uh to say I've given up my rights as an apostle and I'm free to exercise those rights, but I'm voluntarily foregoing that liberty. And then he gets
41:40 more specific. He says, "This is my defense to those who would examine me." And he asks these three questions. First, do we not have the right to eat and drink? Do we not have the right to take along a believing wife as do the other apostles and the brothers of the Lord and Cphus? Or is it only Barnabas and I who have no right to refrain from working for a living? Who serves as a soldier at his own expense? Who plants a vineyard without eating any of its fruit? Or who tends a flock without getting some of the milk? So he he's he's arguing that he he's responding to criticism from the Corinthians who are saying you're not accepting our financial support like a like a a
42:18 notable speaker should. And he's saying well I don't have to though I deserve it. And he's saying uh eating and drinking here that first question that that is a figurative way of referring to financial support. He has the right to it. Taking along a believing wife when he traveled would require additional financial support. And then that third question, receiving financial support for preaching would mean he wouldn't need to work a so-called secular job like tentmaking to support himself. And he supports that third question with with more examples. A soldier deserves to get paid. Uh a farmer deserves to eat the crop he's planted. A shepherd deserves to drink the milk from the
42:55 flocky tents. And in a similar way, Paul as a minister of the gospel has the right to receive all of his financial support from churches that he serves. He goes on and argues, "Do I say these things on human authority? Does not the law say the same? For it is written in the law of Moses, that should look familiar to you. You shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain." That's the same passage he quotes in 1 Timothy 5:18. And he says, "Is it for oxen that God is concerned?" Does he not certainly speak for our sake? It was written for our sake because the plow which plow and hope and the thresher thresh of sharing in the crop. Pause right there.
43:32 So what he's doing is supporting his argument with the divine authority of Deuteronomy 25:4 just like Paul does in 1 Timothy 5:18 by saying you shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain. And the answer to his hypothetical questions first is it for not hypothetical to his rhetorical questions. Is it for oxen that God is concerned? The answer is no. God is not concerned primarily or exclusively with oxen but with human workers. And then he says, "Does he not certainly speak for our sake?" The answer is yes. God wrote Deuteronomy 25:4 for the sake of gospel ministers like Paul because the one who plows and threshes should share in the crop. Luther quipped, "This is not
44:15 written because of the oxen since they don't know how to read." Paul may argue from the greater to the lesser. So if you should feed the hardworking ox for working, that's the lesser. you should feed the hardworking pastor for preaching and teaching the greater. But, and I think there's a a better way to take this passage, if God gave this law to Israel to establish justice for both the ox and its owner when someone borrowed or rented an ox, then what Paul is doing here is straightforwardly applying the principle from the Old Testament context. Here it is. The laborer deserves his wages.
44:52 That's the principle. And it's so interesting that in 1 Timothy 5:18, that's the next sentence that Paul quotes from Luke 10. So a negative way to state the principle is don't withhold just compensation from the one who has offered you service or labor. Paul's next line is verse 11. If we have sown spiritual things among you, is it too much if we reap material things from you? Since the one who plows or threshes has the right to share in the crop, then Paul who's who has done that spiritually. He's plowed and thrust spiritually has the right for the Corinthians to pay him. And he says in verse 12, "If others share this rightful claim on you, don't we even more?
45:32 Nevertheless, we've not made use of this right, but we enter anything rather than put an obstacle in the way of the gospel of Christ." So if if others have a right for the Corinthians to pay them, Paul says, "I have that right even more, but I'm choosing not to exercise that right. I don't want to get paid in a way that would impede or get in the way of the gospel's advance." And that was Paul's policy as a church planter. Uh and he followed that everywhere he went. Uh so he'd go into a city, he'd plant it, would not take financial support. When he left the city with a newly established church, then he would accept financial payment from them. And he would also solicit money from those
46:06 churches to help out other churches. That was his apostolic pattern. Verses 13 and 14, he argues, "Don't you know that those who are employed in the temple service get their food from the temple, and those who serve at the altar share in the sacrificial offerings? In the same way the Lord commanded that those who proclaim the gospel should get their living by the gospel. But I've made no use of any of these rights. Nor am I writing these things to secure any such provision. For I would rather die than have anyone deprive me of my ground for boasting. So he's saying in the Old Testament the priests who served at the altar they had the right to eat portions of the offerings. In a similar way Paul
46:41 has a right to earn his living from preaching the gospel as Jesus himself taught. But in spite of that, he's choosing not to exercise his right because he doesn't want to get in the way of his good kind of boasting to present the gospel free of charge. Verse 18. Okay. So the point I'm trying to establish here is this principle. The New Testament teaches that a pastor may choose not to accept his payment. That's a clear principle from 1 Corinthians 9.
47:08 So you put that together with the principle that a pastor deserves to be paid. That leads to this inevitable conclusion. A church should pay every pastor for his work and a pastor may choose not to accept his payment. So when a church sets it up so that some pastors get paid and some do not get paid, they refuse to pay them at all, I think that's wrong because the church is failing to pay a pastor what he deserves and the church is deciding not to pay a pastor rather than letting each pastor choose not to accept the payment. So for pastors who serve our church in a more part-time way, we have budgeted a more part-time salary. What we've budgeted for pastors Tom and Dustin is quite low
47:55 for the nature and the volume and the quality of the work that they're doing. I calculated that given how much work that they're putting in, what we are paying them is slightly more than what an entrylevel Chick-fil-A worker makes per hour. In other words, the number is far too low. It's likely that pastors Tom and Dustin will choose not to receive their payments from our church. But I think we should include a line item for them and let them make that decision as a matter of principle. That is their choice, not ours whether we pay them. It's likely that they will choose not to accept that. But I want to lay down a a pattern here, a custom for our church because later on we may add more
48:41 pastors to our church who are in the same position they are, but they could really use that financial payment. And we don't want them to feel pressure. Oh, well, it's it's a line item, but we actually don't receive it. We want them to feel fully free to receive it without a pressure of, oh, I can't receive it. So, we're not going to publicly announce what pastors Nathan, excuse me, what pastors Tom and Dustin do with that, but they are free not to accept it. We're going to assume that all our pastors are being paid and each pastor is free to decline his payment.
49:16 Okay, we made it. I'd like to conclude with two brief exhortations about this passage. Number one, if you are financially supporting Christ the King Church regularly, cheerfully, and generously, then continue that good work. So, I'm saying this in the spirit of Paul in 1 Thessalonians 5. Encourage one another, build one another up just as you are doing. So, he's exhorting them to just keep on doing the good work you're doing. In a similar way, I exhort you, church, keep on doing the good work you're doing in giving. I'm I'm assuming that you're doing that. I don't know what our church members give. I assume that most of you are giving regularly, cheerfully, generously. And for that, I
50:01 and the other pastors say thank you. Thank you. So, brothers and sisters, one of the most strategic ways that you can serve our church is by working hard, making a lot of money, investing some of that money in our church. That's a tangible way to contribute to our church's mission to make disciples who glorify God and all of life for all is still water. And the second exhortation, if you are not financially supporting Christ the King Church regularly, cheerfully, and generously, please do.
50:33 And my motive for saying that is not greed. I'm saying this because this is what God says to do. If this is your church, supporting your church is your joyful responsibility. Let's pray. Thank you, Father, for giving gifts to your church, including the gift of elders or pastors to teach and exercise authority. Would you please enable our church to obey your command to teach and to exercise authority? Well, would you please enable us to uh I think I think I said that wrong. Enable our pastors to teach and exercise authority. Well, enable our members to generously support our pastors who are doing that good work. Help us do that regularly,
51:22 cheerfully, generously. And we ask in the name of Christ the King. Amen. Amen.
No transcript available.
